Originally, fallibilism (from Medieval Latin: fallibilis, "liable to error") is the philosophical principle that propositions can be accepted even though they cannot be conclusively proven or justified,[1][2] or that neither knowledge nor belief is certain.[3] The term was coined in the late nineteenth century by the American philosopher Charles Sanders Peirce, as a response to foundationalism. Theorists, following Austrian-British philosopher Karl Popper, may also refer to fallibilism as the notion that knowledge might turn out to be false.[4] Furthermore, fallibilism is said to imply corrigibilism, the principle that propositions are open to revision.[5] Fallibilism is often juxtaposed with infallibilism.
Infinite regress and infinite progress
According to philosopher Scott F. Aikin, fallibilism cannot properly function in the absence of infinite regress.[6] The term, usually attributed to Pyrrhonist philosopher Agrippa, is argued to be the inevitable outcome of all human inquiry, since every proposition requires justification.[7] Infinite regress, also represented within the regress argument, is closely related to the problem of the criterion and is a constituent of the Münchhausen trilemma. Illustrious examples regarding infinite regress are the cosmological argument, turtles all the way down, and the simulation hypothesis. Many philosophers struggle with the metaphysical implications that come along with infinite regress. For this reason, philosophers have gotten creative in their quest to circumvent it.
Somewhere along the seventeenth century, English philosopher Thomas Hobbes set forth the concept of "infinite progress". With this term, Hobbes had captured the human proclivity to strive for perfection.[8] Philosophers like Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Christian Wolff, and Immanuel Kant, would elaborate further on the concept. Kant even went on to speculate that immortal species should hypothetically be able to develop their capacities to perfection.[9]
Already in 350 B.C.E, Greek philosopher Aristotle made a distinction between potential and actual infinities. Based on his discourse, it can be said that actual infinities do not exist, because they are paradoxical. Aristotle deemed it impossible for humans to keep on adding members to finite sets indefinitely. It eventually led him to refute some of Zeno's paradoxes.[10] Other relevant examples of potential infinities include Galileo's paradox and the paradox of Hilbert's hotel. The notion that infinite regress and infinite progress only manifest themselves potentially pertains to fallibilism. According to philosophy professor Elizabeth F. Cooke, fallibilism embraces uncertainty, and infinite regress and infinite progress are not unfortunate limitations on human cognition, but rather necessary antecedents for knowledge acquisition. They allow us to live functional and meaningful lives.[11]
In the mid-twentieth century, several important philosophers began to critique the foundations of logical positivism. In his work The Logic of Scientific Discovery (1934), Karl Popper, the founder of critical rationalism, argued that scientific knowledge grows from falsifying conjectures rather than any inductive principle and that falsifiability is the criterion of a scientific proposition. The claim that all assertions are provisional and thus open to revision in light of new evidence is widely taken for granted in the natural sciences.[12]
Furthermore, Popper defended his critical rationalism as a normative and methodological theory, that explains how objective, and thus mind-independent, knowledge ought to work.[13] Hungarian philosopher Imre Lakatos built upon the theory by rephrasing the problem of demarcation as the problem of normative appraisal. Lakatos' and Popper's aims were alike, that is finding rules that could justify falsifications. However, Lakatos pointed out that critical rationalism only shows how theories can be falsified, but it omits how our belief in critical rationalism can itself be justified. The belief would require an inductively verified principle.[14] When Lakatos urged Popper to admit that the falsification principle cannot be justified without embracing induction, Popper did not succumb.[15] Lakatos' critical attitude towards rationalism has become emblematic for his so called critical fallibilism.[16][17] While critical fallibilism strictly opposes dogmatism, critical rationalism is said to require a limited amount of dogmatism.[18][19] Though, even Lakatos himself had been a critical rationalist in the past, when he took it upon himself to argue against the inductivist illusion that axioms can be justified by the truth of their consequences.[16] In summary, despite Lakatos and Popper picking one stance over the other, both have oscillated between holding a critical attitude towards rationalism as well as fallibilism.[15][17][18][20]
