Muhammad played at Oklahoma State from 2020 to 2022. As a freshman in 2020, he played in five games and had one tackle. As a sophomore in 2021, he played in all 14 games with one start and recorded 23 tackles. In 2022, Muhammad started all 12 games and had 48 tackles and one interception.[3][4] After the season, he entered the transfer portal and transferred to the University of Washington.[5][6] Muhammad was a starter his first year at Washington in 2023.[7]
On January 12, 2024, Muhammad announced that he would be entering the transfer portal for the second time.[8] On January 27, he announced that he would transfer to Oregon.[9]