Mervyn Macartney

Sir Mervyn Edmund Macartney
Born	(1853-09-16)16 September 1853
Died	28 October 1932(1932-10-28) (aged 79)
Nationality	British
Occupation	Architect

Sir Mervyn E. Macartney FSA FRIBA (16 September 1853 – 28 October 1932) was a British architect and Surveyor of the Fabric of St Paul's Cathedral between 1906 and 1931.[1][2] Macartney was a leading figure in the Arts and Craft movement, being a founder of the Art Workers' Guild and the Arts and Crafts Exhibition Society, and an influential voice as the editor of The Architectural Review[3] and via his publications The Practical Exemplar of Architecture and Later Renaissance Architecture in England with John Belcher.

The English House 1860–1914: Catalogue to an Exhibition of Photographs and Drawings in 1980 stated that Macartney did not deserve the comparative obscurity that he has today,[4] while Peter Davey in his 1980 book Arts and Crafts Architecture: The Search for Earthly Paradise described Macartney as the least Ruskin of the architects that came from Richard Norman Shaw's tutorage.[5]

Early life

Macartney was born in London on 16 September 1853, the youngest of the four sons of Elizabeth and Maxwell Macartney, a doctor.[2] His half brother was the painter C. H. H. Macartney. He was privately educated[6] until 1873 when he completed his education at Lincoln College, Oxford, before working under the tutorial of Richard Norman Shaw.[7][8] Before he started his own practice he travelled across Europe visiting  France, Italy and Germany. There are various dates to when Macartney started his own practice, ranging from 1877,[9] which must be inaccurate as he was articled to Shaw at this time, to 1882.[6] It was in 1882 that his first design from his own practice, Kent Hatch in Westerham, Kent was completed.[10][11] In 1891, he married the Hon. Elizabeth Wilhelmina Ritchie, the daughter of Charles Ritchie, 1st Baron Ritchie of Dundee.

Architectural practice

Examples of buildings and estates that Macartney worked on include:

• a pilastered conservatory at Swaylands in the Kentish Weald[12]
• a rebuilding of St Leonard's Church, Downham in Lancashire[13]
• The Court, Woolhampton[14]
• South Avenue in Whiteley Village[15]
• Egerton Place, Knightsbridge on the Smiths Charity Estate[16][17]
• 169 Queen's Gate in South Kensington, London[18]
• Islington South Library[19]
• Guinness Trust tenements in Draycott Avenue, Chelsea, in 1891.(Robert John Stirling was instructed to use them as a model when he came to design tenements for the Trust to the north of St Patrick's Cathedral, Dublin)[20]
• Welders, Chalfont St. Giles (his father-in-law Charles' home)[21]
• Newbury Town War Memorial[22]

Newbury Town War Memorial by Sir Mervyn E. Macartney

In addition to his architectural designs, Macartney also designed the organ case at St Thomas Church in Winchelsea, the only known example of this type of work.[23]

The Architectural Review

Macartney was one of the original editorial board members of The Architectural Review, founded in 1896, along with Sir Reginald Blomfield, Ernest Newton and Henry Wilson.[24] In 1896, he wrote a piece for the review criticising the redevelopment of Charing Cross Road by the Metropolitan Board of Works, which he had previously submitted plans for as part of the competition for the redevelopment.[25][26] In 1903, Macartney had a disagreement with the then editor of the review, D.S. MacColl, who had criticised the 1903 Art and Crafts Exhibition Society show as being amateurish, with Macartney reposit being that MacColl wasn't an architect.[27] MacColl was sacked after another financial crisis at the journal, and Macartney replaced him as the editor for the review serving from 1905 until 1921.[28][8] Under Macartney, the journal moved with the British architectural style, from being broadly devoted to Arts and Crafts architecture to increasing what is now call Edwardian Baroque. In 1913, Macartney relaunched the Review, with pages of whole pictures in a new lavish style, while new topics including The Architecture of the Liner were added. Macartney created a special issue to mark the end of World War I to celebrate the 'Great Peace' in which ideas and plans for the centre of the proposed League of Nations were shown.[27]

