Daughter of Shanghai

For the memoir by Tsai Chin, see Daughter of Shanghai (memoir).
Daughter of Shanghai
Theatrical release poster
Directed byRobert Florey
Screenplay byGladys Unger
Garnett Weston
Story byGarnett Weston
Produced byAdolph Zukor
Edward T. Lowe
StarringAnna May Wong
Charles Bickford
Buster Crabbe
CinematographyCharles Schoenbaum
Edited byEllsworth Hoagland
Music byBoris Morros
Production
company
Distributed byParamount Pictures
Release date
  • December 17, 1937 (1937-12-17)
Running time
62 minutes
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish

Daughter of Shanghai is a 1937 American crime film directed by Robert Florey and starring Anna May Wong, Charles Bickford and Buster Crabbe. Unusually for the time, East Asian American actors played the lead roles. It was also one of the first films in which Anthony Quinn appeared. In 2006, Daughter of Shanghai was included in the annual selection of 25 motion pictures to be added to the National Film Registry of the Library of Congress.[1][2]

Plot

A ruthless gang of people smugglers brings foreign nationals into the US illegally, and is prepared to drop their cargo from a plane to their deaths to avoid capture by the authorities.

The gang tries to force Mr. Lang, a wealthy importer of Oriental antiques, to employ aliens or risk his business being wrecked. He refuses and contacts Lloyd Burkett of the Immigration Bureau. Mr. Lang and his daughter Lan Ying Lin set off to meet Burkett but are kidnapped. Mr. Lang is shot dead and their car is dumped in the harbour, but Lan Ying Lin escapes and goes to the house of wealthy society matron and family friend Mrs. Mary Hunt, who introduces her to Burkett and government agent Kim Lee. Burkett says that the identity of the gang's Boss is unknown, but their no. 2 is Otto Hartman. After Burkett, Kim Lee and Lan Ying Lin have left, it is revealed that Mrs. Hunt is the Boss. Her gang have removed incriminating evidence from Mr. Lang's safe, but she is worried that Lan Ying Lin may have more.

Lan Ying Lin turns detective, refusing the help of Kim Lee, and travels independently in search of Hartman to an island off the coast of Central America. She gets a job as a dancer at Hartman's Café bar, which is a front for people smuggling. She sees Hartman's business ledger, and discovers the Boss is a woman.

Meanwhile, Kim Lee gets a job on Captain Gulner's people smuggling ship and makes contact with Lan Ying Lin at Hartman's Café. Kim Lee gets the ledger and Hartman is shot dead by one of the refugees. Lan Ying Lin disguises herself as a man and gets on board Captain Gulner's ship, with Kim Lee. She is discovered, and Gulner finds Kim Lee and the ledger. Lan Ying Lin and Kim Lee are taken onto the people smuggling plane to be dumped at sea, but they escape and swim to the shore unnoticed and come to Mrs. Hunt's house, where they are found by Jake Kelly, her chauffeur. They think they are safe with Mrs. Hunt, but Kim Lee is taken away and tied up. Lan Ying Lin sees the incriminating ledger and realizes Mrs. Hunt is the Boss. Kim Lee reaches a phone and alerts Burkett. Kelly, who was not part of the people smuggling gang and is honest, frees Lan Ying Lin and Kim Lee. There is a fight, the authorities arrive, and Mrs. Hunt and her gang are arrested. Lan Ying Lin agrees to marry Kim Lee.

Cast

Analysis

Publicity photo of Philip Ahn and Anna May Wong

Daughter of Shanghai is unique among 1930s Hollywood features for its portrayal of an Asian-focused theme with two prominent Asian-American performers as leads. This was truly unusual in a time when white actors typically played Asian characters in the cinema. At best, Hollywood assigned some Asian roles to Asian performers and some to white stars in the same film, with results that seem discordant today even if widely accepted at the time. Daughter of Shanghai was prepared as a vehicle for Anna May Wong, the first Asian-American woman to become a star of the Hollywood cinema. Appearing in some 60 movies during her life, she was a top billed player for over twenty years, working not only in Hollywood, but also in England and Germany. In addition, she was a star of the stage and a frequent guest performer on radio, and would headline the first American television series concentrating on an Asian character, The Gallery of Madame Liu-Tsong (DuMont, 1951).

In Daughter of Shanghai, Wong played the Asian-American female lead in a role that was rewritten for her as the heroine of the story, actively setting the plot into motion rather than the more passive character originally planned.[3] The script was so carefully tailored for Wong that at one point it was given the working title Anna May Wong Story.[4]

Of this film, Wong told Hollywood Magazine, "I like my part in this picture better than any I've had before ... because this picture gives Chinese a break—we have sympathetic parts for a change! To me, that means a great deal."[5]

Reception

Contemporaneous

Publicity still of Anna May Wong

On its release, on December 17, 1937, The New York Times gave the film a generally positive review, commenting of its B-movie origins, "An unusually competent cast saves the film from the worst consequences of certain inevitable banalities. [The cast]... combine with effective sets to reduce the natural odds against any pictures in the Daughter of Shanghai tradition."[6]

Modern

The film has received critical acclaim from modern day critics. The review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes reports that 95% of critics gave the film a positive review based on 20 reviews.[7] Critics near universally praised the performances of the lead actors Philip Ahn and especially Anna May Wong.

In 2006, the film was selected for preservation in the United States National Film Registry by the Library of Congress as being "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant". In a press release, the Library of Congress said:

"B-films during the studio era often resonate decades later because they explore issues and themes not found in higher-budget pictures. Robert Florey, widely acclaimed as the best director working in major studio B-films during this period, crafted an intriguing, taut thriller. Anna May Wong overcame Hollywood's practice at the time of casting white actors to play Asian roles and became its first, and a leading, Asian-American movie star in the 1920s through the late 1930s. Daughter of Shanghai was more truly Wong's personal vehicle than any of her other films. In the story she uncovers the smuggling of illegal aliens through San Francisco’s Chinatown, cooperating with costar Philip Ahn as the first Asian G-man of the American cinema."[2]

References

  1. ^ "Complete National Film Registry Listing". Library of Congress. Retrieved 2020-06-04.
  2. ^ a b "Librarian of Congress Adds Home Movie, Silent Films and Hollywood Classics to Film Preservation List". Library of Congress. Retrieved 2020-06-04.
  3. ^ Lim, Shirley Jennifer (9 April 2019). Anna May Wong: Performing the Modern. Temple University Press. p. 66. ISBN 978-1439918340.
  4. ^ Liu, Cynthia W. (2000). "When Dragon Ladies Die, Do They Come Back as Butterflies? Re-imagining Anna May Wong". In Hamamoto, Darrel; Liu, Sandra (eds.). Countervisions: Asian American Film Criticism. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. pp. 23–39. ISBN 1-56639-776-6.
  5. ^ Leung, Louise (June 1938). "East Meets West". Hollywood Magazine. pp. 40, 55. Quoted in Leong 2005, p. 94
  6. ^ Crisler, B.R. (1937-12-24). "Daughter of Shanghai". The New York Times.
  7. ^ "Daughter of Shanghai (1937)". Rotten Tomatoes. Fandango. Retrieved March 31, 2022.

Bibliography

  • Taves, Brian (1986). Robert Florey, The French Expressionist. Lanham, Maryland: Scarecrow Press. ISBN 0-8108-1929-5.