I, Lucifer shows the band drifting away from their metalcore sound established in their debut, Saints, as it features less screaming and more singing.[12]
Background
Both Sparks and Ackerman, then of Chapter 14, would join Destroy the Runner in 2007.[14] Ackerman, a friend of drummer Marc Kohlbury would join at Kohlbury's request following the departure of Kyle Setter.[15]
The band released three tracks as singles to promote the album: "Mr. and Mrs. Cuckoldom," "Crumbs For The Murder," and "Isabella's," on February 20, March 11, and April 14 2008 respectively.[16][17]
A music video for the song "Isabella's" was released on January 14, 2009.[18]
The record takes on a far more progressive sound from the band's previous effort.[22] When interviewed, Ackerman noted that after his time with scream-heavy As I Lay Dying he wanted to do an album more singing-focused, and added he felt that "I, Lucifer" turned out to be about 80% singing, 20% screaming.[12]
The band's new direction was well received by critics. AllMusic's Greg Prato rated the album favorably, praising the "new look" band for embracing "tricky prog music" and "good old-fashioned clean singing"[12] Indie Vision Music praised the band's change in direction as well, commending Ackerman's vocal melodies and calling the album "much more powerful, emotional, and memorable record than the majority of the releases of their counterparts in the scene."[8]