Supreme Electoral Court (El Salvador)

Supreme Electoral Court
Tribunal Supremo Electoral

The headquarters of the TSE.
Agency overview
Formed1991 (1991)
Preceding agency
  • Consejo Central de Elecciones
JurisdictionEl Salvador
HeadquartersSan Salvador, El Salvador
Agency executive
  • Dora Esmeralda Martínez de Barahona, Presiding judge
Websitehttp://www.tse.gob.sv/

The Supreme Electoral Court (Spanish: Tribunal Supremo Electoral, TSE) is the highest electoral authority in the country of El Salvador.

Composition

Article 208 of the Constitution of El Salvador establishes that "there will be a Supreme Electoral Court which will be formed of five Judges, who will remain on the Court for five years and will be chosen by the Legislative Assembly" and that "three of the Judges will each come from one of the three political parties or coalitions who obtained the greatest number of votes in the last presidential election."[1] The two remaining judges are chosen from two slates of judges with no political affiliation proposed by the Supreme Court.[1][2]

2019-2024 term

On 30 July 2019, the members of the Supreme Electoral Court for the period 2019-2024 were announced as per below.[3][4][5]

Title Member Deputy
Presiding Judge Dora Esmeralda Martínez de Barahona René Abelardo Molina Osorio
Judge Luis Guillermo Wellman Carpio Marlon Harold Cornejo Ávalos
Judge Julio Olivo Granadino Carmen Veralíz Velásquez Sánchez
Judge Rubén Atilio Meléndez García María Blanca Paz Montalvo
Judge Noel Antonio Orellana Orellana Sonia Clementina Liévano de Lemus

History

Central Electoral Council

The 1950 constitution of El Salvador established a Central Electoral Council (Spanish: Consejo Central de Elecciones, CCE) as the "highest authority of electoral matters".[6] It was formed of three members and three deputies, all chosen by the Legislative Assembly for a period of three years from lists proposed by the Supreme Court and the executive branch.[7] The 1962 constitution maintained the same structure.[8] However, this structure was criticised as leading to electoral processes falling under the control of the executive branch, and led to accusations of political bias.[9]

The constitution of 15 December 1983 changed the way that the Central Electoral Council was appointed; it stated that the three members of the Council would be chosen by the Legislative Assembly, with one each being chosen from slates proposed by the three political parties or coalitions with the largest vote share in the last presidential elections.[10] This is the same set of procedures taken for the three political members of the Court today.[1]

Civil War-era reforms

In April 1991, during the negotiations between the government of El Salvador and the Farabundo Martí National Liberation Front to end the Salvadoran Civil War, an agreement was reached to reform various articles of the Constitution. One of these reforms was the conversion of the Central Electoral Council into the Supreme Electoral Court, and the addition of the two non-partisan members onto the makeup of the Court.[11][12]

The first challenge the new Court faced was the 1994 Salvadoran general election. Whilst the International Foundation for Electoral Systems' observers found that "the El Salvador voting process was conducted in an orderly, peaceful and transparent fashion which permitted the popular will of the Salvadoran people to be expressed",[13] concerns were also raised about the number of voter applications the Court rejected, often due to lack of documentation.[13][14]

The IFES report also recommended that El Salvador institute a new unitary document for voter registration and identification, which it called at the time a Citizens Voting and Identification Document (Spanish: Sistema de Identificación Ciudadana y Electoral).[13] Whilst efforts started towards this process in 1994, it was not until the 2004 elections that the Unique Identity Document (Spanish: Documento Único de Identidad) substituted the previous electoral cards.[15] The 2013 Electoral Code states that the Unique Identity Document forms the complete basis of the electoral register, and information on all citizens who own one is given to the Court to establish their voter registration.[16]

Modern day

Voters in El Salvador voting at a polling station in 2019
Voters in El Salvador voting at a polling station in 2019

In 2019, Dora Esmeralda Martínez de Barahona, was chosen as the first woman President of the Court, after being proposed by the Grand Alliance for National Unity.[3]

