The concept of privilege is generally considered to be a theoretical concept used in a variety of subjects and often linked to social inequality.[2] Privilege is also linked to social and cultural forms of power.[2] It began as an academic concept, but has since been invoked more widely, outside of academia.[3] This subject is based on the interactions of different forms of privilege within certain situations.[4] It can be understood as the inverse of social inequality, in that it focuses on how power structures in society aid societally privileged people, as opposed to how those structures oppress others.[4]
Arguably[further explanation needed], the history of privilege as a concept dates back to American sociologist and historianW. E. B. Du Bois's 1903 book The Souls of Black Folk. Here, he wrote that although African Americans were observant of white Americans and conscious of racial discrimination, white Americans did not think much about African-Americans, nor about the effects of racial discrimination.[5][6][7] In 1935, Du Bois wrote about what he called the "wages of whiteness" held by white Americans. He wrote that these included courtesy and deference, unimpeded admittance to all public functions, lenient treatment in court, and access to the best schools.[8]
Codification of the concept
Early concepts that would lead to the term White Privilege were developed by the Weather Underground in the 1960s.[9][10] In 1988, American feminist and anti-racism activist Peggy McIntosh published "White Privilege and Male Privilege: A Personal Account of Coming to See Correspondences through Work in Women's Studies". Here, McIntosh documented forty-six privileges which she, as a white person, experienced in the United States. As an example, "I can be sure that if I need legal or medical help, my race will not work against me", and "I do not have to educate my children to be aware of systemic racism for their own daily physical protection". McIntosh described white privilege as an "invisible package of unearned assets" which white people do not want to acknowledge, and which leads to them being confident, comfortable, and oblivious about racial issues, while non-white people become unconfident, uncomfortable, and alienated.[11] McIntosh's essay has been credited for stimulating academic interest in privilege, which has been extensively studied in the decades since.[12]
Overview
Historically, academic study of social inequality focused mainly on the ways in which minority groups were discriminated against, and ignored the privileges accorded to dominant social groups. That changed in the late 1980s, when researchers began studying the concept of privilege.[12]
Privilege, as understood and described by researchers, is a function of multiple variables of varying importance, such as race, age, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, neurology, citizenship, religion, physical ability, health, level of education, and others. Race and gender tend to have the highest impacts given that one is born with these characteristics and they are immediately visible. However, religion, sexuality and physical ability are also highly relevant.[4] Some such as social class are relatively stable and others, such as age, wealth, religion and attractiveness, will or may change over time.[13] Some attributes of privilege are at least partly determined by the individual, such as level of education, whereas others such as race or class background are entirely involuntary.
American sociologist Michael S. Kimmel uses the metaphor of a wind to explain the concept. He explains that when you walk into the wind you have to struggle for each step that you take. When you walk with the wind, you do not feel the wind at all but you still move faster than you would otherwise. The wind is social privilege and if it flows with you, it simply propels you forward with little effort of your own.[4]
In the context of the theory, privileged people are considered to be "the norm", and, as such, gain invisibility and ease in society, with others being cast as inferior variants.[14] Privileged people see themselves reflected throughout society both in mass media and face-to-face in their encounters with teachers, workplace managers and other authorities, which researchers argue leads to a sense of entitlement and the assumption that the privileged person will succeed in life, as well as protecting the privileged person from worry that they may face discrimination from people in positions of authority.[15]
Some academics, such as Peggy McIntosh, highlight a pattern where those who benefit from a type of privilege are unwilling to acknowledge it.[16][17][18] The argument may follow that such a denial constitutes a further injustice against those who do not benefit from the same form of privilege. Derald Wing Sue has referred to such denial as a form of "microaggression" or microinvalidation that negates the experiences of people who do not have privilege and minimizes the impediments they face.[19]
McIntosh wrote that most people are reluctant to acknowledge their privilege, and instead look for ways to justify or minimize the effects of privilege stating that their privilege was fully earned. They justify this by acknowledging the acts of individuals of unearned dominance, but deny that privilege is institutionalized as well as embedded throughout our society. She wrote that those who believe privilege is systemic may nonetheless deny having personally benefited from it, and may oppose efforts to dismantle it.[11] According to researchers[who?], privileged individuals resist acknowledging their privileges because doing so would require them to acknowledge that whatever success they have achieved did not result solely through their own efforts. Instead it was partly due to a system that has developed to support them.[19] The concept of privilege calls into question the idea that society is a meritocracy, which researchers[who?] have argued is particularly unsettling for Americans for whom belief that they live in a meritocracy is a deeply held cultural value, and one that researchers commonly characterize as a myth.[14][20][21][22]
In The Gendered Society, Michael Kimmel wrote that when people at all levels of privilege do not feel personally powerful, arguments that they have benefited from unearned advantages seem unpersuasive.[21][further explanation needed]
Examples
Educational racism
Racism is the belief that groups of humans possess different behavioral traits corresponding to physical appearance and can be divided based on the superiority of one race over another. This can result in particular ethnic and cultural groups having privileged access to a multitude of resources and opportunities, including education and work positions.
