The town was once called Freshwater, and was the center of activity for the Freshwater Mining District, a minor producer of copper, lead, zinc, mica, feldspar, and other minerals, including traces of gold and silver.[5]
Activity and population peaked between the years 1895 and 1902, with over 500 residents and 40 businesses in the town. Cattle ranching and lumber operations supplemented the mining activity.[6] The town was also known for its dances and fiddlers.[5]
In January 2001, the bodies of three members of the Dutcher family were found near Guffey; all had been murdered. Three teenagers were convicted of the crime. The boys had formed a group that took on aspects of a paramilitary organization, and one of them claimed that the murders were part of a plan to fight insurrection in the country of Guyana. The brutal nature of the crime and its bizarre motive attracted national attention.[7][8]
The town has a cat named "Monster" as its unofficial Mayor.[5] The town is perhaps less famous for its annual Fourth of July Chicken Fly, a tradition which lasted for twenty-six years, but ended in 2016. At the chicken-fly, small chickens were released from a velvet-lined mailbox atop a ten-foot-high (3.04 m) platform; prizes were awarded for those chickens that flew the greatest distance.[9]
^ abcVeatch, Steven W.; Alfrey, Dan; Beckwith, Jo; Blair, Becky; Peterson, Chris L.; Johnston, Wayne; Hammond, Maury; Loest, Maury (November 8–9, 2008). "Mineral Strike to Meteor Strike: Guffey and the Freshwater Mining District". Abstracts of the 29th Annual New Mexico Mineral Symposium. New Mexico Bureau of Geology and Mineral Resources. Retrieved September 24, 2013.
^"xmACIS". National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Retrieved January 5, 2024.
^Peterson, Chris (2002). "The Guffey Meteorite". Cloudbait Observatory. Archived from the original on September 27, 2013. Retrieved September 24, 2013.
^"Guffey". Meteoritical Bulletin Database. The Meteoritical Society. Retrieved September 24, 2013.