Academy Award untuk Cerita Terbaik

Academy Award untuk Cerita Terbaik adalah sebuah Academy Award yang diberikan dari permulaan Academy Awards sampai 1957, ketika kategori tersebut digantikan oleh Academy Award untuk Penulis Permainan Latar Asli, yang diperkenalkan pada 1940.

• 1927/1928: Underworld - Ben Hecht
  • The Last Command - Lajos Bíró
• 1928/1929: Tidak ada yang diberikan

• 1929/1930: Tidak ada yang diberikan
• 1930/1931: The Dawn Patrol - John Monk Saunders
  • Doorway to Hell - Rowland Brown
  • Laughter - Harry D'Arrast, Douglas Doty, Donald Stewart
  • The Public Enemy - John Bright, Kubec Glasmon
  • Smart Money - Lucien Hubbard, Joseph Jackson
• 1931/1932: The Champ - Frances Marion
  • Lady and Gent - Grover Jones, William Slavens McNutt
  • The Star Witness - Lucien Hubbard
  • What Price Hollywood? - Adela Rogers St. Johns, Jane Murfin
• 1932/1933: One Way Passage - Robert Lord
  • The Prizefighter and the Lady - Frances Marion
  • Rasputin and the Empress - Charles MacArthur
• 1934: Manhattan Melodrama - Arthur Caesar
  • Hide-Out - Mauri Grashin
  • The Richest Girl in the World - Norman Krasna
• 1935: The Scoundrel - Ben Hecht, Charles MacArthur
  • Broadway Melody of 1936 - Moss Hart
  • The Gay Deception - Stephen Morehouse Avery, Don Hartman
  • Penulisan dalam Kandidat: G Men - Gregory Rogers (pseudonim dari Darryl F. Zanuck)
• 1936: The Story of Louis Pasteur - Pierre Collings, Sheridan Gibney
  • Fury - Norman Krasna
  • The Great Ziegfeld - William McGuire
  • San Francisco - Robert Hopkins
  • Three Smart Girls - Adele Comandini
• 1937: A Star Is Born - Robert Carson, William Wellman
  • Black Legion - Robert Lord
  • In Old Chicago - Niven Busch
  • The Life of Emile Zola - Heinz Herald, Geza Herczeg
  • One Hundred Men and a Girl - Hans Kraly
• 1938: Boys Town - Eleanore Griffin, Dore Schary
  • Alexander's Ragtime Band - Irving Berlin
  • Angels with Dirty Faces - Rowland Brown
  • Blockade - John Howard Lawson
  • Mad About Music - Marcella Burke, Frederick Kohner
  • Test Pilot - Frank Wead
• 1939: Mr. Smith Goes to Washington - Lewis R. Foster
  • Bachelor Mother - Felix Jackson
  • Love Affair - Mildred Cram, Leo McCarey
  • Ninotchka - Melchior Lengyel
  • Young Mr. Lincoln - Lamar Trotti

