On May 3, 2005, Pearson delivered a pair of gray pants to a local dry cleaning establishment in Washington, D.C. called Custom Cleaners, operated by Jin, Soo, and Ki Chung. When the pants were returned to him several days later, Pearson insisted that the pants he was presented with were not the pants he initially dropped off, and accused the Chungs of losing his pants. Pearson demanded to be compensated $1,000 by the Chungs, which Pearson claimed the pants to be worth, but the Chungs refused. In response, Pearson filed suit against the Chungs for inconvenience and mental distress, initially requesting $67 million in damages, though later reduced the amount to $54 million.
The case went to trial on June 12, 2007. Representing himself pro se during the proceedings, Pearson argued that the Chungs had failed to fulfill the "Same Day Service" and "Satisfaction Guaranteed" promises posted outside their business. The Chungs argued that the signs could only be considered fraud if a reasonable person could be misled by them. Pearson lost the case and subsequent appeal. The Chungs made a motion to recover their legal fees, but withdrew it following the conclusion of a successful fundraising campaign.
On May 3, 2005, Pearson delivered a pair of gray pants to a dry cleaning establishment in Washington, D.C. called Custom Cleaners to be altered.[nb 1] The establishment was owned collectively by Jin and Soo Chung, a married couple, and their son Ki Chung, all of whom had immigrated from South Korea and did not speak fluent English.[2] The pants that Pearson delivered belonged to a blue and maroon suit that he owned,[3] and were described by him as being gray with "blue and red stripes on them".[1] Pearson requested his pants be ready for pickup two days later on May 5, which Soo Chung, who took his order, agreed to.[2]
When Pearson returned on May 5 to pick up his pants, Soo Chung informed him that his pants were not ready and had been sent to another store they owned by mistake.[4] Soo Chung promised to have them ready the following morning, but when Pearson returned on May 6, the pants "still had not been located".[4] Soo Chung asked Pearson to return the following day. Pearson returned the next morning on May 7, where the Chungs presented him with a pair of charcoal gray pants.[5] Pearson insisted that the pants were not his, contrary to the dry cleaner's records, tags, and his receipt, and refused to accept them. Pearson demanded what he claimed to be the price of the pants as compensation, an amount of over $1,000, which the Chungs refused. As a result, Pearson filed suit in the District of Columbia's Superior Court. The judge to whom the case was presented decided to bring it to trial on the basis of two of Pearson's claims. The first claim was the issue of the ownership by Pearson of the presented pair of pants. The second claim was on the issue of signs posted outside the business, advertising "Same Day Service" and "Satisfaction Guaranteed", which Pearson claimed to be misleading.[6]
The Chungs were reportedly considering moving back to South Korea.[7] After an outpouring of support for the Chungs from members of the public, a website was set up to accept donations for the Chungs' legal defense.[8] Over time, the Chungs presented three settlement offers in the amounts of $3,000, $4,600, and $12,000—all of which were rejected by Pearson. D.C. Superior Court Judge Neal Kravitz stated that "the court has significant concerns that the plaintiff is acting in bad faith". The judge resolved some of the issues in the Chungs' favor in response to their motion for summary judgment (which was filed at the close of discovery), but could not dismiss the case because some facts were in dispute.