Educational racism has been entrenched in American society since the creation of the United States of America. A system of laws in the 18th and 19th century known as the Black Codes, criminalized the access to education for black people. Until the introduction of the Thirteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution and the Civil Rights Act of 1866, seeking out an education was punishable by the law for them. This thus served to keep African Americans illiterate and only value them as a workforce. However, even after these institutional and legal changes, African Americans were still targeted by educational racism in the form of school segregation in the United States. In the 20th century the fight against educational racism reached its climax with the landmark Supreme Court case Brown v. Board of Education.[23]
Educational racism also took other forms throughout history such as the creation of Canadian Indian residential school system in 1831, which forcefully integrated indigenous children into schools aimed at erasing their ethnic, linguistic and cultural specificities in order to assimilate them into a white settler society. Until the last residential school closed in 1996, Canada had an educational system which specifically harmed and targeted indigenous children. An estimated 6,000 children died under that system.[24]
Nowadays the opportunity gap pinpoints how educational racism is present in societies. The term refers to "the ways in which race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, English proficiency, community wealth, familial situations, or other factors contribute to or perpetuate lower educational aspirations, achievement, and attainment for certain groups of students."[25] In other words, it is "the disparity in access to quality schools and the resources needed for all children to be academically successful."[26] Concretely this can be seen in the United States by considering how, according to the Schott Foundation's Opportunity to Learn Index, "students from historically disadvantaged families have just a 51 percent Opportunity to Learn when compared to White, non-Latino students."[26]
According to McKinley et al.
Students of color are pushed toward academic failure and continued social disenfranchisement. Racist policies and beliefs, in part, explain why children and young adults from racially marginalized groups fail to achieve academically at the same rate as their White peers.[27]
Heterosexual privilege
Heterosexual privilege can be defined as "the rights and unearned advantages bestowed on heterosexuals in society".[28] There are both institutional and cultural forces encouraging heterosexuality in society.[28]Sexual orientation is a repeated romantic, sexual or emotional attraction to one or multiple genders. There are a variety of categories including heterosexual, gay, lesbian, and bisexual.[29] Heterosexual is considered the normative form of sexual orientation.[1]
Heterosexual privilege is based in the existence of homophobia in society, particularly at the individual level. Between 2014 and 2018, 849 sexual orientation related hate crimes were committed in Canada.[30] Despite the fact that Canada legalized same-sex marriage in 2005 and has enshrined the protection of the human rights of all people of all sexual orientations, there is still societal bias against those who do not conform to heterosexuality.[31][32]
Beyond this, institutions such as marriage stop homosexual partners from accessing each other's health insurance, tax benefits or adopting a child together.[28] Same sex marriage is legal in only 27 countries, mostly in the northern hemisphere.[33] This results in an inability for non-heterosexual couples to benefit from the institutional structures that are based on heterosexuality, resulting in privilege for those who are heterosexual.
