Prisoners of war during World War II faced vastly different fates depending on the theater of conflict, their captors, and the conventions adhered to or ignored. During the war approximately 35 million soldiers surrendered, with many held in the prisoner-of-war camps. Most of the POWs were taken in the European theatre of the war. Approximately 14%, or 5 million, died in captivity.
Early in the World War II, Nazi Germany, overwhelmed by the number of POWs, released many, though some became used as forced labor. As the war progressed, POWs became strategic assets, increasingly used as forced labor, or considered an important leverage for reciprocal treatment. Within a few years of the war ending, most of POWs were repatriated, though notable exceptions persisted: Axis POWs in Chinese and Soviet camps were held into the 1950s.
The mortality rate was disproportionately high in the Eastern and Pacific theaters, where atrocities, forced labor, and starvation were common, especially for Soviet and Chinese captives under Axis powers and German POWs in Soviet hands. Axis POWs were treated very well by the Western Allies and very harshly by the USSR. Western Allied POWs generally experienced better conditions than most other belligerents, although their treatment by the Japanese was harsh.
Post-war trials, including the Nuremberg Trials, prosecuted violations of POW treatment, though public awareness of such crimes emerged much later, particularly in Germany, while in Japan the issue is still mostly ignored. WWII POWs have been selectively depicted in popular culture, often romanticized in Western media through escape narratives like The Great Escape, while harsher realities, such as Axis and Soviet treatment of captives, remain underrepresented.
History
Most prisoners, after being captured, spent the war in the prisoner of war camps. In the early phases of the war, following German occupation of much of Europe, Germany also found itself unprepared for the number of POWs it held. As a result of that, as well as for political reasons, it released many (particularly enlisted personel) on parole (as a result, it released all the Dutch, the Danes,[1]: 90–92 all Flemish Belgian, all Greeks, nine-tenths of the Poles, and nearly a third of the French captives; some, however, like Poles, were almost immediately forcibly conscripted as laborers).[2][1]: 288 Later prisoners became valuable and were kept as guarantee of good treatment of the prisoners' kept by the other side, or directly used for hard (forced) labor. A small number were exchanged in prisoner exchanges, primarily between Italy and Germany and the Western Allies (approximately 6,000 Italian, 14,000 German, and 12,400 Allied POWs were exchanged in such a fashion).[2]
Majority of POWs were released by late 1940s.[1]: 381–482 In most places they were warmly received by the populace, major exceptions included France (where the society "preferred to forget about them") and the USSR, where they suffered from much discrimination.[1]: 488–489, [488] The last POWs of WWII were Germans and Japanese released from the USSR camps in 1956; some Japanese were held in China until 1964.[1][3]: 192, 196 A few exceptions include stories such as András Toma, considered the last POW of WWII released from captivity, who was discovered living in a Russianpsychiatric hospital in 2000 and was returned to Hungary some fifty-six years after his capture.[4][1]: 483
Number of POWs
In mid-90s Simon MacKenzie observed that "Obtaining an exact figure for the number of POWs [in WWII] is made virtually impossible by the inexactness or unavailability of the records kept by many of the belligerents".[2] In some cases, where entire countries surrendered (for example, Belgians), most if not all soldiers who were not killed in action were captured at some point during the fighting, but many were quickly released unofficially; while others were imprisoned for years. Different estimates may or may not count all such groups as POWs.[5]: 187 [1]: 11 Likewise, German and Japanese soldiers held after their countries surrendered at the end of the war have often not been categorized as prisoners of war (see Japanese Surrendered Personnel, Disarmed Enemy Forces and Surrendered Enemy Personnel.).[2][6]: 322 [7]
MacKenzie cites the figure of 35 million following the 1960s estimate by German historian Kurt W. Böhme [Wikidata].[2] That estimate was considered conservative by MacKenzie, and has been repeated in more recent works (such as by Christian Gerlach in mid-2010s).[8]: 235 Bob Moore, who in his monograph focused on the European theater, gave an estimate of "more than 20 million", which he considered inflated with the number of Axis troops that surrendered after the war.[1]: 1
Consequently, the estimates of the number of prisoners by country or origin or capture can vary as well.[2] With regards to nationality, some estimates include:
By country of origin:
American POWs taken in all theaters: 103,918[9]: 4 (2%[9]: 4 of total). Out of that, 95,532 were held by Germans and 21,580[10]: 3 -26,943[9]: 4 by Japanese.
