Hinckley United F.C. played in the Non League Pyramid from the formation of the club in 1997 until their final season in 2013–14. This is a list of seasons played by the club in English football.
^Beat Workington 2–1 on aggregate in the semi-final before losing 4–2 to Farsley Celtic in the 2007 Conference North play-off Final.[1]
^In 2009–10, only 40 games were played as opposed to 42, due to the insolvency of Farsley Celtic, whose games were removed from the record.
^In 2010–11, only 40 games were played as opposed to 42, due to the insolvency of Ilkeston Town, whose games were removed from the record.
^Hinckley United were deducted three points on 13 December for failing to pay football creditors, and a further three points on 15 April for failing to fulfil their fixture against Bishop's Stortford on 18 December.