By the end of the first week of August 1939, George Sayre and Harvey Huntley completed the script for Torture Ship and the film was scheduled to start on August 14 but was held back. [3] Filming was then set to begin by the last week of August but no cast was yet assembled.[3] The cast was announced in September with John Miller originally set to play Jesse, though Skelton Knaggs appears in the final film. [3]
From contemporary reviews, "Herb." of Variety noted the acting in the film stating "there can be no quarrel with the acting of the principals" but that Torture Ship was a "quickie action thriller that misses fire [sic] all the way on its possibilities" and that the film "has so many unreasonable and unexplainable points that it will annoy even the most jueve-minded [sic]"[4]The Film Daily also praised the film's acting while finding Halperin's direction as "O.K." while declaring the film "has enough punch and drama to satisfy the nabe trade."[4]