Fallibilism has also been employed by philosopher Willard V. O. Quine to attack, among other things, the distinction between analytic and synthetic statements.[21] British philosopher Susan Haack, following Quine, has argued that the nature of fallibilism is often misunderstood, because people tend to confuse fallible propositions with fallible agents. She claims that logic is revisable, which means that analyticity does not exist and necessity (or a priority) does not extend to logical truths. She hereby opposes the conviction that propositions in logic are infallible, while agents can be fallible.[22] Critical rationalist Hans Albert argues that it is impossible to prove any truth with certainty, not only in logic, but also in mathematics.[23]
Mathematical fallibilism
In Proofs and Refutations: The Logic of Mathematical Discovery (1976), philosopher Imre Lakatos implemented mathematical proofs into what he called Popperian "critical fallibilism".[24] Lakatos's mathematical fallibilism is the general view that all mathematical theorems are falsifiable.[25] Mathematical fallibilism deviates from traditional views held by philosophers like Hegel, Peirce, and Popper.[16][25] Although Peirce introduced fallibilism, he seems to preclude the possibility of us being mistaken in our mathematical beliefs.[2] Mathematical fallibilism appears to uphold that even though a mathematical conjecture cannot be proven true, we may consider some to be good approximations or estimations of the truth. This so called verisimilitude may provide us with consistency amidst an inherent incompleteness in mathematics.[26] Mathematical fallibilism differs from quasi-empiricism, to the extent that the latter does not incorporate inductivism, a feature considered to be of vital importance to the foundations of set theory.[27]
In the philosophy of mathematics, a central tenet of fallibilism is undecidability (which bears resemblance to the notion of isostheneia, or "equal veracity").[25] Two distinct types of the word "undecidable" are currently being applied. The first one relates, most notably, to the continuum hypothesis, which was proposed by mathematician Georg Cantor in 1873.[28][29] The continuum hypothesis represents a tendency for infinite sets to allow for undecidable solutions — solutions which are true in one constructible universe and false in another. Both solutions are independent from the axioms in Zermelo–Fraenkel set theory combined with the axiom of choice (also called ZFC). This phenomenon has been labeled the independence of the continuum hypothesis.[30] Both the hypothesis and its negation are thought to be consistent with the axioms of ZFC.[31] Many noteworthy discoveries have preceded the establishment of the continuum hypothesis.
In 1877, Cantor introduced the diagonal argument to prove that the cardinality of two finite sets is equal, by putting them into a one-to-one correspondence.[32] Diagonalization reappeared in Cantors theorem, in 1891, to show that the power set of any countable set must have strictly higher cardinality.[33] The existence of the power set was postulated in the axiom of power set; a vital part of Zermelo–Fraenkel set theory. Moreover, in 1899, Cantor's paradox was discovered. It postulates that there is no set of all cardinalities.[33] Two years later, polymathBertrand Russell would invalidate the existence of the universal set by pointing towards Russell's paradox, which implies that no set can contain itself as an element (or member). The universal set can be confuted by utilizing either the axiom schema of separation or the axiom of regularity.[34] In contrast to the universal set, a power set does not contain itself. It was only after 1940 that mathematician Kurt Gödel showed, by applying inter alia the diagonal lemma, that the continuum hypothesis cannot be refuted,[28] and after 1963, that fellow mathematician Paul Cohen revealed, through the method of forcing, that the continuum hypothesis cannot be proved either.[30] In spite of the undecidability, both Gödel and Cohen suspected dependence of the continuum hypothesis to be false. This sense of suspicion, in conjunction with a firm belief in the consistency of ZFC, is in line with mathematical fallibilism.[35] Mathematical fallibilists suppose that new axioms, for example the axiom of projective determinacy, might improve ZFC, but that these axioms will not allow for dependence of the continuum hypothesis.[36]
Undecidability and uncertainty are not one and the same phenomenon. Mathematical theorems which can be formally proved, will, according to mathematical fallibilists, nevertheless remain inconclusive.[40] Take for example proof of the independence of the continuum hypothesis or, even more fundamentally, proof of the diagonal argument. In the end, both types of undecidability add further nuance to fallibilism, by providing these fundamental thought-experiments.[41]
Fallibilism should not be confused with local or global skepticism, which is the view that some or all types of knowledge are unattainable.
