St. Mary Academy (Stafford Township, near Manahawkin CDP[2][3] - From 1997,[4] until 2019 it operated as All Saints Regional Catholic School and was collectively managed by five churches. In 2019 St. Mary Church of Barnegat took entire control of the school, which remained on the same Manahawkin campus, and changed its name. The other churches no longer operate the school but still may send students there.[5] The other churches that formerly collectively operated the school include: St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Church in Whiting, St. Francis of Assisi Church in Brant Beach, St. Pius X Church near Forked River CDP (in Lacey Township and adjacent to the Forked River CDP.[6][7]), and St. Theresa Church in Little Egg Harbor.[4] The five churches still participate in sending students to the school.[2]
Holy Innocents School (Neptune Township[8][9]) - Closed in 2019 as, while the school administration stated it would be sustainable at 200 students, it had only 93 students.[5]
St. Veronica School (Howell) - Merged into Mother Seton Academy in 2019.[5]
Ocean County
St. Aloysius School (Jackson) - Merged into Mother Seton Academy in 2019.[5]
^ ab"Tuition". St. Mary Academy. Retrieved June 23, 2020. Participating parishes include: [...]400 Doc Cramer Blvd, Manahawkin, NJ 08050 - It has a Manahawkin address but is outside of the Manahawkin CDP
^"Home". Saint Pius X Church. Retrieved June 23, 2020. 300 Lacey Road, Forked River, NJ 08731 - It has a Forked River postal address but is outside the CDP.
^"Home". Holy Innocents School. Archived from the original on March 11, 2016. Retrieved June 23, 2020. Address 3455 West Bangs Ave., Neptune NJ 07753 - The address shows that it is in the township.