Intersectionality
Privilege theory argues that each individual is embedded in a matrix of categories and contexts, and will be in some ways privileged and other ways disadvantaged, with privileged attributes lessening disadvantage and membership in a disadvantaged group lessening the benefits of privilege.[17] This can be further supported by the idea of intersectionality, which was coined by Kimberle Crenshaw in 1989.[34] When applying intersectionality to the concept of social privilege, it can be understood as the way one form of privilege can be mitigated by other areas in which a person lacks privilege, for example, a black man who has male privilege but no white privilege.[35] It is also argued that members of privileged social identity groups often do not recognize their advantages.[36]
Intersections of forms of identity can either enhance privilege or decrease its effects.[37] Psychological analysis has found that people tend to frame their lives on different elements of their identity and therefore frame their lives through the privilege they do or do not have.[38] However, this analysis also found that this framing was stronger amongst certain nationalities, suggesting that identity and privilege may be more central in certain countries.[38] Often people construct themselves in relation to the majority, so ties to identity and therefore degrees of privilege can be stronger for more marginalized groups.
Forms of privilege one might have can actually be decreased by the presence of other factors. For example, the feminization of a gay man may reduce his male privilege in addition to already lacking heterosexual privilege.[35] When acknowledging privilege, multifaceted situations must be understood individually. Privilege is a nuanced notion and an intersectional understanding helps bridge gaps in the original analysis.
Criticism
The concept of privilege has been criticized for ignoring relative differences among groups. For example, Lawrence Blum argued that in American culture there are status differences among Chinese, Japanese, Indians, Koreans, and Cambodians, and among African Americans, black immigrants from the Caribbean, and black immigrants from Africa.[39]
Blum agreed that privilege exists and is systemic yet nonetheless criticized the label itself, saying that the word "privilege" implies luxuries rather than rights, and arguing that some benefits of privilege such as unimpeded access to education and housing would be better understood as rights; Blum suggested that privilege theory should distinguish between "spared injustice" and "unjust enrichment" as some effects of being privileged are the former and others the latter. Blum also argued that privilege can end up homogenising both privileged and non-privileged groups when in fact it needs to take account the role of interacting effects and an individual's multiple group identities.[39] "White privilege", Michael Monahan argued, would be more accurately described as the advantages gained by whites through historical disenfranchisement of non-whites rather than something that gives whites privilege above and beyond normal human status.[40]
Psychologist Erin Cooley reported in a study published in 2019 that reading about white privilege decreased social liberals' sympathy for poor whites and increased their will to punish/blame but did not increase their sympathy for poor blacks.[41]
Rohlinger, Deana A. (2010). "Privilege". In Ritzer, G.; Ryan, J.M. (eds.). The Concise Encyclopedia of Sociology. John Wiley & Sons. pp. 473–474. ISBN978-1-44-439264-7.
References
^ abBlack, Linda L.; Stone, David (2005). "Expanding the Definition of Privilege: The Concept of Social Privilege". Journal of Multicultural Counseling and Development. 33 (4): 243–255. doi:10.1002/j.2161-1912.2005.tb00020.x.
^ abcTwine, France Winddance (2013). Geographies of Privilege. Routledge. pp. 8–10. ISBN978-0415519618.
^ abcdS. Kimmel, Michael (17 April 2018). Kimmel, Michael S; Ferber, Abby L (eds.). privilege: A Reader (4 ed.). Fourth Edition. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 2016. Revised edition of Privilege, 2014.: Routledge. pp. 1–11. doi:10.4324/9780429494802. ISBN9780429494802.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location (link)
^Sullivan, Shannon (2006). Revealing Whiteness: The Unconscious Habits of Racial Privilege. Indiana University Press. pp. 121–123. ISBN978-0253218483.
^Reiland, Rabaka (2007). W.E.B. Du Bois and the Problems of the Twenty-First Century: An Essay on Africana Critical Theory. Lexington Books. p. 3. ISBN978-0739116821.
^Kincheloe, Joe L. (2008). Critical Pedagogy Primer. Peter Lang International Academic Publishers. pp. 60–62. ISBN978-1433101823.
^Christensen, Mark (2010). Acid Christ: Ken Kesey, LSD, and the Politics of Ecstasy. IPG. p. 264.
^Sine, Peter (1995). The Sixties. Wayne State University Press. p. 222.
^ abKimmel, Michael S. (2009). Privilege: A Reader. Westview Press. pp. 1, 5, 13–26. ISBN978-0813344263.