But the fallibility of our knowledge — or the thesis that all knowledge is guesswork, though some consists of guesses which have been most severely tested — must not be cited in support of scepticism or relativism. From the fact that we can err, and that a criterion of truth which might save us from error does not exist, it does not follow that the choice between theories is arbitrary, or non-rational: that we cannot learn, or get nearer to the truth: that our knowledge cannot grow.
— Karl Popper
Fallibilism claims that legitimate epistemic justifications can lead to false beliefs, whereas academic skepticism claims that no legitimate epistemic justifications exist (acatalepsy). Fallibilism is also different to epoché, a suspension of judgement, often accredited to Pyrrhonian skepticism.
Criticism
Nearly all philosophers today are fallibilists in some sense of the term.[3] Few would claim that knowledge requires absolute certainty, or deny that scientific claims are revisable, though in the 21st century some philosophers have argued for some version of infallibilist knowledge.[42][43][44] Historically, many Western philosophers from Plato to Saint Augustine to René Descartes have argued that some human beliefs are infallibly known. John Calvin espoused a theological fallibilism towards others beliefs.[45][46] Plausible candidates for infallible beliefs include logical truths ("Either Jones is a Democrat or Jones is not a Democrat"), immediate appearances ("It seems that I see a patch of blue"), and incorrigible beliefs (i.e., beliefs that are true in virtue of being believed, such as Descartes' "I think, therefore I am"). Many others, however, have taken even these types of beliefs to be fallible.[22]
^Thornton, Stephen (2022). Karl Popper. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
^Forrai, Gábor (2002). Lakatos, Reason and History. p. 6–7. In Kampis, George; Kvasz, Ladislav & Stöltzner, Michael (2002). Appraising Lakatos: Mathematics, Methodology, and the Man. Vienna Circle Institute Library. Vol. 1.
^Kockelmans, Joseph J. Reflections on Lakatos’ Methodology of Scientific Research Programs. Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science. Vol. 59. pp. 187–203. In Radnitzky, Gerard & Andersson, Gunnar. The Structure and Development of Science. D. Reidel Publishing Company.
^Lakatos, Imre (1962). "Infinite Regress and Foundations of Mathematics (in Symposium: The Foundations of Mathematics)". Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volumes. 36: 145–184 (165). JSTOR4106691. Popperian critical fallibilism takes the infinite regress in proofs and definitions seriously, does not have illusions about 'stopping' them, accepts the sceptic criticism of any infallible truth-injection. However, Lakatos' interpretation of Popper was not equivalent to Popper's philosophy: Ravn, Ole; Skovsmose, Ole (2019). "Mathematics as Dialogue". Connecting Humans to Equations: A Reinterpretation of the Philosophy of Mathematics. History of Mathematics Education. Cham: Springer-Verlag. pp. 107–119 (110). doi:10.1007/978-3-030-01337-0_8. ISBN9783030013363. S2CID127561458. Lakatos also refers to the scepticist programme as a 'Popperian critical fallibilism.' However, we find that this labelling could be a bit misleading as the programme includes a good deal of Lakatos' own philosophy.
