A reviewer in Reading Time wrote "Mem Fox's rhymed rhythmic text teams brilliantly with Judy’s bright quirky cartoon illustrations",[1] and Publishers Weekly wrote "for times when a single bedtime story just isn't enough, ...".[2]
^Wendy Fitzgerald (23 October 2015). "This & That". Reading Time. Children's Book Council of Australia. Retrieved 9 September 2021.
^"This & That". Publishers Weekly. PWxyz LLC. 16 January 2017. Retrieved 9 September 2021.
^"This & That". Kirkus Reviews. Kirkus Media LLC. 1 December 2016. Retrieved 9 September 2021. The repetition of "that" and the many words that rhyme with it creates a rhythm that encourages participation and can also be used by the adult to dial down a child's energy at the end of the day. ... A master of the bedtime hush, Fox shines.
^Amelia Jenkins (1 February 2017). "This & That". School Library Journal. Media Source Inc. Retrieved 9 September 2021. The bright, cartoonish illustrations perfectly match the playful tone of the text.
^Carissa Mason (16 January 2019). "This & That". Reading Time. Children's Book Council of Australia. Retrieved 9 September 2021. The more we read it, the more I see in it.
^Maryn Wheeler (2018). "This & That". Children's Book and Media Review. 39 (9). BYU ScholarsArchive. Retrieved 9 September 2021. Mem Fox has created another fantastic read aloud. ... The seemingly simple watercolor illustrations are a perfect match to highlight reading as a bonding experience.
^"Notables 2016". cbca.org.au. Children's Book Council of Australia. Retrieved 9 September 2021.