Season
|
Winner
|
Score
|
Runner-up
|
Venue
|
Notes
|
1878–79
|
The Wednesday
|
3 – 2
|
Heeley
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1879–80
|
Heeley
|
2 – 1
|
The Wednesday
|
Sheaf House
|
|
1880–81
|
Not completed
|
|
|
1881–82
|
The Wednesday
|
5 – 0
|
Heeley
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1882–83
|
The Wednesday
|
4 – 0
|
Pyebank
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1883–84
|
Lockwood Brothers
|
6 – 0
|
Pyebank
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1884–85
|
Heeley
|
4 – 0
|
The Wednesday
|
Bramall Lane
|
Replay; First game 1 – 1 at Bramall Lane
|
1885–86
|
The Wednesday
|
2 – 0
|
Heeley
|
Old Forge Ground
|
|
1886–87
|
Staveley
|
3 – 0
|
The Wednesday
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1887–88
|
The Wednesday
|
2 – 0
|
Rotherham Town
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1888–89
|
Staveley
|
1 – 0
|
Rotherham Town
|
Olive Grove
|
|
1889–90
|
Staveley
|
3 – 0
|
Rotherham Town
|
Olive Grove
|
2nd replay; First game 1 – 1 at Bramall Lane, Second game 1 – 1 at Olive Grove
|
1890–91
|
Not completed
|
|
|
1891–92
|
Not completed
|
|
|
1892–93
|
Not won
|
Olive Grove
|
The Wednesday and Sheffield United drew 0-0- competition declared 'unwon'
|
1893–94
|
Not played
|
|
1894–95
|
Mexborough
|
n/a
|
Chesterfield
|
n/a
|
League format, played under the auspices of the Sheffield & District Football League
|
1895–96
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
n/a
|
Barnsley St. Peters
|
n/a
|
League format
|
1896–97
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
n/a
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
n/a
|
League format
|
1897–98
|
Not played
|
|
|
1898–99
|
Not played
|
|
|
1899–1900
|
The Wednesday F.C. reserves
|
n/a
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
n/a
|
League format
|
1900–01
|
Monk Bretton
|
2 – 1
|
Roundel
|
Old Forge Ground
|
|
1901–02
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
n/a
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
n/a
|
League format
|
1902–03
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
n/a
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
n/a
|
League format
|
1903–04
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
n/a
|
Barnsley reserves
|
n/a
|
League format
|
1904–05
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
n/a
|
Denaby United
|
n/a
|
League format
|
1905–06
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
n/a
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
n/a
|
League format
|
1906–07
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
n/a
|
Rotherham County
|
n/a
|
League format
|
1907–08
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
3 – 2
|
Rotherham County
|
Bramall Lane
|
1908–09
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
n/a
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
n/a
|
League format
|
1909–10
|
Barnsley reserves
|
3 – 1
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1910–11
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
3 – 0
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1911–12
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
2 – 1
|
South Kirkby Colliery
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1912–13
|
Gainsborough Trinity
|
3 – 1
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
Central Avenue
|
Replay; First game 0 – 0 at Central Avenue
|
1913–14
|
Rotherham County
|
2 – 0
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1914–15
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
4 – 1
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1915–16
|
Worksop Town
|
n/a
|
|
n/a
|
League format
|
1916–17
|
Not played
|
|
|
1917–18
|
Not played
|
|
|
1918–19
|
Not played
|
|
|
1919–20
|
Maltby Main
|
-
|
Retford Town
|
|
Awarded to Retford Town ? - trophy is engraved Maltby Main F.C. for season 1919–20 [3]
|
1920–21
|
Rotherham County reserves
|
3 – 1
|
Frickley Colliery
|
Oakwell
|
|
1921–22
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
3 – 1
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1922–23
|
Doncaster Rovers
|
1 – 0
|
Scunthorpe & Lindsey United
|
Belle Vue
|
|
1923–24
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
2 – 1
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1924–25
|
The Wednesday reserves