^ abO'Brien, Jodi A. (2008). Encyclopedia of Gender and Society. SAGE Publications. p. 418. ISBN978-1412909167.
^Sweet, Holly Barlow (2012). Gender in the Therapy Hour: Voices of Female Clinicians Working with Men (The Routledge Series on Counseling and Psychotherapy with Boys and Men). Routledge. p. 71. ISBN978-0415885515.
^ abCase, Kim (2013). Deconstructing Privilege: Teaching and Learning as Allies in the Classroom. Routledge. pp. 63–64. ISBN978-0415641463.
^ abGarnets, Linda (2002). Psychological Perspectives on Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Experiences. Columbia University Press. p. 391. ISBN978-0231124133.
^Carter, Robert T. (2004). Handbook of Racial-Cultural Psychology and Counseling, Training and Practice. Wiley. p. 432. ISBN978-0471386292.
^ abSue, Derald Wing (2010). Microaggressions in Everyday Life: Race, Gender, and Sexual Orientation. Wiley. pp. 37–39. ISBN978-0470491409.
^Khan, Shamus Rahman (2012). Privilege: The Making of an Adolescent Elite at St. Paul's School (Princeton Studies in Cultural Sociology). Princeton University Press. pp. 107–108. ISBN978-0691156231.
^ abHalley, Jean (2011). Seeing White: An Introduction to White Privilege and Race. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. pp. 67, 191. ISBN978-1442203075.
^Bryan McKinley Jones Brayboy, Angelina E. Castagno and Emma Maughan. Review of Research in Education Vol. 31, Difference, Diversity, and Distinctiveness in Education and Learning (2007), pp. 159-194
^ abCoston, Bethany M.; Kimmel, Michael (19 March 2012). "Seeing Privilege Where It Isn't: Marginalized Masculinities and the Intersectionality of Privilege". Journal of Social Issues. 68 (1): 97–111. doi:10.1111/j.1540-4560.2011.01738.x.
^Allen, Brenda. Difference Matters (2nd ed.). p. 15.
^Gutiérrez y Muhs, Gabriella. (2012). Presumed Incompetent : the Intersections of Race and Class for Women in Academia. Niemann, Yolanda Flores., González, Carmen G., Harris, Angela P. Utah: Utah State University Press. pp. 29–39. ISBN9780874218701. OCLC843635973.
^ abVoltmer, Amy. Understanding Intersectionality through Subjective Experiences of Privilege and Oppression. ISBN9780438047501. OCLC1089398027.
^Cooley, Erin; Brown-Iannuzzi, Jazmin (29 April 2019). "Complex intersections of race and class: Among social liberals, learning about White privilege reduces sympathy, increases blame, and decreases external attributions for White people struggling with poverty". Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. 148 (12): 2218–2228. doi:10.1037/xge0000605. PMID31033321. S2CID139104272.