Drawing of old and new streets in redevelopment of Charing Cross Road by Macartney for The Architectural Review

St Paul's Cathedral and Durham Cathedral

In February 1906, Macartney was appointed the Surveyor of the Fabric of St Paul's Cathedral[29] and remained in the role until his resignation in November 1930.[30] He was made the consulting architect for Durham Cathedral in 1911, replacing C. Hodgson Fowler who had died the previous year.[29] Macartney completed extensive repairs and restoration to St Paul's during his time at the Cathedral, especially work on the piers, which Macartney said had been built of indifferent quality by various contractors.[31][32][33] With architect Detmar Blow and sculptor Sir William Reid Dick, they designed the Kitchener Memorial in the All Souls' Chapel in St Paul's.[34][35] Other work included completing the work of his predecessor as surveyor, Somers Clarke, on the St Michael and St George's Chapel,[36] and the adding of a hot water heating system for the building and later installing fire resistance partitions to the cathedral's iconic dome. Macartney, along with W. Godfrey Allen, set the building restriction St Paul's heights to protect the view of the Cathedral's views across the city.[37] Macartney designed the St Paul's Choristers war memorial, a timber free standing screen built by Henry Poole, which is located at the north wall of the quire aisle.[38]

Arts and crafts

Macartney was a member of the St George's Art Society, which along with fellow society, the Fifteen, promoted the unity of the arts. However, in 1884, both the Royal Academy of Arts and the Royal Institute of British Architects were seemingly trying to work against this.[39] Macartney, along with fellow Shaw apprentices W. R. Lethaby, Edward Prior, Ernest Newton and Gerald C. Horsley, plus metal worker W. A. S. Benson, designer Heywood Sumner, painter and brother C. H. H. Macartney, sculptors Hamo Thornycroft and Edward Onslow Ford,[40] and the architect John Belcher[41][42] set about founding the Art Workers' Guild.

Macartney, along with Blomfield and John Belcher complained to The Times in 1901 about the Victoria and Albert Museum holding an exhibition of continental Art Nouveau.[43]

Kenton & Co.

Desk designed by Mervyn Macartney, built by W. Hall for Kenton and Co. now in the collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art

Six years after the creation of the Art Worker's Guild in 1890, he was one of the co-founders of the furniture company Kenton & Co.. His co-founders were Sidney Barnsley, Reginald Blomfield, William Lethaby, Ernest Gimson, Stephen Webb and Colonel Harold Esdaile Malet. The company had been setup with the object of designing, making and supplying furniture of excellent quality from an idea by William Lethaby and Ernest Gimson, with the formal registration in February 1891 with capital of £3000.[44] Macartney was the company chairman and the business operated from Jubilee Place, Chelsea before moving to Brownlow Mews in Guilford Street.[44]

Blomfield in his memoirs written during 1932 stated of the management of the business:

We used to meet in each other’s rooms, undertake designs of our own choice and invention more or less in turn, except the Colonel, who held, as it were, a watching brief on the whole proceeding. Each man was responsible solely for his own design and its execution, and it was delightful to go to the [work]shop and see one’s design growing into shape in the hands of our skilful cabinet-makers. We made no attempt to interfere with each other’s idiosyncrasies.[44]

The company had an exhibition of their works at Barnard's Inn at Holborn, and in the January 1892 edition of Furniture and Decoration praised the design of Macartney' chairs but criticised the price of £24 for six chairs, though The British Architect, December 1891 edition

found the furniture beautiful in form, delightful because of the quality of the workmanship and reasonable in price.[44]

Although the company had healthy sales, a further share issue was completed in January 1892 which raised £465, though £40 remained unpaid. However four months later the owners realised that the business required a further £1,000 investment to keep going, so the company was wound up and the remaining stock was distributed amongst the board members.[8][44]

A desk designed by Macartney was shown at the 1893 Arts and Crafts Exhibition at the New Gallery, London, and was favorably commented on in The Cabinet Maker and Art Furnisher,