In April 2020, the Court announced plans to continue the 2021 elections to schedule, with additional measures put in place to ensure voters and polling staff would not be put in danger by the coronavirus pandemic.[17] It was announced in May 2020 that the Court would ask for an additional US$5,000,000 to put these measures in place.[18] This funding would be additional to the existing US$45,000,000 approved by the Legislative Assembly for the 2021 elections.[19]

References

  1. ^ a b c Article 208, Section VII of the Constitution of El Salvador (1983, as amended to 2003)
  2. ^ Velásquez, Eugenia (30 July 2019). "Partidos tienen acuerdo en tres propuestas para el TSE" [Parties have agreement in their three proposals for the TSE]. El Diario de Hoy (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 May 2020.
  3. ^ a b Calderon, Beatriz (30 July 2019). "Eligen magistrados del Tribunal Supremo Electoral con una mujer a la cabeza por primera vez" [Judges of the Supreme Electoral Court are chosen with a woman heading it up for the first time]. La Prensa Gráfica (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 May 2020.
  4. ^ "Integración del Organismo Colegiado periodo 2019-2024" [Composition of the Collegiate Body for the period 2019-2024]. Tribunal Supremo Electoral (in Spanish). 1 August 2019. Retrieved 7 August 2019.
  5. ^ "Dora Martínez, nueva presidenta del Tribunal Electoral" [Dora Martínez, the new president of the Electoral Court]. Diario1 (in Spanish). 30 July 2019. Retrieved 6 May 2020.
  6. ^ Article 33, Section III of the Constitution of El Salvador (1950)
  7. ^ Article 34, Section III of the Constitution of El Salvador (1950)
  8. ^ Article 34 and Article 35, Section III of the Constitution of El Salvador (1962)
  9. ^ Haggerty, Richard A. (1990). El Salvador: a country study. Washington, D.C.: Federal Research Division, Library of Congress. LCCN 89048948.
  10. ^ Article 208, Section VII of the Constitution of El Salvador (1983, unamended)
  11. ^ Miranda Cuestas, Guillermo (12 December 2017). "El FMLN aceptó la Constitución con las reformas de 1991" [The FMLN accepted the Constitution with the 1991 reforms]. El Diario de Hoy Historico (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 May 2020.
  12. ^ González, Joel (2 February 2019). "Resumen de las elecciones presidenciales desde 1994 a 2014" [Summary of presidential elections from 1994 to 2014]. InformaTVX (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 May 2020.
  13. ^ a b c McBride, Kelly (8 August 1994). Election Observation El Salvador, March 20 - April 24, 1994 (PDF) (Report). International Foundation for Election Systems. Retrieved 6 May 2020.
  14. ^ Lehoucq, Fabrice (June 1995). "The election of 1994 in El Salvador" (PDF). Electoral Studies. 14 (2): 179–183. doi:10.1016/0261-3794(95)96842-6.
  15. ^ Puente, Leidy (1 March 2018). "6 datos curiosos sobre las elecciones de antaño en El Salvador" [6 curious facts about past elections in El Salvador]. El Diario de Hoy Historico (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 May 2020.
  16. ^ Código Electoral [Electoral Code] (PDF) (Decree 413) (in Spanish). Asamblea Legislativa. 3 June 2013.
  17. ^ Rivas, Violeta (26 April 2020). "Plan para elecciones 2021 incluye distanciamiento y desinfección en un escenario post pandemia" [The plan for the 2021 elections includes distancing and disinfection in a post-pandemic scenario]. El Diario de Hoy (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 May 2020.
  18. ^ Campos Madrid, Gabriel (6 May 2020). "TSE pedirá $5 millones más para elecciones 2021" [TSE will ask for $5 million more for the 2021 elections]. La Prensa Gráfica (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 May 2020.
  19. ^ Sibrián, Walter (5 March 2020). "Asamblea avala $ 45 millones para elecciones 2021: "Esto nos permitirá organizar comicios con mejor tiempo", asegura presidenta del Tribunal" [The Assembly approves a budget of $45 million for the 2021 elections: "This will allow us to organise the elections in better time", says the Supreme Electoral Court president]. La Prensa Gráfica (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 May 2020.