This article does not cite any sources. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Mashike District, Hokkaido – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (December 2009) (Learn how and when to remove this message) The area of Mashike Districts in Rumoi Subprefecture. Mashike (増毛郡, Mashike-gun) is a district located in Rumoi Subprefecture, Hokkaido, Japan.…
Ossetians in TurkeyTotal populationc. 60,000[1] Ossetians in Turkey are citizens and denizens of Turkey who are, or descend from, ethnic Ossetians who originate in Ossetia in the Caucasus. History An estimated 50,000 Ossetes left the Russian Caucasus during the early 1860s as part of a greater migration of Muslims from the region to the Ottoman Empire due to Russia's activities in the region. [2] Many settled in villages in the eastern district of Sarıkamış, but moved further …
French seer and astrologer (1503–1566) For other uses, see Nostradamus (disambiguation). Michel de NostredamePortrait by his son Cesar, c. 1614, nearly fifty years after his deathBorn14 or (1503-12-21)21 December 1503Saint-Rémy-de-Provence, Provence, Kingdom of FranceDied1 or 2 July 1566(1566-07-02) (aged 62)Salon-de-Provence, Provence, Kingdom of FranceOccupations Physician apothecary author translator astrological consultant Known forProphecy, treating plagueNotable workLes …
Tochmarc ÉtaíneÉtaín e Midir, illustrazione di Stephen Reid tratta dall'edizione moderna The High Deeds of Finn (1910) di Thomas William Rolleston. Autoreignoto 1ª ed. originale> Editio princepsMüller (1878) Generepoema Sottogenereepica Lingua originaleirlandese AmbientazioneIrlanda (isola) ProtagonistiÉtaínMidir Altri personaggiAengusFuamnachEochaid Airem SerieCiclo mitologico irlandese Modifica dati su Wikidata · Manuale Tochmarc Étaíne (lett. Il corteggiamento di Étaí…
ChiancheKomuneComune di ChiancheLokasi Chianche di Provinsi AvellinoNegaraItaliaWilayah CampaniaProvinsiAvellino (AV)Luas[1] • Total6,61 km2 (2,55 sq mi)Ketinggian[2]356 m (1,168 ft)Populasi (2016)[3] • Total551 • Kepadatan83/km2 (220/sq mi)Zona waktuUTC+1 (CET) • Musim panas (DST)UTC+2 (CEST)Kode pos83010Kode area telepon0825Situs webhttp://www.comune.chianche.av.it Chianche adalah sebuah …
Former Royal Air Force operations group No. 18 Group RAFRoyal Air Force EnsignActive1 April 1918 - 18 October 19191 September 1938 - 1 April 1996Country United KingdomBranch Royal Air ForceTypeRoyal Air Force groupPart ofRAF Coastal Command (1938 - 1969) RAF Strike Command (1969 - 1994)HeadquartersRAF Pitreavie CastleNorthwood HeadquartersMotto(s)Constant Endeavour[1]EngagementsWorld War I European theatre of World War II Battle of the Atlantic Military unit No. 18 Group (18 Gp…
Soviet archaeologist and anthropologist For the poet with the same name, see Mikhail Gerasimov (poet). Mikhail Gerasimov on a Russian coin Mikhail Mikhaylovich Gerasimov (Russian: Михаи́л Миха́йлович Гера́симов; 2 September 1907 – 21 July 1970) was a Soviet archaeologist and anthropologist who discovered the Mal'ta–Buret' culture and developed the first technique of forensic sculpture based on findings of anthropology, archaeology, paleontology, a…
Professional ice hockey league season Sports season1938–39 NHL seasonLeagueNational Hockey LeagueSportIce hockeyDurationNovember 3, 1938 – April 16, 1939Number of games48Number of teams7Regular seasonSeason championsBoston BruinsSeason MVPToe Blake (Canadiens)Top scorerToe Blake (Canadiens)Stanley CupChampionsBoston Bruins Runners-upToronto Maple LeafsNHL seasons← 1937–381939–40 → The 1938–39 NHL season was the 22nd season of the National Hockey League (NHL). S…
Water-polo aux Jeux olympiques de 1912 Généralités Sport Water-polo Éditions 4e Lieu(x) Stockholm Participants 6 équipes Épreuves 1 Palmarès Tenant du titre Grande-Bretagne Vainqueur Grande-Bretagne Deuxième Suède Troisième Belgique Navigation Londres 1908 Anvers 1920 modifier Le tournoi de water-polo aux Jeux olympiques de 1912 ont lieu pendant les épreuves olympiques à Stockholm, en Suède. Équipes 45 poloïstes appartenant à 6 nations participèrent aux J…
