The game received "mixed" reviews on both platforms according to the review aggregation website GameRankings.[11][12]IGN said of the N64 version, "Konami's NHL Blades of Steel '99 title was plagued by terrible gameplay and horrible control and few nice touches didn't compensate for a disappointing and generally dull game."[8]Nintendo Power gave the same console version a mixed review over a month before it was released stateside,[10] while the same magazine gave the GBC version a mixed review over two months before it was released.[9]
Notes
^In Electronic Gaming Monthly's review of the Nintendo 64 version, four critics gave it different scores: 4.5/10, 3.5/10, 6.5/10, and 6/10.
^In GameFan's review of the Nintendo 64 version, one critic gave it 74, and the other 83.
^GamePro gave the Nintendo 64 version two 3/5 scores for graphics and overall fun factor, 3.5/5 for sound, and 2.5/5 for control.