British and the British Commonwealth POWs taken in all theatres: 353,941[9]: 4 (9%[9]: 4 of total); including at least 15,000 Indian soldiers from the British Indian Army in German and Italian hands.[1]: 348 Out of that total number, 142,319[9]: 4 -169,000[1]: 114 were captured by Germany and Italy. In mid-1943 Italians held 70,000 British troops (about 40,000 British and the rest from the Commonwealth territories).[1]: 138 Japanese held 21,000[9]: 4 - 21,726[10]: 3 Australian, 50,016[9]: 4 [10]: 3 British, 1,691[10]: 3 Canadian, at least 60,000[3]: 66 Indian and 121[10]: 3 New Zealand prisoners.
Belgians: majority of the Belgian army numbering between 600,000-650,000 has been captured by the Germans; 225,000 were sent to POW camps while the rest were released. Within a year, 108,000 Flemish Belgians were released as well.[5]: 187–188 [1]: 99–113
Chinese POWs: the total number is unknown,[8]: 235 but it has been estimated that "tens of thousands" have been captured every year of the Second Sino-Japanese War (1937-1945)[11]: 360
Danish POWs: while Germans quickly captured Danish army following the German invasion of Denmark, the Danes were quickly released. In 1943 about 10,000 Danish soldiers were arrested again and imprisoned in Germany, but most were gain released quickly.[1]: 90–92
Dutch POWs: while Germans quickly captured the Dutch army (c. 300,000 soldiers) following the German invasion of the Netherlands, the Danes were quickly released. However, over 10,000 were taken into custody later in several German actions. A small number of soldiers from Free Dutch Forces was also subject to becoming POWs in Germany upon capture at various stages of the war.[1]: 92–99 37,000 from the forces of the Dutch colonial empire were held by Japanese.[10]: 3
Filipino POWs: held by Japanese: at least 60,000[3]: 76–77
French POWs: held by Germany: estimates vary from 1,500,000,[9]: 15 1,800,000[14] to 1,900,000[1]: 61 following the fall of France, including about 100,000 colonial auxiliaries.[1]: 330–331 15,000 (12,000 French and 3,000 colonial auxiliaries) were briefly held by the Japanese following the Japanese coup d'état in French Indochina in March 1945.[3]: 169, 200 [15][16]: 61
German POWs: held by the USAs: 11,000,000 total (with 1,600,000 captured by the Americans, and 2,400,000 by the British).[17]: 67 425,000 in the USA territory;[18] more than 400,000 in British and Commonwealth territory;[19] 2.8 million held by Western custody by April 30, 1945[20]: 185 (and close to 7 million in the months after the war[21]); approximately 3,000,000 held by the USSR.[22]: 246 Small numbers were briefly held in France until the fall of France.[1]: 68 5,000 have been transferred to the custody of Free French in 1943, effectively as hostages to prevent Axis executions of Free French and French Resistance members; that number grew significantly to over 200,000 in as the war progressed.[1]: 190, 194, 291–292
Greek POWs: Following the capitulation of Greece, the whole Greek Army numbering around 430,000 men was declared to be prisoners of war, however almost all were almost immediately released. Some Greeks joined the Allies-affiliated Greek Armed Forces in the Middle East; an estimated 2,000 were subsequently captured and treated as British auxiliaries.[1]: 288–289
Hungarian POWs: around 280,000 were held by the USSR[1]: 477
Italian POWs: estimate of Italian POWs before the Italian surrender: 700,000.[23]: 92, 94, 96 Out of these: held by USSR: 65,000.[24]: 275 154,000 were held in Britain[25] and 400,000 have been held by Britain in various locations by the time war ended.[23]: 89 [1]: 194 A small number initially, then over 50,000 later, were sent to the United States;[1]: 156, 190 others in various parts of the Commonwealth (such as India, Australia, South Africa and Kenya).[1]: 154–155, 184, 186–188 Close to 20,000 if not more have been captured by Greeks during the Greek-Italian War in 1940.[1]: 287 15,000 have been transferred to the custody of Free French in 1943; that number later increased to over 35,000.[1]: 190, 194, 291 An estimate for the number of new Italian POWs following the surrender was at 1,300,000;[23]: 97, 103 most - approximately one million - were interned by the Germans following Italian surrender;[26]: 146 [23]: 103 They were not recognized as POWs by the Germans.[1]: 6 A small number was interned by the Japanese.[3]: 64, 244 An estimate of one million Italian POWs still held by various captors by the time war ended in 1945 has also been given.[1]: 182 Early in the war British also captured "many thousands" of Italian colonial troops; who were quickly released after being assessed as having little military value.[1]: 14
