Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) tracks were completed on the present line in 1841.[3] At first, trains did not stop here, with Bethpage appearing only as a notation ("late Bethpage") associated with the Farmingdale station to the east.[4] By 1854, the LIRR stopped at a local station called Jerusalem.[5][6] A local post office opened January 29, 1857, with the name Jerusalem Station.[7] In 1867, the residents voted to change the name of the local post office to Central Park, and both that and Jerusalem appeared on LIRR schedules until 1936. The station and the post office were renamed Bethpage on October 1, 1936.[8] In 1959, the station burned down and was replaced. Electrified service through the station was inaugurated in 1987.[9]
Two nearby stations also had Bethpage in their name:
Bethpage Junction was a connection to the east of the present station where the LIRR crossed with the Central Railroad of Long Island, which was built in 1873. A platform was built to enable passengers to transfer. This is the location where the present Central Branch splits from the Main Line at Beth Interlocking one mile southeast of the Bethpage station on the way to Babylon station and the Montauk Branch. The LIRR built the B-Tower at Beth Interlocking in 1925 to replace hand-operated switching between the tracks.
Bethpage was also the name of the northern terminus of the former Bethpage Branch from Bethpage Junction to the former Bethpage Brickworks in the community now called Old Bethpage, but which was called Bethpage until 1936.
From 1873 until 1876, the Central Railroad of Long Island had a regularly scheduled stop also named Central Park near Stewart Avenue and Motor Lane in Plainedge, approximately 0.75 miles (1.21 km) south of the present station.[10][11][12] Service was continued by the LIRR at that location until about 1924.
Station layout
There are two tracks at this station with two 12-car high-level side platforms.
^"1863 LIRR timetable". Retrieved December 31, 2011. The schedule shows the stop is 2 miles from Farmingdale and 3 miles from Hicksville, the same distances as of 2025[update].
^David Roberts. "Nassau County Post Offices 1794-1879". Archived from the original on July 25, 2008. Retrieved December 23, 2007. John L. Kay; Chester M. Smith, Jr. (1982). New York Postal History: The Post Offices & First Postmasters from 1775 to 1980. American Philatelic Society.