On May 30, 2007, Pearson reduced his demands to $54 million in damages rather than $67 million. Among his requests were $500,000 in attorney's fees, $2 million for "discomfort, inconvenience, and mental distress", and $15,000 which he claimed would be the cost to rent a car every weekend to drive to another dry cleaning service. The remaining $51.5 million would be used to help similarly dissatisfied D.C. consumers sue businesses.[9][10] Pearson also re-focused his lawsuit from the missing pants to the removal of window signs for "Satisfaction Guaranteed" and "Same Day Service". Pearson claimed the signs represented fraud on the part of the Chungs. The Chungs' lawyer, Christopher Manning, alleged that the signs could only be considered fraud if a reasonable person would be misled by them, and that a reasonable person would not see the signs as an unconditional promise.[11] The Chungs' lawyer portrayed Pearson as a bitter, financially insolvent man; under questioning, Pearson admitted that, at the start of the court case, he had only $1000–2000 in the bank due to divorce proceedings, and was collecting unemployment benefits.[12]
Trial
The trial heard opening arguments on June 12, 2007, with Pearson representing himself pro se and the Chungs being represented by attorney Chris Manning.[13] The trial drew a "standing-room-only" crowd.[14] Pearson broke down in tears during an explanation about his frustration after losing his pants,[15] and a short recess had to be declared.[16][17]
Decision
On June 25, 2007, the trial ended with District of Columbia Superior Court Judge Judith Bartnoff ruling in favor of the dry cleaners, and awarding them court costs pursuant to a motion which the Chungs later withdrew.[18] The court took judicial notice of Pearson's divorce proceedings, where he was sanctioned $12,000 by the trial court for "creating unnecessary litigation and threatening both his wife and her lawyer with disbarment".[19][20]
Post-trial motions and appeal
Pearson made a motion on July 11, 2007, to reconsider in the trial court, stating that he felt the judge had "committed a fundamental legal error", and had failed to address his legal claims.[21] Pearson stated he believed the court had imposed its own conditional interpretation of "satisfaction guaranteed", rather than what Pearson believes is an offer of unconditional and unambiguous satisfaction. The court denied the motion.[22]
It was revealed on August 2, 2007, that a panel recommended Pearson not be given a ten-year term as an administrative law judge after his initial two-year term expired mid-2007, in part because his suit against Mr. Chung demonstrated a lack of "judicial temperament". Pearson was appointed in 2005 and stood to lose his $100,512 salary if a hearing upheld that decision.[23] On October 22, a D.C. commission voted against reappointing Pearson to the bench of the Office of Administrative Hearings.[24] On November 14, it was confirmed that Pearson had lost his job by not being affirmed for an extension.[25]
Roy Pearson filed suit against Washington, D.C., on May 2, 2008, claiming that he had been wrongfully dismissed for exposing corruption within the Office of Administrative Hearings. Pearson sought $1 million in compensation for lost wages and punitive damages as well as his job back.[26] On July 23, 2009, federal district judge Ellen Segal Huvelle dismissed Pearson's May 2008 lawsuit, ruling the District of Columbia had not broken the law by declining to reappoint him as an administrative law judge. Pearson had maintained in the suit that the failure to reappoint him to the ten-year term was in part intended as retaliation for his suit against the dry cleaners.[27] Pearson lost his appeal when the D.C. Circuit ruled against him on May 27, 2010.[28]
The Chungs moved to recover $83,000 in attorneys' fees and to impose sanctions, but withdrew the motion after recovering their costs through fund-raising. The Chungs stated that they did so in the hopes of persuading Pearson to stop litigating,[29] but on August 14, 2007, Pearson filed a notice of appeal.[29]
On September 10, 2008, Pearson filed an appeal to the District of Columbia Court of Appeals, where oral argument was held on October 22, 2008, before a three-judge panel consisting of judges Phyllis Thompson, Noel Anketell Kramer and Michael W. Farrell.[30][31] Manning represented the Chungs on the appeal pro bono,[32] and Pearson represented himself pro se.[31] On December 18, 2008, the panel that heard Pearson's appeal announced that they were rejecting it. According to The Washington Post, "Pearson has two remaining avenues of appeal left: He could ask the entire nine-judge appellate court to review the case, or ask the U.S. Supreme Court to weigh in."[30] On January 6, 2009, Pearson filed a petition with the D.C. Court of Appeals, requesting the case be reheard en banc by the full nine-judge court.[33][34] On March 2, 2009, the appeals court denied the petition.[34] Pearson's final option was to ask the U.S. Supreme Court to hear the case.[34][35] The 90-day deadline for seeking Supreme Court review elapsed without Pearson filing a petition for certiorari, bringing the dispute to an end.
