This text was written in response to Randhir Singh's writing[3]Jhatke Prithaye Tat Gurmat Nirney, which harshly demotes Jhatka practice in Sikhs. Niranjan Singh addresses the root of every question and doubt raised against Jhatka and answered accordingly. The book was published in 1966 and was republished in 2008.
Content
Following are various topics covered in this text:[4]
More thoughts on discussion with Akali Kaur Singh.
Was Bhai Randhir Singh sweet speaker?
I was threaten!
A small objection
Bibliography
The Last Poem
Reception and Controversy
The book was criticized by Bhai Randhir Singh followers[5] known as Akhand Kirtani Jatha. As per Niranjan Singh, he was threaten by Jatha members and also efforts were taken to remove this book from all libraries and book shops limiting its existence.
Kehar Singh Nihang, Budha Dal appreciated Saral for his work. He wished this book to reach among Sikhs so that they could clarify difference between Jhatka and Kutha and know about historicity of Jhatka and Meat in Sikh religion.[6]
^Mr. Niranjan Singh Saral's devastating attack on all traditional Schools of Interpretation in his Jhatka Parkash: Page 156, Guru Nanak, a Global Vision, Inderpal Singh, Guru Nanak Dev University, 1997