• 1940: Arise, My Love - Benjamin Glazer, John Toldy
  • Comrade X - Walter Reisch
  • Edison, the Man - Hugo Butler, Dore Schary
  • My Favorite Wife - Leo McCarey, Samuel Spewack dan Bella Spewack
  • The Westerner - Stuart N. Lake
• 1941: Here Comes Mr. Jordan - Harry Segall
  • Ball of Fire - Thomas Monroe, Billy Wilder
  • The Lady Eve - Monckton Hoffe
  • Meet John Doe - Richard Connell, Robert Presnell
  • Night Train to Munich - Gordon Wellesley
• 1942: 49th Parallel (The Invaders) - Emeric Pressburger
  • Holiday Inn - Irving Berlin
  • The Pride of the Yankees - Paul Gallico
  • The Talk of the Town - Sidney Harmon
  • Yankee Doodle Dandy - Robert Buckner
• 1943: The Human Comedy - William Saroyan
  • Action in the North Atlantic - Guy Gilpatric
  • Destination Tokyo - Steve Fisher
  • The More the Merrier - Frank Ross, Robert Russell
  • Shadow of a Doubt - Gordon McDonell
• 1944: Going My Way - Leo McCarey
  • A Guy Named Joe - David Boehm, Chandler Sprague
  • Lifeboat - John Steinbeck
  • None Shall Escape - Alfred Neumann, Joseph Than
  • The Sullivans - Edward Doherty, Jules Schermer
• 1945: The House on 92nd St. - Charles G. Booth
  • The Affairs of Susan - László Görög, Thomas Monroe
  • A Medal for Benny - John Steinbeck, Jack Wagner
  • Objective, Burma! - Alvah Bessie
  • A Song to Remember - Ernst Marischka
• 1946: Vacation from Marriage - Clemence Dane
  • The Dark Mirror - Vladimir Solomonovich Pozner
  • The Strange Love of Martha Ivers - Jack Patrick
  • The Stranger - Victor Trivas
  • To Each His Own - Charles Brackett
• 1947: Miracle on 34th Street - Valentine Davies
  • A Cage of Nightingales (Prancis: La Cage aux rossignols) - Georges Chaperot, René Wheeler
  • It Happened on Fifth Avenue - Herbert Clyde Lewis, Frederick Stephani
  • Kiss of Death - Eleazar Lipsky
  • Smash-Up, the Story of a Woman - Frank Cavett, Dorothy Parker
• 1948: The Search - Richard Schweizer, David Wechsler
  • Louisiana Story - Robert J. Flaherty, Frances H. Flaherty
  • The Naked City - Malvin Wald
  • Red River - Borden Chase
  • The Red Shoes - Emeric Pressburger
• 1949: The Stratton Story - Douglas Morrow
  • Come to the Stable - Clare Boothe Luce
  • It Happens Every Spring - Valentine Davies, Shirley Smith
  • Sands of Iwo Jima - Harry Brown
  • White Heat - Virginia Kellogg

• 1950: Panic in the Streets - Edna Anhalt, Edward Anhalt
  • Bitter Rice - Giuseppe De Santis, Carlo Lizzani
  • The Gunfighter - William Bowers, André de Toth
  • Mystery Street - Leonard Spigelgass
  • When Willie Comes Marching Home - Sy Gomberg
• 1951: Seven Days to Noon - James Bernard, Paul Dehn^[1]
  • Bullfighter and the Lady - Budd Boetticher, Ray Nazarro
  • The Frogmen - Oscar Millard
  • Here Comes the Groom - Liam O'Brien, Robert Riskin
  • Teresa - Alfred Hayes, Stewart Stern
• 1952: The Greatest Show on Earth - Frank Cavett, Fredric M. Frank, Theodore St. John
  • My Son John - Leo McCarey
  • The Narrow Margin - Martin Goldsmith, Jack Leonard
  • The Pride of St. Louis - Guy Trosper
  • The Sniper - Edward Anhalt, Edna Anhalt
• 1953: Roman Holiday - Dalton Trumbo
  • Above and Beyond - Beirne Lay, Jr.
  • The Captain's Paradise - Alec Coppel
  • Hondo - Louis L'Amour
  • Little Fugitive - Ray Ashley, Morris Engel, Ruth Orkin
• 1954: Broken Lance - Philip Yordan
  • Bread, Love and Dreams (Italia: Pane, amore e fantasia) - Ettore Margadonna
  • Forbidden Games (Prancis: Jeux interdits) - François Boyer
  • Night People - Jed Harris, (Tom Reed)
  • There's No Business Like Show Business - Lamar Trotti (nominasi anumerta)
• 1955: Love Me or Leave Me - Daniel Fuchs
  • The Private War of Major Benson - Joe Connelly, Bob Mosher
  • Rebel Without a Cause - Nicholas Ray
  • The Sheep Has Five Legs (Prancis: Le Mouton à cinq pattes) - Jean Marsan, Henri Troyat, Jacques Perret, Henri Verneuil, Raoul Ploquin
  • Strategic Air Command - Beirne Lay, Jr.
• 1956: The Brave One - Robert Rich (alias Dalton Trumbo)
  • The Eddy Duchin Story - Leo Katcher
  • High Society - Edward Bernds, Elwood Ullman
  • The Proud and the Beautiful (Prancis: Les Orgueilleux) - Jean-Paul Sartre
  • Umberto D. - Cesare Zavattini