An escritoire by Mr. Mervyn Macartney….is quite a gem. Original in design, dressed up with lovely wood, and perfectly made by Mr. W. Hall, it is one of the few miniature woodwork triumphs of the exhibition. Hitherto the French have had a monopoly in dainty things of this sort. The buyer who has the means need not now go to Paris to satisfy the taste of his lady-love.[45]

Honours and later life

Memorial plaque to Macartney in the crypt of St. Paul's Cathedral

Macartney was elected as a Fellow of the Royal Institute of British Architects (FRIBA) in 1889, before resigning in 1891, along with John Belcher and Ernest Newton over a dispute before being reinstated in 1906.[46] A bust of Macartney carved by Michael Murphy was exhibited at the Royal Academy of Arts in London during 1892.[47] He was made an Honorary Corresponding Member of the American Institute of Architects (AIA) and was elected the Master of the Art Workers' Guild in 1899.[48][49] Macartney died on 28 October 1932.[28][8]

Publications

• Later Renaissance Architecture in England (1901)
• English Houses and Gardens in the 17th and 18th Centuries (1908)
• The Practical Exemplar of Architecture (1908–27)

Further reading

• Mervyn Edmund Macartney, Architect, 1853-1932: The Life and Work of Sir Mervyn Macartney, BA, FRIBA, FSA, with Particular Reference to His Houses and Clients on the Surrey/Kent Border by Jan Ward 1998

External links

• Bust of Mervyn Edmund Macartney (RIBA Collections)