Artikel ini sebatang kara, artinya tidak ada artikel lain yang memiliki pranala balik ke halaman ini.Bantulah menambah pranala ke artikel ini dari artikel yang berhubungan atau coba peralatan pencari pranala.Tag ini diberikan pada Februari 2023. Meskipun serangan beruang terbilang langka, serangan tersebut dapat menjadi fatal. Serangan beruang adalah sebuah serangan oleh seekor beruang terhadap hewan lain, meskipun biasanya berujuk kepada seekor beruang yang menyerang manusia atau hewan domestik…
Artikel ini bukan mengenai Kekaisaran Tiongkok. Kekaisaran Tiongkok中華帝國Zhōnghuá Dìguó1915–1916 Bendera Lambang nasional Dua Belas Simbol Lagu kebangsaan: Zhōngguó xióng lì yǔzhòujiān《中國雄立宇宙間》Ibu kotaBeijing39°54′N 116°23′E / 39.900°N 116.383°E / 39.900; 116.383Koordinat: 39°54′N 116°23′E / 39.900°N 116.383°E / 39.900; 116.383Bahasa yang umum digunakanTionghoaAgama Pemujaan surgawiPeme…
Masjid Baiturrahman Banda Acehمسجد بيت الرحمن في باندا آتشيهAgamaAfiliasiIslam – SunniProvinsi AcehLokasiLokasiBanda AcehNegara IndonesiaArsitekturArsitekGerrit BruinsTipeMasjidGaya arsitekturTimur Tengah dengan sedikit sentuhan arsitektur MughalDidirikan1612 dan 1879SpesifikasiKapasitas30.000 JemaahKubah7[1]Menara8 Masjid Baiturrahman Banda Aceh (bahasa Arab: مسجد بيت الرحمن في باندا آتشيه) (bahasa Aceh: Meuseujid Bayturrahma…
Dune nel deserto di La Guajira Il deserto di La Guajira è situato nella parte più settentrionale della Colombia, circa 1100 km a nord di Bogotà, nel Dipartimento di La Guajira, che comprende la maggior parte della Penisola della Guajira e anche parte del territorio del Venezuela. La regione contiene enormi riserve di carbone, sfruttate nella zona di El Cerrejon. L'area è anche la terra nativa degli indigeni Wayuu, un gruppo etnico dedito prevalentemente alla pastorizia. I Wayuu sono anc…
Hybrid rail service in Denton County, Texas A-trainA-train diesel multiple unit train at the Downtown Denton Transit CenterOverviewOwnerDenton County Transportation AuthorityLocaleDenton County, TexasTerminiDowntown Denton Transit CenterTrinity Mills stationStations6Websitedcta.net/a-trainServiceTypeHybrid railSystemDenton County Transportation Authority (DCTA)Operator(s)Rio Grande Pacific (operations)Stadler US (rolling stock maintenance)[1]Rolling stock11 Stadler GTW 2/6Daily ridership…
Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento società contiene errori ortografici o sintattici oppure è scritta in una forma migliorabile. Contribuisci a correggerla secondo le convenzioni della lingua italiana e del manuale di stile di Wikipedia. Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento società è ritenuta da controllare. Motivo: La generale carenza di fonti su talune affermazioni specifiche solleva dubbi sull'attendibilità del contenuto. Si veda la pagina di discussione Partecipa alla discuss…
This article is about one of the United States military reserve forces. For other countries that have a National Guard, see National Guard. For other United States military reserves, see Reserve components of the United States Armed Forces. For the general idea of militas in the United States, see Militia (United States). National GuardSealActiveEnglish colonial militia: since December 13, 1636 As National Guard: since 1824 in New York, since 1903 nationwide Dual state-federal reserve forces: si…
Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento politici statunitensi non cita le fonti necessarie o quelle presenti sono insufficienti. Puoi migliorare questa voce aggiungendo citazioni da fonti attendibili secondo le linee guida sull'uso delle fonti. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. Hiram Fong Senatore, HawaiiDurata mandato21 agosto 1959 - 3 gennaio 1977 PredecessoreCarica di nuova creazione SuccessoreSpark Matsunaga Dati generaliPartito politicoRepubblicano Hiram Leong Fo…
