In both 2010 and 2011, the Stars finished third in the regular season, but managed to upset the second place Nipigon Elks in the league semi-finals to earn entrance into the league finals. In both cases, the Stars were defeated by the Thunder Bay Northern Hawks.
At the end of the 2016–17 season, long-time Stars owners Dave and Scott Simpson sold the franchise to Derek Geddes. The team was rebranded as the Thunder Bay Fighting Walleye.
For the 2018 season British Columbia, Alberta, and Saskatchewan elected not to participate in the Keystone Cup. As a result, the tournament was reorganized to feature the LJHL and KJHL champion and runner-up. Although the Thunder Bay Northern Hawks won the LJHL championship, the new format allowed the Fighting Walleye make their first Keystone Cup tournament. They returned to the Keystone Cup the following season as well, and then were awarded hosting duties for the 2020 tournament.[1] However, the 2020 tournament would be cancelled due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Prior to the 2020–21 season the team rebranded once again as the Kam River Pickerel, but was instead sold and rebranded again as Thunder Bay Bandits.
Season-by-season standings
Season
GP
W
L
T
OTL
Pts
GF
GA
Results
Playoffs
2009-10
30
6
24
0
---
12
123
222
3rd of 3
Won Semifinals, 3-1 vs Elks Lost Finals, 0-4 vs Northern Hawks
2010-11
30
9
17
4
---
22
123
161
3rd of 4
Won Semifinals, 3-1 vs Elks Lost Finals, 0-4 vs Northern Hawks
2011-12
32
15
17
0
---
30
149
171
3rd of 5
Lost Semifinals, 2-3 vs Elks
2012-13
32
14
17
1
---
29
140
143
3rd of 5
Lost Semifinals, 3-4 vs Elks
2013-14
30
16
12
2
---
34
123
104
2nd of 4
Won Semifinals, 4-1 vs Elks Lost Finals, 1-4 vs Northern Hawks
2014-15
30
15
15
0
---
30
149
132
2nd of 4
Won Semifinals, 4-1 vs Elks Lost Finals, 0-4 vs Northern Hawks
2015-16
32
27
5
0
---
54
210
81
1st of 5
Won Semifinals, 4-0 vs Falcons Lost Finals, 2-4 vs Northern Hawks
2016-17
30
4
22
4
---
12
114
231
3rd of 4
Lost Semifinals, 1-4 vs Elks
2017-18
28
16
8
4
---
36
212
109
1st of 4
Won Semifinals, 4-0 vs Falcons Lost Finals, 1-4 vs Northern Hawks
2018–19
30
17
10
4
---
38
187
96
2nd of 4
Won Semifinals, 4-0 vs Elks Lost Finals, 1-4 vs Northern Hawks
2019–20
27
17
8
1
1
36
143
104
2nd of 4
Playoffs cancelled due to COVID-19
2020–21
Cancelled due to COVID-19
2021–22
18
17
0
1
---
35
111
51
1st of 4
Won Semifinals, 4-2 vs (Elks) WON Finals, 4-1 (Northern Hawks) LJHL CHAMPIONS