User talk:A Man In Black/Archive Other

This is my miscellaneous talk archive, for talk page fragments that would otherwise be deleted or lost. These discussions are not originally from my talk page.

This was originally posted at Wikipedia:Village pump (policy).

I seem to have had a run-in with User:CoolKatt number 99999, over said user adding a link to User:CoolKatt number 99999/Grudges in the Pokemon anime to Pokémon (anime), and readding the link after I removed it.

I don't want to violate the 3RR by removing that link again, but I'm almost entirely sure that links to user-space pages in article-space articles isn't kosher. In any case, the user-space article page in question, User:CoolKatt number 99999/Grudges in the Pokemon anime, is a rescue of Grudges in the Pokémon anime (which was deleted by VFD process).

I would normally toss it off and maybe bring it up at WP:PAC or WP:PCP, but CoolKatt number 99999 has accused me of vandalism, so I'd like a more immediate third opinion. Is the link I removed appropriate? Is this vandalism?

Relevant pages:

Input would be appreciated. - A Man In Black (Talk | Contribs) 04:18, 3 September 2005 (UTC)[reply]

What you've done seems to be exactly right. I've reverted the link, and added a message to CoolKatt's talk page.-gadfium 05:05, 3 September 2005 (UTC)[reply]
Well, technically you started it, A Man In Black, by nominating the initial "Grudges" article for VFD, but right now I have nothing else to say - CoolKatt number 99999
Oops, wrong user to blame, should be Sinistro. And no, being Greek does not excuse him for his actions - CoolKatt number 99999
I could bring it up at WP:PAC or WP:PCP, if you let me, but if you want to, do it, since there is no vandalism involved, I might join the discussion. CoolKatt number 99999
I'm having a little trouble understanding what you're suggesting, here. - A Man In Black (Talk | Contribs) 20:25, 4 September 2005 (UTC)[reply]
I meant Sinistro started this whole ordeal by putting up the VFD. - CoolKatt number 99999