|
3 – 1
|
Rotherham Town
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1925–26
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
|
Wath Athletic
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1926–27
|
Doncaster Rovers reserves
|
2 – 0
|
Barnsley reserves
|
Belle Vue
|
|
1927–28
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
4 – 0
|
Worksop Town
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1928–29
|
Doncaster Rovers reserves
|
2 – 0
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1929–30
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
6 – 3
|
Rotherham United reserves
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1930–31
|
Sheffield Wednesday reserves
|
4 – 0
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1931–32
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
2 – 0
|
Sheffield Wednesday reserves
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1932–33
|
Sheffield Wednesday reserves
|
2 – 1
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1933–34
|
Doncaster Rovers reserves
|
2 – 1
|
Barnsley reserves
|
|
|
1934–35
|
Norton Woodseats
|
3 – 1
|
Goldthorpe United
|
|
|
1935–36
|
Not played
|
|
|
1936–37
|
Sheffield United 'A'
|
3 – 2
|
Dinnington Athletic
|
Shiregreen
|
|
1937–38
|
Sheffield Wednesday 'A'
|
4 – 1
|
Sheffield United 'A'
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1938–39
|
Sheffield Wednesday 'A'
|
5 – 3
|
Norton Woodseats
|
Coach & Horses Ground
|
|
1939–40
|
Not played
|
|
|
1940–41
|
Thurcroft Welfare
|
3 – 0
|
Beighton Miners Welfare
|
Woodhouse
|
|
1941–42
|
RASC
|
4 – 1
|
Sheffield Wednesday reserves
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1942–43
|
RASC
|
2 – 1
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
Hillsborough
|
|
1943–44
|
RASC
|
1 – 0
|
Sheffield United reserves
|
Bramall Lane
|
|
1944–45
|
Thorncliffe Welfare
|
|
|
|
|
1945–46
|
Thorncliffe Welfare
|
3 – 1
|
Greens Welfare
|
|
|
1946–47
|
Thorncliffe Welfare
|
|
|
|
|
1947–48
|
Not completed
|
|
Hoyland Common fielded ineligible player in final win over Penistone Church - competition voided
|
1948–49
|
Stocksbridge Works
|
2 – 0
|
YMCA
|
Penistone
|
|
1949–50
|
Hoyland Common Athletic
|
1 – 0
|
Aughton Juniors
|
|
|
1950–51
|
Aughton Juniors
|
|
|
|
|
1951–52
|
Penistone Church
|
|
Aughton Juniors
|
|
|
1952–53
|
Beighton Miners Welfare
|
|
Aughton Juniors
|
|
|
1953–54
|
Thorncliffe Recreation
|
5 – 1
|
Parkgate Welfare
|
|
|
1954–55
|
Brown Bayleys Steels & Greenhill Meths
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
Cup shared
|
1955–56
|
Thurcroft Main
|
|
|
|
|
1956–57
|
Sheffield Wednesday youth
|
3 – 2
|
Sheffield
|
High Green
|
|
1957–58
|
Sheffield Wednesday youth
|
6 – 0
|
Grenoside Sports
|
High Green
|
|
1958–59
|
Sheffield Wednesday youth
|
4 – 3
|
Thurcroft Main
|
High Green
|
|
1959–60
|
Thorncliffe Recreation
|
4 – 2
|
Sheffield Wednesday youth
|
High Green
|
|
1960–61
|
Harworth Colliery Institute
|
3 – 2
|
Thorncliffe Recreation
|
Thurcroft
|
Fri 12 May
|
1961–62
|
Retford Town reserves
|
4 – 2
|
Y.M.C.A. (Sheffield)
|
Swallownest Miners Welfare
|
Sat 12 May
|
1962–63
|
Harworth Colliery Institute
|
5 – 2
|
Hillsborough Select
|
Retford Town
|
Sat 1 June
|
1963–64
|
Swallownest Miners Welfare
|
|
Steel, Peech & Tozer
|
|
|
1964–65
|
Maltby Miners Welfare
|
|
|
|
|
1965–66
|
Frecheville Community Association
|
|
|
|
|
1966–67
|
Frecheville Community Association
|
3 – 1
|
Kiveton Park United
|
Swallownest Miners Welfare
|
|
1967–68
|
Charlton United
|
|
|
|
|
1968–69
|
Swallownest Miners Welfare
|
1 – 0
|
Windsor British Legion
|
Kiveton Park
|
|
1969–70
|
Thurcroft Welfare
|
|
|
|
|
1970–71
|
Hallam
|
|
|
|
|
1971–72
|
Ecclesfield Red Rose
|
|
|
|
|
1972–73
|
Charlton United
|
|
|
|
|
1973–74
|
Heeley Amateurs
|
|
|
|
|
1974–75
|
Kiveton Park
|
1 – 0
|
Maltby Miners Welfare
|
Swallownest Miners Welfare
|
Mon 19 May
|
1975–76
|
Harworth Colliery Institute
|
3 – 1
|
Kiveton Park
|
Denaby United
|
Mon 10 May
|
1976–77
|
Norton Woodseats
|
|
|
|
|
1977–78
|
Mosborough Trinity
|
|
|
|
|
1978–79
|
Charlton Tavern
|
1 – 1 (p)
|
Maltby Miners Welfare
|
|
|
1979–80
|
Maltby Miners Welfare
|
|
|
|
|
1980–81
|
Not played
|
|
|
1981–82
|
Not played
|
|
|
1982–83
|
Frecheville Community Association
|
|
|
|
|
1983–84
|
Kiveton Park
|
2 – 1
|
Hallam
|
Kiveton Park
|
|