Legacy Five's first lineup consisted of tenor Josh Cobb, lead Scott Fowler, baritone Scott Howard, bass Glenn Dustin, and pianist Roger Bennett, who supplied a fifth vocal part in some songs.
The group enjoyed great success with their first album release, Strong In The Strength. The group's first Top 10 hit, "I Stand Redeemed", featured young tenor Josh Cobb. He won the Horizon Individual Award at the 2000 National Quartet Convention,[3][4] and resigned from the group two days later,[5] saying he felt he wasn't really part of the group. Cobb was replaced by Tony Jarman, who stayed with the group until 2004.[6][7]
Frank Seamans, who sang with Scott Fowler in the 1990s in a group called The Sound,[8] replaced Tony and stayed with the group from 2004 to 2009.[9] In 2005, he won the Horizon Individual Award.[1]
Tim Parton, a pianist who produced a number of the group's albums, joined the group on the road in October 2006 as a substitute for the ill Bennett. Following Bennett's death on March 17, 2007,[10] from complications related to leukemia, Parton's "interim" tag was removed, as the group officially named him the regular pianist.[11][12]
In September 2009, Frank Seamans announced his departure from Legacy Five due to his son's health issues. In October, his replacement, Gus Gaches, who previously sang with The LeFevre Quartet, was announced.[13][12]
In 2011, pianist Tim Parton left, and was replaced by Trey Ivey.[14]
On July 12, 2012, bass singer Glenn Dustin resigned,[15] and was replaced by Matt Fouch from Soul'd Out Quartet.[12]
In November 2015, Gus Gaches announced his departure due to several allergies and vocal fatigue.[16] On October 8, Josh Feemster, formerly of Mercy's Mark, was named the new tenor for Legacy Five and started singing in December 2015.
On April 21, 2017, pianist Trey Ivey announced his departure from Legacy Five to spend more time with his family and focus on his studio.[17][18] On June 17, 2017, Josh Townsend, from the Lefevre Quartet, announced on his personal Facebook profile he had been chosen to be Ivey's replacement.[19]
On March 11, 2019, tenor Josh Feemster announced his resignation to work from home.[20] Two weeks later, on March 25, baritone Scott Howard also announced his resignation to work at Danley Sound Labs, assisting and developing clients with audio needs.[21] On April 22, 2019, it was announced that Bryan Walker, former member of the Perrys, would be taking over the baritone position. Also, songwriter Lee Black would join the group as the tenor singer.[22][23][24]
On May 24, 2021, Josh Townsend announced he would leave his position as the group's piano player to focus on producing his own music.[25] His replacement, Garrett Anderson, was announced on Legacy Five's Facebook page on August 2.[26][27] On March 4, 2023, Anderson announced his departure from the group after accepting a position with Dailey & Vincent.[28] A week later, Bryan Walker, too, announced his departure from the group.[29]
On June 5, 2023, Legacy Five announced the return of Tim Parton as pianist and the addition of Jake Losen as the new baritone singer.[30]
They have been nominated for over 70 Singing News Fan Awards,[31][32][33] including Best Traditional Male Quartet in 2004,[10] and have won or been nominated for an award nearly every year. At the 2004 Fan Awards, the group won in the categories of Traditional Quartet, Baritone, Bass and Pianist. At the 2005 Fan Awards, Frank Seamans won the Horizon Individual Award. At the 2007 Fan Awards, Roger Bennett was posthumously awarded Favorite Musician Award. He had won it 15 times in a row, and is the holder of the record for most consecutive such awards to date. Glenn Dustin also won Favorite Bass, and the group's Live In Music City album won Album of the Year. At the 2008 Fan Awards, the group won the Best Traditional Male Quartet Award one more time. At the 2010 Fan Awards, the Jubilee! project, by Legacy Five, Greater Vision and The Booth Brothers, won the Album of the Year Award.[1] The group has also been nominated for a few GMA Dove Awards,[34] and their Pure Love project was awarded Southern Gospel Album of the Year on the 2020 Dove Awards.[35][36]
One of their best-known songs, "Heroes of the Faith", was composed by Roger Bennett in honor of Glen Payne.[37] "Hello After Goodbye", from their God's Been Good project, was recorded in honor of Roger Bennett.
Compilation of The Cathedrals' most famous songs recorded by Legacy Five.