Norwegian POWs: while Germans quickly captured Norwegian army following the German invasion of Norway, the Norwegians were quickly released. About 1,500 were arrested in 1943; about 1,000 were held until the end of the war. Small number of Norwegians fighting for the Allies in exile were occasionally captured as well throughout the war.[1]: 90–92
Polish POWs: all POWs after invasion of Poland: estimates range 650,000[29]-1 039 800[29] with the lower estimates based on number of soldiers held at POW camps and the higher, for all soldiers as well as similar groups (ex. policeman) taken into custody (many were quickly released). Out of these: 420,000-694,000 held by Germany (many were quickly released then forced to became forced laborers[2]), and 125,000,[30] 190,000[30] or 452 500[29] held by the USSR following the Soviet invasion of Poland. More Polish soldiers would be captured later in the war as Poland created several armies in exile; for example, 60,000 were captured after fall of France.[9]: 15 15,000 Polish partisans taken into custody after the Warsaw Uprising were recognized as prisoners of war and deported to POW camps.[1]: 294
Romanian POWs held by USSR: between 100,000 to 250,000[31]
Soviet POWs: held by Fins: 64,000;[8]: 236 held by Germany: 5,700,000[32]-6,200,000;[32] held by Romania: 91,000[8]: 236 A small number (few dozens) were held by the Japanese following the 1939 border clashes Khalkhin Gol (at that point, however, USSR was not a WWII participant).[3]: 40
Yugoslav POWs: approximately half of the Yugoslav Army had been captured by the Germans, resulting in approximately 350,000 Yugoslav POWs shortly after the German invasion of Yugoslavia; however about half of them were nearly instantly released (however, most were forced to become laborers shortly afterward[2]). Shortly afterward, Germans released more prisoners, retaining only the Serbs (about 130,000).[1]: 273–274 Due to the infighting in Yugoslavia, over 100,000 partisans opposed to the victorious, communist aligned groups were taken into custody by their opponents near the end of the war.[1]: 281–282
By country of capture:
numer of POWs held by the British and Commonwealth: 400,000 Germans[19] (mostly in Canada[9]: 4–5 until the Normandy landings;[1]: 12, 154–155 that number has been also given for the number of Germans "held in Britain;[25] some have also been transferred to the American custody[1]: 156 ) and by the time war ended, 2,400,000 Germans).;[17]: 67 400,000 Italians[23]: 89 (at least 154,000 held in Britain[25] or Commonwealth territories such as India, Australia, South Africa and Kenya[1]: 154–155, 184, 186–188 ), as well as small number of Japanese troops (35,000-50,000 held by the Western Allies).[27]: 61 The Germans in British hand included 1,200 soldiers captured by the Dutch in 1940 and evacuated to Britain before the Germans overrun the Dutch.[1]: 92–93
number of POWs held by Germans has been estimated at approximately 11,000,000 (out of that, roughly 6,000,000 Soviet[32] and 5,000,000 were non-Soviet[8]: 235 )
by mid-1943 Italians held 80,000 Allied troops troops (about 42,000 British and 26,000 from the British Commonwealth)[1]: 138
number of POWs held by Japanese has been estimated at 320,000[9]: 4 to 350,000.[10]: 3 Approximately 132,000 of them came from the Western Allied nations (British Commonwealth, Netherlands and the USA.[10]: 3
number of POWs held by the United States: 425,000 Germans (in the US territory),[18] and by the time the war ended, 1,600,000[17]: 67 as well as small number of Italian[1]: 156 and Japanese troops (35,000-50,000 held by the Western Allies)[27]: 61
number of POWs held by the USSR: approximately 3,000,000 Germans,[22]: 246 65,000 Italians,[24]: 275 100,000-250,000 Romanians[31][dead link] as well as 560,000 to 760,000 Japanese (taken into custody after Japan surrendered)[28]
Treatment of POWs varied significantly based on time and place.[2][9]: 103 Some were released - or killed - almost immediately after capture.[2][5]: 187 Many ended up in prisoner-of-war camps.[2][9]: 78–79
Support from Red Cross was important in improving camp conditions and supplementing often inadequate rations and other necessities for the prisoners, particularly in the camps run by the Axis.[9]: 103
The death rate of prisoners of war in World War II was higher than that of prisoners of war in World War I. Christian Gerlach explained this due to "much higher prisoner numbers, more supply problems, politically motivated denial of food, hard labor and direct violence", including racism.[8]: 235, 237
