Baldridge is queer. They met their future wife Elizabeth Capel during their time at Elon University. The two married in August 2018 in an Episcopalian ceremony, and the couple's wedding was featured in an episode of the Refinery29 series World Wide Wed.[6][5][7] Their Twitter post giving coming out advice to themselves as a teenager attracted national attention.[5] As of 2021, Baldridge and Capel live in Los Angeles, California.[5][8]
Baldridge writes and records music as Semler. The name was chosen because of both the name's links to their maternal family history and they prefer their music to be experienced from a gender-neutral viewpoint.[11][12]
Their second EP, titled Late Bloomer, was released on October 22, 2021. Like its predecessor, it reached first place on the iTunes Christian charts, once again displacing Lauren Daigle's Look Up Child.[16]
Their third EP, titled Stages of a Breakdown, was released on April 13, 2022.
Baldridge has been a regular guest host of The Young Turks, and co-hosted the former TYT Network show Pop Trigger.[19] They created and hosted the TYT-associated YouTube series Murder with Friends,[20] which was nominated for Best Non-Fiction Series in the 7th Streamy Awards in 2017.[21]
In 2020, Baldridge hosted a documentary series entitled State of Grace, which covered being LGBTQ and Christian, produced by Refinery29. The first episode, "The Life Threatening Dangers Of Gay Conversion Therapy", was nominated at the 31st GLAAD Media Awards for the Outstanding Digital Journalism – Multimedia award.[4]