References

1. "Sir Mervyn Edmund Macartney (1853-1932)". Oxford Reference. Retrieved 23 November 2021.
2. Macartney, Sir Mervyn Edmund. doi:10.1093/ww/9780199540884.013.U213193. ISBN 978-0-19-954089-1.
3. London 1900. Rizzoli. 1979. p. 249. ISBN 9780847802142.
4. International Architecture (1980). The English House 1860–1914:Catalogue to an Exhibition of Photographs and Drawings. p. 27. OCLC 10772810.
5. Davey. Peter (1980). Arts and Crafts Architecture:The Search for Earthly Paradise. Architectural Press. p. 105. ISBN 9782870092699.
6. Ward. Jan (1998). Mervyn Edmund Macartney, architect, 1853–1932: the life and work of Sir Mervyn Macartney, BA, FRICA, FSA. Jan Ward. ISBN 0953464105.
7. "(Sir) Mervyn Edmund Macartney". Scottish Architects. Retrieved 23 November 2021.
8. "Macartney, Mervyn Edmund 1853–1932". Biographical Dictionary of British and Irish Architects 1800–1950 – Art History Research net. Retrieved 30 December 2023.
9. London: Technical Journals Ltd (1914). Who's Who in Architecture 1914.
10. "Kent Hatch Westerham". Archiseek. 24 February 2013. Retrieved 25 November 2021.
11. Davey. Peter (1980). L'Architecture Arts & Crafts. Editions Mardaga. p. 131. ISBN 2-87009-269-5.
12. "HER Number:TQ 54 SW 274 Type of record: Landscape Name: Swaylands". Kent County Council Exploring Kents Oast. 25 January 2008. Retrieved 26 January 2024.
13. Hartwell, Clare; Pevsner, Nikolaus (2009) [1969], Lancashire: North, The Buildings of England, New Haven and London: Yale University Press, p. 277, ISBN 978-0-300-12667-9
14. "The Court and Forecourt Walls to North List Entry Number: 1319514". Historic England. 10 November 1983.
15. Ian Nairn, Nikolaus Pevsner, Bridget Cherry (2002). Surrey. Yale University Press. p. 520. ISBN 9780300096750.
16. Greater London Council (1983). Southern Kensington, Brompton. Athlone Press. p. 123-124. ISBN 9780485482416.
17. F H W Sheppard (1983). Survey of London: Volume 41, Brompton. p. 120-126.
18. Baltic Security and Defence Review. Vol. 11. 2009. p. 128.
19. "Town Hall to save Grade II-listed South Library from disrepair". Islington Citizen. 12 May 2021.
20. "MaCartney, Mervyn Edmund (Sir)". Dictionary of Irish Architects 1720–1940. Retrieved 26 January 2024.
21. "Building record 1252800000 - Welders House, Jordans". Buckinghamshire Herotage Portal. 11 December 2019.
22. "Newbury Town War Memorial". Historic England. 11 May 2016.
23. "The Friends of Winchelsea Church. The Organ Appeal". Just Giving. Retrieved 28 January 2024.
24. "AR 120: Jonathan Glancey on Campaigns". The Architectural Review. 17 January 2017.
25. "From Holborn to The Strand: an ideal street". The Architectural Review. 6: 239-244. 1896.
26. Jonathan Schneer (2001). London 1900. Yale University Press. p. 23-24. ISBN 9780300089035.
27. "Centenary, 1896-1921". Architectural Review. 1 May 1996.
28. "Sir Mervyn Edmund Macartney (1853—1932)". A Dictionary of Architecture and Landscape Architecture. Oxford University Press. 2006. Retrieved 2020-12-30.
29. Ian Curry (1985). Sense and Sensitivity: Durham Cathedral and Its Architects : Delivered in the Prior's Hall in Durham, 14 March 1985. Dean and Chapter. ISBN 9780907078173.
30. "Sir Mervyn Macartney, Surveyer of the Fabric of St Pauls: Extracts from The Times ref.CO 447/127/17". The National Archives. 1930.
31. Katherine Wheele (2017). Victorian Perceptions of Renaissance Architecture. Routledge. p. 114. ISBN 9781351537766.
32. "Here and there". Oamaru Mail. 16 September 1919. p. 6.
33. "The Condition of St. Paul's Cathedral". Progress. 3 (4): 133. 1 February 1908.
34. "Sir William Reid Dick". Fine Art Facts. Retrieved 26 January 2024.
35. Nikolaus Pevsner (1951). The Buildings of England: Northumberland. p. 122.
36. Arthur Barnes (2004). St. Paul's: The Cathedral Church of London, 604-2004. Yale University Press. p. 260. ISBN 9780300092769.
37. City of London (March 2013). City of London Local Development Framework. Supplementary Planning Documents. Eastcheap Conservation Area. Fenchurch Street Station Conservation Area. St Paul's Cathedral Conservation Area. Appendix 1 - Statement of Consultation (PDF). p. 13.
38. "St Paul's Choristers". War Memorials. Retrieved 28 January 2024.
39. Whyte. W (4 October 2007). "Founder members of the Art-Workers' Guild (act. 1884–1899)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/96545. ISBN 978-0-19-861412-8. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
40. Harriet Bridgeman, Elizabeth Drury (1975). The Encyclopedia of the Victorian. Country Life. p. 188. ISBN 9780600331230.
41. "The Art Worker' s Guild". Victorian Web. Retrieved 3 August 2021.
42. "UCL Bloomsbury Project – Art Workers Guild". UCL. Retrieved 3 August 2021.
43. Stephan Tschudi Madsen (2013). The Art Nouveau Style: A Comprehensive Guide with 264 Illustrations. Courier Corporation. ISBN 9780486142371.
44. "Kenton & Co. (1891-1892)". British and Furniture Makers Online - The Furniture History Society. 30 November 2019.
45. "Desk". The Met. Retrieved 26 January 2024.
46. "The Old Question: What is an Architect". The Builder. 58: 288. 19 April 1890.
47. "Sir Mervyn Edmund Macartney RIBA reference number RIBA98214". RIBApix. Retrieved 26 January 2024.
48. Ward. J (1998). Mervyn Edmund Macartney, architect, 1853-1932. Jan Ward. ISBN 0953464105.
49. "(Sir) Mervyn Edmund Macartney". Scottish Architects. Retrieved 23 November 2021.