On "Wake Me Up", the Weeknd explores themes of existentialism and facing reality as he reflects on inner struggles.[3] Emma Johnson of The MSU Reporter said of the song, "In a funk reminiscent of his 2022 album, 'Dawn FM,' he sings about needing to wake up 'cause I’m dreaming/It feels so damn real.'"[4] Roisin O'Connor of The Independent saw the song as "a scene-setting moment for what, it soon emerges, is the Canadian artist's most ambitious project to date – a feature film-length album that supposedly serves as the final chapter for his enigmatic alter ego The Weeknd".[5] The song starts off slow and then gets upbeat, in which the fast-paced instrumental is reminiscent of the music from Michael Jackson's fifth studio album, Off the Wall (1979) and the song "Tell Me I'm Not Dreamin' (Too Good to Be True)" by Jermaine Jackson.[6][7]
Critical reception
Writing for Clash, Robin Murray described "Wake Me Up" as "a stellar opener" from Hurry Up Tomorrow.[8] In contrast, Neil McCormick, Andrew Perry, and Poppie Platt described the song as a "doomy opening".[9] Carl Lamarre of Billboard ranked "Wake Me Up" as the twelfth best song on the album as he acknowledged the Weeknd's love for Michael Jackson's music and the "Thriller" sample, describing the song as "a five-minute exhibition of [the] Weeknd’s exploration of legacy, reality, and disillusionment" and "[The] Weeknd's deftly executes on the pop-synth intro with sizzling precision".[10]