American actor Frederick CombsBornGeorge Frederick Combs, Jr.(1935-10-11)October 11, 1935Portsmouth, Virginia, United StatesDiedSeptember 19, 1992(1992-09-19) (aged 56)Los Angeles, California, United StatesOccupation(s)Actor, playwright, director Frederick Combs (October 11, 1935 – September 19, 1992) was an American film, theater and television actor, playwright and director.[1] Combs is best known for originating the role of Donald in the play The Boys in the Band and then …
1976 U.S. Senate Democratic primary in Mississippi ← 1970 June 1, 1976 1982 → Nominee John C. Stennis E. Michael Marks Party Democratic Democratic Popular vote 157,943 27,016 Percentage 85.39% 14.61% U.S. senator before election John C. Stennis Democratic Elected U.S. Senator John C. Stennis Democratic Elections in Mississippi Federal government U.S. President 1820 1824 1828 1832 1836 1840 1844 1848 1852 1856 1860 1872 1876 1880 1884 1888 1892 1896 1900 1904 190…
British political initiative The Citizen's Charter was a British political initiative launched by the then prime minister, John Major, on 22 July 1991, less than a year into his premiership.[1] Aims It aimed to improve public services in the UK by:[1] Making administration accountable and more user-focused. Ensuring transparency and the right to information in an open and easy to understand manner. Taking measures to improve performance in the civil service. Adopting a stakeholde…
Island off the coast of Alaska, United States KodiakNickname: Emerald Isle[1]KodiakGeographyLocationPacific OceanCoordinates57°28′N 153°26′W / 57.467°N 153.433°W / 57.467; -153.433ArchipelagoKodiak ArchipelagoTotal islands25Area3,595.09 sq mi (9,311.2 km2)Highest elevation4,469 ft (1362.2 m)Highest pointKoniag PeakAdministrationUnited StatesStateAlaskaBoroughKodiak IslandLargest settlementKodiak (pop. 5,581)Demog…
Figure in the mythology of the Nation of Islam For the prophet of Islam, see Jacob in Islam.For other people with the same name, see Yakub. Depiction of Yakub from Malachi Z. York's Holy Tablets, 1993 Part of a series on theNation of Islam Influencers Satokata Takahashi Noble Drew Ali Leaders Wallace Fard Muhammad Elijah Muhammad Malcolm X Warith Deen Mohammed Louis Farrakhan Tynnetta Muhammad Ishmael Muhammad Ava Muhammad David Muhammad James 3X Khalid Muhammad Beliefs and theology Saviours' Da…
This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: TÜBİTAK Space Technologies Research Institute – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (February 2015) (Learn how and when to remove this message) TÜBİTAK Space Technologies Research InstituteTÜBİTAK Uzay Teknolojileri Araştırma EnstitüsüAbbreviatio…
Voce principale: Promozione 1986-1987. Promozione Veneto 1986-1987 Competizione Promozione Sport Calcio Edizione Organizzatore FIGC - LNDComitato Regionale Veneto Luogo Italia Cronologia della competizione 1985-1986 1987-1988 Manuale Nella stagione 1986-1987 la Promozione era il sesto livello del calcio italiano (il massimo livello regionale). Qui vi sono le statistiche relative al campionato in Veneto. Il campionato è strutturato in vari gironi all'italiana su base regionale, gestiti dai…
British actor Michael ShepleyPublicity still, autographed 1950Born(1907-09-29)29 September 1907Plymouth, Devon, England, UKDied28 September 1961(1961-09-28) (aged 53)London, England, UKOccupationActorYears active1929–1961Spouse(s)Evelyn Mary Patricia(m. 19??) Arthur Michael Shepley-Smith[1][2] (29 September 1907 – 28 September 1961), known professionally as Michael Shepley, was a British actor, appearing in theatre, film and some television between 1929 and 1961…
سرينيفاسا فارادهان (بالتاميلية: சாத்தமங்கலம் ரங்க ஐயங்கார் ஸ்ரீனிவாச வரதன்) معلومات شخصية الميلاد 2 يناير 1940(1940-01-02)تشيناي الهند البريطانية مواطنة الهند الولايات المتحدة عضو في الجمعية الملكية، والأكاديمية النرويجية للعلوم والآداب، …
Australian state election 1985 Victorian state election ← 1982 2 March 1985 (1985-03-02) 1988 → All 88 seats in the Victorian Legislative Assembly45 seats needed for a majorityand 22 (of the 44) seats in the Victorian Legislative Council First party Second party Third party Leader John Cain Jr. Jeff Kennett Peter Ross-Edwards Party Labor Liberal National Leader since 9 September 1981 26 October 1982 17 June 1970 Leader's seat Bundoora …