In June and July 2005, the band played a few headlining shows, before supporting Head Automatica and Gym Class Heroes on separate stints. Following this, they appeared on a week's worth of East Coast Warped Tour shows.[4] The band released a split single with the Early November that featured an acoustic version of "I Took a Beating" and new song "New Disaster".[5] They went on a two-week US tour in August 2005 with Silverstein, Scary Kids Scaring Kids and Evergreen Terrace.[6] Following this, I Am the Avalanche went on a cross-country US tour with Bayside, June, and the Forecast, running into October 2005.[7]I Am the Avalanche was made available for streaming on September 25, 2005 through Mammoth Press' website, before being released two days later through Drive-Thru Records.[8] They played a handful of shows with the Audition and Rock Kills Kids in October 2005, prior to a West Coast tour supporting the Honorary Title the following month, and then supported Hot Rod Circuit on the East Coast.[9][10][11]
In January 2006, I Am the Avalanche supported the Starting Line and MxPx on their co-headlining UK tour.[12] Following this, the band toured the rest of the US with No Use for a Name and the Suicide Machines until March 2006.[13] Following this, they supported the Receiving End of Sirens on their US tour in April and May 2006.[14] The band appeared at The Bamboozle and MacRock festivals, and supported Bayside on their US tour.[15][16][17] I Am the Avalanche then supported Rx Bandits, prior to an appearance on the Smartpunk stage at that year's Warped Tour.[18][19] Following this, they embarked on a tour with This Is Hell and the Blackout Pact, which lead into a short stint with BoySetsFire.[20][21] In September 2006, they went on a short tour of Japan with No Use for a Name; upon returning to the US, they went on a short US East Coast tour with Emanuel.[22][23] Though the band were initially announced to support Saves the Day on a short tour, they taken off the dates as they were touring Japan at the time.[24][25] I Am the Avalanche closed out the year supporting Senses Fail on their headline US tour.[26]
In January 2007, I Am the Avalanche went on a US Northeastern headlining tour with support from the Forecast.[27] In September 2007, they went on an East Coast tour with You, Me, and Everyone We Know and Daggermouth.[28] The following month, the band performed at Waidestock festival.[29] They closed out the year with another East Coast tour with Daggermouth.[30] In May 2008, the band performed at The Bamboozle festival and played a handful of Midwest and West Coast shows with Set Your Goals, Hit the Lights, 2*Sweet, and the Years Gone By.[31][32] Following this, they played some shows with Hit the Lights, Jet Lag Gemini, and the Armada until June 2008.[33] In October 2008, the band supported Four Year Strong on their headlining West Coast and Midwestern tour.[34] In February and March 2009, the band toured Australia as part of the Soundwave festival.[35]