The tract The True Character of a Churchman was printed under West's name in the SomersTracts;[7] it was a product of the debate over "occasional conformity" of religious dissenters, and in it West argued for religious tolerance, in defence of Burnet.[8] At the time of its appearance it was attributed by some to William Lloyd the bishop of Worcester, who made political use of it in Worcestershire against the Tory Sir John Pakington, 4th Baronet, in 1702.[9] Lloyd denied the authorship, in the course of a parliamentary complaint brought by Pakington.[10] West at this time crossed swords in pamphleteering with Henry Sacheverell, whose The character of a Low-Church-man was a reply to West, at the period when High Church and latitudinarian (Latitude-men) were emerging concepts. Sacheverell wrote of latitude that it allowed interpretation of each of the 39 Articles in 39 ways. West came back implying that the Oxford High Church side objecting to that latitude were Calvinists.[11][12]
In January 1710 the Winchester MPs Lord William Powlett and George Rodney Brydges together organised support in Parliament, to thank West for a sermon in which he had stated that in the English Civil War the faults were on both sides.[13][14][15] It had proved controversial in its views (pan-Protestant, Whig, and in favour of continuing the War of the Spanish Succession), and required a vote in Parliament before it was printed.[16]J. P. Kenyon writes that West's sermon was in fact moderate in its Whiggism, in comparison with that of William Stephens on the same occasion ten years before, but the vote on it, at 124 to 105, was close.[17] Despite his reputation as an intemperate Whig who had defended the execution of Charles I,[8] West continued to preach on public occasions.[18]