The series was syndicated and began running on a handful of stations late in 1956.[7] With the sale to General Cigar Company of Baltimore in May 1957, the series was contracted to 188 markets.[8] According to Billboard's "Pulse Film Ratings" The O. Henry Playhouse generally received television ratings around 10.0 for its only season and ranked in the middle of the "Syndicated Film Drama Shows" category.[9]
DVD release
Unseen for decades and largely forgotten, The O. Henry Playhouse has recently received a DVD release. Classic Flix, a rental and retail site with a home video label,[10] has restored thirty-nine episodes of the series and is releasing them in three installments during 2021-22.
The web site for the DVD release features plot summaries of each episode, along with links to online texts of the original stories so viewers can compare O. Henry's writings and the television adaptations. The site also includes cast and crew information for each episode and a video sample from the episode. The overall description of the series recounts its unusual story telling method:
Veteran character actor Thomas Mitchell stars in each episode as writer O. Henry himself as he relates his stories to his publisher, his barber, a bartender, or the cop on the beat. In some episodes, O. Henry meets his characters as he discovers firsthand the story he will later write. This rather unique story telling method is made possible by the fame of the author himself and the O Henry audience's desire to learn where each story came from.[11]
Several years before the DVD release Ron Hall, an entrepreneur specializing in public domain video material,[12] related how he received a large collection of original 16mm prints of the series. He posted a video sample of the "Two Renegades" episode, along with general discussion of the series' history, copyright status, number of episodes, and sometimes unexpected casting.[13]
Episodes
Series 1
#
Title
Writers
Original airdate
01
"The Reformation of Calliope"
George Waggner
23 January 1957 (1957-01-23)
#1.01
N/A
Director: George Waggner
02
"Man About Town"
George Waggner
30 January 1957 (1957-01-30)
#1.02
N/A
Director: George Waggner – Includes plot elements from "An Unfinished Story"
03
"Sam Plunkett's Promise"
Donald Hyde
6 February 1957 (1957-02-06)
#1.03
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard — Based on "The Theory and the Hound"
04
"Two Renegades"
Irving Cooper
13 February 1957 (1957-02-13)
#1.04
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
05
"The Marionettes"
George Waggner
20 February 1957 (1957-02-20)
#1.05
N/A
Director: Peter Godfrey
06
"Fog In Santone"
George Waggner
27 February 1957 (1957-02-27)
#1.06
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
07
"Hearts and Hands"
Irving Cooper
6 March 1957 (1957-03-06)
#1.07
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
08
"Blackjack Bargainer"
Irving Cooper
13 March 1957 (1957-03-13)
#1.08
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
09
"The World And The Door"
George Waggner
20 March 1957 (1957-03-20)
#1.09
N/A
Director: Peter Godfrey
10
"The Guilty Party"
Irving Cooper
27 March 1957 (1957-03-27)
#1.10
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
11
"A Ramble In Aphasia"
Irving Cooper
3 April 1957 (1957-04-03)
#1.11
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
12
"Fourth in Salvador"
George Waggner
10 April 1957 (1957-04-10)
#1.12
N/A
Director: George Waggner
13
"After Twenty Years"
Donald Hyde
17 April 1957 (1957-04-17)
#1.13
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
14
"A Trick of Nature"
Donald Hyde
24 April 1957 (1957-04-24)
#1.14
