Stark is also a talented player of the game, and she says she is unsure if she wants to try for a career as a player or an umpire.[4] She entered the women’s league with many accolades already to her name, taking out the NTFL under-15s best and fairest in 2021 and the leading goalkicker award after kicking 54 goals for the competition.[5] While playing for St Mary's, Stark was selected to represent The Allies in the under-18 AFLW National Championships in 2022.[6]
After making her senior football debut during the 2021–22 NTFL season, Stark would win the under-18s best and fairest award.[7]
In 2022, Stark was named the Northern Territory's junior sportsperson of the year.[3]
^"Record-breaking teen set to trailblaze two AFL pathways on the field — with and without a whistle: Emma Stark has already broken new ground as the youngest AFLW umpire, but can she also play at the top level too?". ABC Premium News. Sydney, New South Wales: Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 7 September 2022.
^"Best juniors in NTFL crowned for outstanding feats". NT News. Darwin, Northern Territory: Nationwide News Pty Ltd. 9 March 2021. p. 31.
^Cameron, Ben (7 April 2022). "Territory's best young talent named in Allies side". NT News. Darwin, Northern Territory: Nationwide News Pty Ltd. p. 37.
^Chambers, Nathaniel (10 March 2022). "TOP YOUNG STARS EARN COVETED GONGS". NT News. Darwin, Northern Territory: Nationwide News Pty Ltd. p. 43.