2001
Heritage Vol. I
Tony Jarman
Scott Fowler
Scott Howard
Glenn Dustin
Roger Bennett
First album with Tony Jarman as tenor.
Heroes of the Faith
2002
Heritage Vol. II
Also released on VHS and DVD.
2003
London
Legacy Five's first #1 charting song, "I Found Grace", was included on this album.
Live at the Palace
Recorded with Greater Vision; also released on VHS and DVD.
2004
Heritage Vol. III
Tony Jarman left Legacy Five shortly after his version of this album was released. Because of that, the group recorded it one more time with Frank Seamans as tenor.
Frank Seamans
Scott Fowler
Scott Howard
Glenn Dustin
Roger Bennett
Monuments
This is considered Seamans' first album with Legacy Five, as it had not been recorded with another tenor before.
A Capella
Live at NQC 2004
Recorded live at the 2004 National Quartet Convention, featuring songs recorded in their projects Monuments and A Capella; also released on VHS and DVD.
2005
A Little Taste of Heaven
Songs from this album were also featured on the group's 2007 release, 2006 Celebration: Friday Night Favorites!
2006
Live in Music City
Recorded live at the Gaylord Opryland Hotel, on Memorial Day 2006. It was awarded Singing News Fan Awards for Album of the Year in 2007. Also released on DVD.
2007
2006 Celebration: Friday Night Favorites!
Recorded live at the Gaylord Opryland Hotel, on Memorial Day 2006. It was Roger Bennett's last album with Legacy Five, as he died shortly after its release. The project was also released on DVD.
Know So Salvation
Frank Seamans
Scott Fowler
Scott Howard
Glenn Dustin
Tim Parton
Roger Bennett started the development of this album, but died before it was finished. It is, therefore, Tim Parton's first album with Legacy Five. It includes a new version of the song "I Stand Redeemed", which was originally recorded featuring Josh Cobb in 2000, now featuring Seamans.
A Little Christmas
Legacy Five's first Christmas album; also released on DVD in 2010, with Gus Gaches as tenor.
Compilation of Legacy Five's greatest successes, such as "Strong in The Strength", "I Found Grace", "Out of my Darkness" and others. The album consisted of two discs: the first included the original recordings of the songs mentioned; the second had new arrangements of those songs.
Frank Seamans left Legacy Five shortly after his version of this album was released, in 2009. Because of that, the group recorded it one more time with Gus Gaches as tenor in 2010.
2010
Gus Gaches
Scott Fowler
Scott Howard
Glenn Dustin
Tim Parton
Give the World a Smile
Compilation of The Cathedrals' most famous songs recorded by Legacy Five. It is considered Gaches' first album with Legacy Five, as it had not been recorded with another tenor before.
Legacy Five's #1 charting song "Christ is Still the King" was included on this album.
2015
Talkin' About Heaven
Gus Gaches left Legacy Five shortly after his version of this album was released. Because of that, the group recorded it one more time with Josh Feemster as tenor.
Also released on DVD. It is considered Feemster's first album with Legacy Five, as it had not been recorded with another tenor before.
In The Hands of a Carpenter
Messiah
Legacy Five's second Christmas album.
2017
Faith & Freedom
Josh Feemster
Scott Fowler
Scott Howard
Matt Fouch
Josh Townsend
Josh Townsend's first album with Legacy Five. It includes a new version of the song "God's Been Good", which was originally recorded featuring Tim Parton in 2008, now featuring Townsend.
2019
Pure Love
Lee Black
Scott Fowler
Bryan Walker
Matt Fouch
Josh Townsend
Lee Black's and Bryan Walker's first album with Legacy Five, released on August 23, 2019. It includes #1 charting songs "What Kind of Man" and "What a Day".
2020
Songs from the Pen of Lee Black & Friends
Features songs written by tenor Lee Black, previously recorded by other groups, with new arrangements.
2021
Something New
Lee Black
Scott Fowler
Bryan Walker
Matt Fouch
Garrett Anderson
Garrett Anderson's only album with Legacy Five, released on October 8, 2021.
2024
25
Lee Black
Scott Fowler
Jake Losen
Matt Fouch
Tim Parton
This album will celebrate 25 years of Legacy Five. The album will feature a mix of new songs and some classic Legacy Five songs. Jake Losen's first album with Legacy Five.