The situation of POWs was easiest in the Western Front, and much worse on the Eastern Front and in the Asian and Pacific theater. On the Western Front, both sides (in particular, major belligerents - Germany, Italy and the Western Allies[1]: 151 ) generally treated one another according to the Geneva Convention, while the Convention as mostly ignored in the Eastern Front. In the Asian and Pacific theater, the Allies respected the Convention and treated Japanese prisoners humanly, which was not reciprocated by the Japanese.[2]
Approximately 14% (~5 million, not counting Chinese POWs) died in captivity.[8]: 235 Soviet POWs in Germany (approximately 3 million fatalities) and Axis and German POWs in the Soviet Union (approximately million fatalities, or one and a half accounting for all Axis POWs in the USSR) were among the most numerous victims.[2][8]: 235–238 [1]: 484–485, 488 However, Western Allies also mistreated POWs on a number of occasions (for example, Japanese soldiers were often executed after surrendering, and some Germans soldiers in American hands died of malnutrition and disease).[2] Among the Allies, after the USSR, the French had the worst record of treating the POWs.[9]: 4–5 Germany treated Western Allied POWs much better than those from the Eastern Front (in particular, Soviets).[8]: 236 Asian and Pacific Fronts saw difficult POW situation as well, as Japan treatment of POWs - Western, Chinese, Indian, Filipino and others - was very harsh.[8]: 237 [9]: 4–5 Canadian POW camps have been recognized as among the most comfortable in the entire war.[1]: 160
Aftermath
Trials
First trials of Germans accused of crimes against prisoners of war took place in the Soviet Union while the war was ongoing.[35]: 10–11 Shortly after World War II, at the Nuremberg trials (in particular, during the High Command Trial), numerous German crimes against prisoners of war were found to be a direct breach of the laws of war (in particular, Geneva and Hague conventions).[35]: 61, 78–85, 144–145 Almost all of the German high commanders tried during that trial were found to be guilty of crimes against POWs.[35]: 150–153
Despite the trial, German public's awareness of the war crimes committed by its regular army (Wehrmacht), did not arise until the late 90s (see myth of the clean Wehrmacht).[35]: 197–198 The awareness of Japanese crimes against POWs is still poor in Japan; the topic mostly ignored or glossed over in that country.[3]: 2 [10]: 256–262
In popular culture
Image of WW2 POWs in popular culture has been highly selective, obscured by the story of victory for the allies (in which those taken prisoner played little role or were even considered traitors, like in the USSR), and driven by Cold War narratives.[1]: 1
The topic has been described as under researched in modern historiography,[36] although there are exceptions. For example, in West Germany, the government established The Scientific Commission for the History of German Prisoners of War (often referred to as the Maschke Commission, after its chairman, Erich Maschke), which produced a large body of research on this topic, collected in 22 volumes.[37]: 4
^ abcWarmbrunn, Werner (2012). The German Occupation of Belgium 1940-1944. American University Studies (1st, New ed.). New York: Peter Lang Inc., International Academic Publishers. ISBN978-1-4539-0997-3.
^ abMalmi, Timo (2005). "Jatkosodan suomalaiset sotavangit". In Leskinen, Jari; Juutilainen, Antti (eds.). Jatkosodan pikkujättiläinen (in Finnish) (1st ed.). Werner Söderström Osakeyhtiö. pp. 1022–1032. ISBN951-0-28690-7.
^ abWolff, Helmut (1974). Die deutschen Kriegsgefangenen in britischer Hand — ein Überblick [The German Prisoners of War in British Hands – An Overview] (in German). The Scientific Commission for the History of German Prisoners of War.
^Ellis, John, ed. (1993). The World War II databook: the essential facts and figures for all the combatants (1. publ ed.). London: Aurum. ISBN978-1-85410-254-6.
^Source: R. Overmans, Soldaten hinter Stacheldraht, Ullstein 2002. p272– 273.
^ abOvermans, Rüdiger; Goeken-Haidl, Ulrike (2000). Soldaten hinter Stacheldraht: deutsche Kriegsgefangene des Zweiten Weltkriegs. München: Propyläen. ISBN978-3-549-07121-2.
^ abcdeLabanca, Nicola (2023-02-03), Overy, Richard (ed.), "The Italian Wars", The Oxford History of World War II, Oxford University Press, p. 0, ISBN978-0-19-288408-4, retrieved 2024-12-15