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
15
"Sisters of the Golden Circle"
William Kozlenko (adaptation); Donald Hyde (written for tv)
1 May 1957 (1957-05-01)
#1.15
N/A
Director: Peter Godfrey
16
"Hygeia at the Solito"
Donald Hyde
8 May 1957 (1957-05-08)
#1.16
N/A
Director: Felix Feist
17
"Only The Horse Would Know"
Al C. Ward (adaptation); Donald Hyde (written for tv)
15 May 1957 (1957-05-15)
#1.17
N/A
Director: Anton M. Leader
18
"The Atvatism Of Jon Tom Little Bear"
Irving Cooper
22 May 1957 (1957-05-22)
#1.18
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
19
"Georgia's Ruling"
Mary McCarthy
29 May 1957 (1957-05-29)
#1.19
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
20
"The Fool Killer"
George Waggner
5 June 1957 (1957-06-05)
#1.20
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
21
"One Dollar's Worth"
Irving Cooper
12 June 1957 (1957-06-12)
#1.21
N/A
Director: George Waggner
22
"Christmas by Injunction"
Donald Hyde
19 June 1957 (1957-06-19)
#1.22
N/A
Director: Felix Feist
23
"The Roads We Take"
Irving Cooper
26 June 1957 (1957-06-26)
#1.23
N/A
Director: George Waggner
24
"Vanity And Some Sables"
George Waggner
3 July 1957 (1957-07-03)
#1.24
N/A
Director: Peter Godfrey
25
"The Sphinx Apple"
Irving Cooper
10 July 1957 (1957-07-10)
#1.25
N/A
Director: Les Goodwins
26
"Wit's End"
Seymour Roth (adaptation); Donald Hyde (written for tv)
17 July 1957 (1957-07-17)
#1.26
N/A
Director: Anton M. Leader
27
"Girl"
Albert Isaac Bezzerides
24 July 1957 (1957-07-24)
#1.27
N/A
Director: Peter Godfrey
28
"Hypotheses Of Failure"
Irving Cooper
31 July 1957 (1957-07-31)
#1.28
N/A
Director: George Waggner
29
"Hiding of Black Bill"
Irving Cooper
7 August 1957 (1957-08-07)
#1.29
N/A
Director:George Waggner
30
"Between Rounds"
George Waggner
14 August 1957 (1957-08-14)
#1.30
N/A
Director: George Waggner
31
"Two Thanksgiving Day Gentlemen"
Irving Cooper
21 August 1957 (1957-08-21)
#1.31
N/A
Director: Frederick Stephani
32
"The Emancipation of Billy"
Donald Hyde
28 August 1957 (1957-08-28)
#1.32
N/A
Director: Frederick Stephani
33
"A Madison Square Arabian Knight"
Irving Cooper
4 September 1957 (1957-09-04)
#1.33
N/A
Director: Frederick Stephani
34
"The Lonely Man"
Donald Hyde
11 September 1957 (1957-09-11)
#1.34
N/A
Director: Kenneth G. Crane — Based on "The Last of the Troubadours"
35
"The Buyer from Cactus City"
Donald Hyde
18 September 1957 (1957-09-18)
#1.35
N/A
Director: Les Goodwins
36
"A Service Of Love"
Mary McCarthy
25 September 1957 (1957-09-25)
#1.36
N/A
Director: Bernard Girard
37
"The Tale Of The Tainted Tenner"
Irving Cooper
2 October 1957 (1957-10-02)
#1.37
N/A
Director: Marshall Grant
38
"The Murderer"
Donald Hyde & Irving Cooper
9 October 1957 (1957-10-09)
#1.38
N/A
Director: Frederick Stephani
39
"The Lotterman Affair"
Donald Hyde & Al C. Ward
16 October 1957 (1957-10-16)
#1.39
N/A
Director: Frederick Stephani
N–A
"Series One Episode Unproduced (Tobin's Palm)"
George Waggner
1957 (1957-N/A)
#N/A
TBD
N–A
"Series One Episode Unproduced (The Count And The Wedding Guest)"
George Waggner
1957 (1957-N/A)
#N/A
TBD
N–A
"Series One Episode Unproduced (The Gentle Grafter)"
^McNeil, Alex. Total Television: The Comprehensive Guide to Programming from 1948 to the Present. New York: Penguin Books, 1996. (pg. 611) ISBN0-14-024916-8
^Becker, Christine. It's The Pictures That Got Small: Hollywood Film Stars on 1950s Television. Middletown, Connecticut: Wesleyan University Press, 2008. (pg. 244) ISBN0-8195-6894-5
^Steinbrunner, Chris and Otto Penzler, ed. Encyclopedia of Mystery and Detection. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1976. (pg. 197) ISBN0-07-061121-1