In 1991, Fenwick was hired as the head football coach for Los Angeles Valley.[6][11] In six seasons as head coach he led the team to a 48–15–1 record; including three ten-win seasons.[12] In 1997, he rejoined Cal State Northridge, this time as the head football coach.[12][13] In his one season at the helm, he led the team to a 6–6 record, but had to forfeit two wins, and is now credited for a 4–8 record.[14][15] After one season, he was hired as the offensive coordinator for New Mexico.[16][17] During his tenure he introduced the Lobos to a West Coast offense.[16] He served in the position for two years before taking the same position at Eastern Oregon.[18] In 2002, he was promoted to head coach.[18] Before the 2004 season, Fenwick was diagnosed with leukemia and had to miss the season.[19] He returned to coach in 2005. In three total seasons as head coach, he led the team to an 11–18 record including a winning 6–3 record in his final season and first in the transitionary period into the NAIA's Frontier Conference.[20] He was fired four days after the conclusion of the 2005 season.[21][22] In 2006, Fenwick was hired as the offensive coordinator for Occidental.[23] In 2009, he returned for his second stint as the head football coach for Los Angeles Valley. He retired from coaching following the 2012 season.[23]
Later career
From 2012 until his retirement in 2020, Fenwick served as the athletic director for Los Angeles Valley College.[24][25]
National championship Conference title Conference division title or championship game berth
Notes
^Not eligible for conference standings as the team was under a probationary period while transitioning from the NCAA Division III to the NAIA's Frontier Conference.
^ abcd Cal State Northridge originally finished the 1997 season 6–6 but had to forfeit their wins over Boise State and Azusa Pacific due to ineligible players. Cal State Northridge is now credited with a 4–8 record.