Cottrell was nominated areaBishop of Reading on 6 January 2004,[11] after Jeffrey John controversially withdrew his nomination to the post in 2003.[18] He had been a supporter of John's original appointment. He said of his nomination: "I am looking forward to becoming the next Bishop of Reading with a mixture of excitement and trepidation. I believe my work in mission and evangelism has prepared me well for the challenges facing the church in this new century. I hope and pray that my love for and understanding of the different traditions of the Church of England will enable me to be a focus for unity in the Reading Episcopal area." He was consecrated on 4 May 2004 by Rowan Williams, Archbishop of Canterbury, at St Paul's Cathedral,[19][20] following confirmation of the appointment by letters patent.[17]
In December 2024, BBC Radio 4'sFile on Four programme conducted an investigation into abuse perpetrated by Anglican priest David Tudor. Cottrell faced calls to resign over his handling of the safeguarding case during his tenure as Bishop of Chelmsford.[30] In response to the programme, Cottrell issued a public statement.[31]
As Bishop of Chelmsford, Cottrell was aware of longstanding safeguarding concerns about Tudor, including a 1989 Church ban for sexual misconduct and a 2008 safeguarding agreement preventing him from being alone with children. Despite this, Tudor was allowed to remain in his position and was made an honorary canon of Chelmsford Cathedral, a decision Cottrell's office regretted in 2024.[30]
The BBC investigation revealed that Cottrell was informed in 2012 about a £10,000 compensation payment made by Tudor to a victim known as "Jessica," who alleged she was sexually abused by Tudor from the age of 11 during the 1970s, sometimes violently. Cottrell's office claimed that the payment admitted no liability and that he was guided by legal advice to take no further action.[30]
Stephen Cottrell suspended Tudor from ministry in 2019, following new complaints against him. The matter was later handled by the ecclesiastical courts of the Church of England, which in October 2024 banned Tudor from ministry for life, after Tudor admitted historical sex abuse related to two girls.[32][33] At least seven women came forward alleging they were abused by Tudor, with one receiving a six-figure compensation payment from the Church in 2019. The Bishop of Newcastle, Helen-Ann Hartley, called for Cottrell's resignation, as his handling of the case undermined his credibility to lead the Church. The victim known as Jessica also considers that Cottrell should leave the Church due to his failure to act on the abuse allegations.[30]
Tudor worked for the Church of England for over 46 years across various regions. Cottrell's spokesman defended the archbishop's actions, stating he was in an "invidious situation" and lacked the legal power to dismiss Tudor.[30] However, Tudor was twice reappointed to a senior role under Cottrell after Cottrell was aware of Tudor's misdeeds, and Cottrell is on the record as strongly praising Tudor as late as 2018.[34]
In February 2024 a victim of Tudor filed formal complaints of misconduct under the Church's disciplinary system against Cottrell, David Tudor and bishop Wilfred Wood (a character witness for Tudor). The Church initiated a tribunal hearing into the complaint against David Tudor, which was ongoing as of January 2025[update].[34]
In October 2024 Tudor was banned for life by the Church after admitting sexual misconduct.[35]
In 2007, Cottrell publicly opposed the renewal of Britain's Trident missile systems.[38] The same year, his support for church celebrations of same-sex relationships was widely reported.[39] In 2017, while serving as Bishop of Chelmsford, Cottrell said "Whether you believe there should be same sex marriage or the blessing of same sex unions or whether you do not, you are still a faithful Anglican...We need to find ways of living with this diversity, not being torn apart by it."[40][41] He also stated that "there is no reason why prayers of thanksgiving for these [same-sex] relationships – perhaps a Eucharist – cannot be offered."[42][43]
In August 2021, Cottrell suggested, in an article for the Daily Telegraph, that Welsh and Scottish sports teams could sing "God Save the Queen" along with the English team in all-British matches, saying that it would help to support the union.[44] His idea met with angry responses by some social media users in Wales and Scotland.[45][importance?]
At the General Synod 2023, in his Presidential Address on 7 July, Cottrell acknowledged that some individuals feel distress when addressing God as 'Father', for a variety of reasons.[46] His carefully worded remarks have attracted both support and criticism.[47]
Personal life
Cottrell and his wife Rebecca have three children.[6]
He is a patron of the charity Antibiotic Research UK.[48] The archbishops of Canterbury and York are presidents of the National Churches Trust.[49]
Do Nothing... Christmas is Coming: An Advent Calendar with a Difference (Church House Publishing, August 2008); ISBN0-7151-4164-3
Do Nothing to Change Your Life: Discovering What Happens When You Stop (Church House Publishing, May 2007); ISBN0-7151-4118-X
Abundance of the Heart: Catholic Evangelism for All Christians (Darton, Longman and Todd Ltd, May 2006); ISBN0-232-52636-2
I Thirst: The Cross - The Great Triumph of Love (Zondervan Publishing House, January 2004); ISBN0-310-25069-2
Praying through Life: How to Pray in the Home, at Work and in the Family (Church House Publishing; 2nd Revised edition, November 2003); ISBN0-7151-4010-8
On this Rock: Bible Foundations for Christian Living (The Bible Reading Fellowship, January 2003); ISBN1-84101-238-6
Travelling Well: A Companion Guide to the Christian Faith (Church House Publishing, June 2000); ISBN0-7151-4935-0
Catholic Evangelism (Affirming Catholicism) (Darton, Longman and Todd Ltd, March 1998); ISBN0-232-52271-5
Sacrament, Wholeness and Evangelism: A Catholic Approach (Grove Books Ltd, February 1996); ISBN1-85174-309-X