Disciplinary action
DC Board of Professional Responsibility issued a 90-day suspension from legal practice against Pearson for engaging in frivolous litigation and thereby interfering with the administration of justice. The District of Columbia Court of Appeals upheld the suspension in June 2020, observing that Pearson had continued his intransigent behavior even during the misconduct proceedings. Pearson retained his DC bar membership.[36]
Cultural impact
The unusual circumstances of this case led The Wall Street Journal, The Washington Post, and dozens of bloggers to refer to it as "The Great American Pants Suit",[37][38] and to Pearson as "Judge Fancy Pants".[39][40] Pearson was named #4 in the list of the Overall Stella Awards Winners by the True Stella Awards,[41] after being the Stella Awards winner for the year 2007.[42] The case has garnered considerable international attention. BBC News quoted Chris Manning, attorney for the Chung family, as saying that the experience for the Chungs has become the "American nightmare"—an ironic reference to the American Dream.[43]Fortune magazine listed the case at #37 in its "101 Dumbest Moments in Business" of 2007.[44]Cracked.com listed the case as "Exhibit 1" in its 2008 article "9 Insane Cases that Prove the US Legal System Is Screwed".[45]
On September 19, 2007, citing a loss of revenue and emotional strain from the lawsuit, the Chungs announced they had closed and sold the dry cleaning shop involved in the dispute. They still owned another dry cleaning shop and said they would be focusing their attention and resources on that.[47]
^Pearson owned five Hickey Freeman suits, all of which he needed altered because they no longer fit him.[1] Throughout the month of April 2005, Pearson brought three pairs of suit pants to Custom Cleaners, as well as a pair of gray slacks that did not belong to a suit. Disregarding the pants at the center of the case, Pearson's other clothes that he delivered to Custom Cleaners were returned without incident.[2]
Breakthru'Album studio karya NidjiDirilis1 September 2006 1 Juli 2007 (Versi Bahasa Inggris) 2 Januari 2016 (Versi Piringan Hitam)GenreRock, Britpop, Alternative rock, Pop rockLabelMusica Studio'sProduserNoeyKronologi Nidji Breakthru' (2006) Breakthru' English Version (2007) Top Up (2007)Top Up2007 Cover versi Bahasa Inggris Cover versi Bahasa Inggris Breakthru' adalah album musik pertama karya Nidji. Dirilis tahun 2006 yang berisi 10 buah lagu dengan hits singel lagu Sudah, Hapus Aku, Bila …
伊斯兰合作组织Organisation of Islamic Cooperation(英語)Organisation de la Coopération Islamique(法語)منظمة التعاون الإسلامي(阿拉伯語) 旗帜格言:To safeguard the interests and ensure the progress and well-being of Muslims 成员国 观察国 暂停会籍行政总部 沙地阿拉伯吉达 官方语言阿拉伯语英语法语类型宗教成员国57个在籍成员国(英语:Member states of the Organisation of …
There are many instances in popular culture in which fictional underground stations appear. In many cases for film or television, actual stations are used for the purpose of filming. This transport-related list is incomplete; you can help by adding missing items. (August 2008) Fictional London Underground stations See also: List of former and unopened London Underground stations, List of London Underground-related fiction, and West Ashfield tube station Many London Underground settings in film h…
Spanish football manager, head coach and sporting director In this Spanish name, the first or paternal surname is Martínez and the second or maternal family name is Losa. Pedro Martínez Losa Personal informationDate of birth (1976-05-09) 9 May 1976 (age 48)Place of birth Madrid, SpainTeam informationCurrent team Scotland womenManagerial careerYears Team2007–2008 Pozuelo Alarcón women2008–2012 Rayo Vallecano Femenino2012–2014 Western New York Flash (assistant)2014–2017 Ars…
Clarinet Trioby Johannes BrahmsThe composer in 1889KeyA minorOpus114Composed1891 (1891)Performed12 December 1891 (1891-12-12): Hall of the Sing-Akademie zu BerlinPublished1892 (1892)Movements4 The Clarinet Trio in A minor, Op. 114, is one of four chamber works composed by Johannes Brahms featuring the clarinet as a primary instrument. It was written in the summer of 1891 in Bad Ischl for the clarinettist Richard Mühlfeld and first performed privately on 24 November…
Dutch high-speed railway HSL-ZuidRoute of the HSL-ZuidOverviewOwnerProRailLocaleNorth Holland, South Holland and North Brabant, NetherlandsServiceOperator(s)Nederlandse SpoorwegenNS InternationalThalysEurostarHistoryOpened7 September 2009TechnicalLine length125 km (78 mi)Track gauge1,435 mm (4 ft 8+1⁄2 in) standard gaugeElectrification25 kV 50 Hz AC overheadOperating speed300 km/h (190 mph)SignallingETCS Level 2, ETCS Level 1…
