When it opened was by Paul Gillon in the 1950s, the bar was called the Columbia Tavern & Liquors. Its current name comes from prior owners Lefty (John Miller) and Lauretta. It is currently owned by Ken Frandsen.
The bar is rumored to have been visited by serial killers Jeffrey Dahmer and John Wayne Gacy, the latter being said to have worn a full clown outfit there during the 1970s.[2]