Republic of Somaliland Ministry of AgricultureWasaaradda Horumarinta Beeraha(MoA)Coat of arms of SomalilandMinistry overviewFormed1993; 31 years ago (1993)JurisdictionSomalilandHeadquartersHargeisa, Maroodi Jeh Minister responsibleMohamed Haji osman, MinisterWebsitewww.slmoad.comFootnotesMinistry of Agriculture on Facebook Politics of Somaliland Constitution Constitution Government Government President (List) Muse Bihi Abdi Vice President Abdirahman Saylici Council of Ministers…
Russian boxer (born 1986) In this name that follows Eastern Slavic naming customs, the patronymic is Shevketovich and the family name is Selimov. Albert Selimov Альберт СелимовSelimov at the 2016 OlympicsPersonal informationFull nameАльберт Шевкетович СелимовNationality Azerbaijani RussianBorn (1986-04-05) 5 April 1986 (age 38)Kaspiysk, Dagestan, Russian SFSR, Soviet UnionEducationDagestan State University[1]Height171 cm…
Color the CoverAlbum studio karya Koda KumiDirilisFebruary 27, 2013Direkam2013GenreJ-pop, Jazz, ElectronicLabelRhythm ZoneCD (RZCD-59335)CD+DVD (RZCD-59334)CD+DVD+Booklet (RZCD-59333)Kronologi Koda Kumi Beach Mix(2012) Color the Cover(2013) Driving Hit's 5(2013) Color the Cover (ditulis sebagai Color The Cover) adalah album cover kedua karya penyanyi-penulis lagu Jepang Koda Kumi, setelah album cover tahun 2010-nya Eternity ~Love & Songs~.[1][2] Album tersebut meraih peri…
American politician and physician (born 1950) This article is about the physician and Green Party activist. For the British restaurateur, see Jill Stein (restaurateur). Jill SteinStein in 2016Member of the Lexington Town Meetingfrom the 2nd PrecinctIn office2005–2010 Personal detailsBornJill Ellen Stein (1950-05-14) May 14, 1950 (age 74)Chicago, Illinois, U.S.Political partyGreenOther politicalaffiliationsDemocratic (1968–2002)SpouseRichard RohrerChildren2EducationHarvard University (AB…
Mountain range in Wyoming and Colorado, United States For the 1952 American Western film, see Laramie Mountains (film). Laramie MountainsSouthern face of Laramie PeakHighest pointPeakSouth Bald MountainElevation11,007 ft (3,355 m)ListingMountain ranges of ColoradoGeographyThe Laramie Mountains are shown highlighted in pink on a map of the western U.S. CountryUnited StatesStatesWyoming and ColoradoParent rangeRocky Mountains The Laramie Mountains are a range of moderately high peak…
Martian dune field Mars Global Digital Dune Database MC-1 map showing the North Polar Sand Sea. Olympia Undae is the area with dune coverage between 120° and 240°E longitude. Olympia Undae is the largest field of sand dunes on the planet Mars. Olympia Undae is a vast dune field in the north polar region of the planet Mars. It consists of a broad sand sea or erg that partly rings the north polar plateau (Planum Boreum) from about 120° to 240°E longitude and 78° to 83°N latitude. Stretching …
Main law enforcement agency of Ghana Law enforcement agency Ghana Police ServiceGhana Police Service patch depicting the service logoLogo of the Ghana Police ServiceShield of the Ghana Police ServiceCommon nameGhana Police ServiceAbbreviationGPSMottoService With IntegrityAgency overviewFormed1894Preceding agencies1894 – 1957: known as the Gold Coast Police Force1957 – known as the Ghana Police ServiceEmployees32,684 (30 June 2011)Jurisdictional structureNational agencyRepublic of GhanaO…
Ethnic group MamTotal population865,884Regions with significant populations Guatemala842,252[1] Mexico23,632[2]LanguagesMam, SpanishReligionCatholic, Evangelical, Maya religionRelated ethnic groupsIxil, Tektitek Woman of the Mame culture. She lives in Pavencul Ejido, Municipality of Tapachula, Chiapas, Mexico The Mam are an indigenous people in the western highlands of Guatemala and in south-western Mexico who speak the Mam language. Most Mam (617,171) live in Guatemala…
Grafik peringkat lima perusahaan teratas (2011-2013) Berikut adalah daftar perusahaan umum dengan kapitalisasi pasar terbesar, serta perusahaan milik negara menurut perkiraan nilai pasar. Kapitalisasi pasar dihitung dari harga saham (tercatat pada hari tertentu) dikali jumlah saham yang dikeluarkan. Jumlah ditukar ke dalam satuan juta dolar Amerika Serikat (nilai tukar pada hari tertentu) agar bisa diperbandingkan. Sejumlah perusahaan milik negara lebih besar daripada perusahaan umum terbesar. M…