Students in Uganda. The system of education in Uganda has a structure of 7 years of primary education, 6 years of secondary education (divided into 4 years of lower secondary and 2 years of upper secondary school), and 3 to 5 years of post-secondary education.[1] Education in Uganda is administered in English. All throughout the levels in the education structure, modules are taught and assessed in English. The government of Uganda recognizes education as a basic human right and continues…
Second Samoan Civil WarMap featuring the locations of battles in which British and U.S. forces fought.Date1898–1899LocationApia, Upolu, Samoa, Pacific OceanResult Compromise; Tripartite Convention Partitioning of the Samoan archipelago United States acquires American Samoa Germany acquires German Samoa Britain withdraws claim in exchange for concessions in the Solomon Islands Mata'afa Iosefo becomes paramount chief of SamoaBelligerents Allies: Samoa United States United Kingdom Mataa…
Politics of a U.S. territory Politics of Puerto Rico Constitution and law United States Constitution Puerto Rico Constitution Puerto Rico law Executive Governor Cabinet Chief of Staff Executive departments Fiscal agent and financing Government-owned corporations Line of succession Office of the Governor Transition process First Lady Legislative Legislature: 17th Legislative Assembly of Puerto Rico Senate: 26th Senate of Puerto Rico President of the Senate: Thomas Rivera Schatz President pro temp…
In ecology, an ideal free distribution (IFD) is a theoretical way in which a population's individuals distribute themselves among several patches of resources within their environment, in order to minimize resource competition and maximize fitness.[1][2] The theory states that the number of individual animals that will aggregate in various patches is proportional to the amount of resources available in each. For example, if patch A contains twice as many resources as patch B,…
Zona libera da armi nucleari Stati con armi nucleari (Russia, USA, Francia, Cina, Regno Unito, Israele, Pakistan, India, Corea del Nord) Condivisione nucleare (Belgio, Germania, Italia, Paesi Bassi, Turchia e Bielorussia) Non condivisione, ma adesione al TNP Ispezione di un sistema di stoccaggio di armi nucleari degli Stati Uniti nella Volkel Air Base nei Paesi Bassi. Un F-16 d…
Formaldehida Nama Nama IUPAC Metanal Nama lain formol, metil aldehida, oksida metilena Penanda Nomor CAS 50-00-0 Model 3D (JSmol) Gambar interaktif 3DMet {{{3DMet}}} Nomor EC Nomor RTECS {{{value}}} CompTox Dashboard (EPA) DTXSID7020637 SMILES C=O Sifat Rumus kimia CH2O Massa molar 30,03 g·mol−1 Penampilan gas tak berwarna Densitas 1 kg·m−3, gas Titik lebur -117 °C (156 K) Titik didih -19,3 °C (253,9 K) Kelarutan dalam air >…
Italian cyclist (1919–1960) Fausto CoppiCoppi at the 1952 Tour de FrancePersonal informationFull nameAngelo Fausto CoppiNicknameThe HeronIl Campionissimo(Champion of Champions)Born(1919-09-15)15 September 1919Castellania, ItalyDied2 January 1960(1960-01-02) (aged 40)Tortona, ItalyHeight1.77 m (5 ft 9+1⁄2 in)Weight68 kg (150 lb; 10 st 10 lb)Team informationDisciplineRoad and trackRoleRiderRider typeAll-rounderProfessional teams1938–1939D…
ASD Antonio Toma MaglieCalcio Segni distintiviUniformi di gara Casa Trasferta Colori sociali Giallo, rosso SimboliTre anelli, passerotto InnoPasserotti all'ertaPiero Tisè - Aldo Presicce Dati societariCittàMaglie Nazione Italia ConfederazioneUEFA Federazione LND CampionatoPromozione Fondazione1944 Presidente Paola Vella Allenatore Gigi Bruno StadioAntonio Tamborino Frisari(2 500 posti) Sito webwww.tomamaglie.it PalmarèsTitoli nazionali1 campionato di Serie C Si invita a seguire il m…
مايك موجيس معلومات شخصية الميلاد 16 مايو 1974 (العمر 50 سنة)نورث بلات، نبراسكا مواطنة الولايات المتحدة الحياة العملية المهنة منتج أسطوانات، وملحن، وعازف قيثارة المواقع IMDB صفحته على IMDB تعديل مصدري - تعديل مايك موجيس (Mike Mogis) هو منتج ومهندس صوتي وعضو في فرقة برا…
Lennart Nilsson Lennart Nilsson 2014.FödelsenamnLars Olof Lennart NilssonFödd24 augusti 1922SträngnäsDöd28 januari 2017 (94 år)StockholmBegravningsplatsNorra begravningsplatsen[1]kartorKonstnärskapFältFotografiVerkBoken Ett barn blir till och filmen Sagan om livet.PriserHasselbladpriset, KTH:s stora pris, Natur & Kulturs Kulturpris, KunskapsprisetRedigera Wikidata (för vissa parametrar) Lennart Nilsson på väg till nyöppnade Fotografiska i Stockholm, 21 maj 2010. Lars Olof Le…
Vous lisez un « article de qualité » labellisé en 2010. Pour les articles homonymes, voir Vampire (homonymie). Vampire The Vampire, tableau disparu de Philip Burne-Jones, 1897. Créature Sous-groupe Mort-vivant Proches Nukekubi, Pontianak, Vrykolakas, Latawiec, Dhampire, Asanbosam, Libishomen (pour les mâles), Succube (pour les femelles)… Origines Origines diverses (morsure par un vampire, magie noire, malédiction, pacte avec le diable ...) modifier - modifier le code - voir Wi…