Crofting

Crofting (Scottish Gaelic: croitearachd) is a form of land tenure[1] and small-scale food production peculiar to the Scottish Highlands, the islands of Scotland, and formerly on the Isle of Man.[2] Within the 19th-century townships, individual crofts were established on the better land, and a large area of poorer-quality hill ground was shared by all the crofters of the township for grazing of their livestock.[3] In the 21st century, crofting is found predominantly in the rural Western and Northern Isles and in the coastal fringes of the western and northern Scottish mainland.[4]

History

Origins and history before 1886

Crofting communities were a product of the Highland Clearances (though individual crofts had existed before the clearances). Previously, Highland agriculture was based on farms or bailtean, which had common grazing and arable open fields operated on the run rig system. An individual baile might have between five and ten families as tenants. As landowners sought to increase the income from their lands, the first step was the removal of the tacksmen. They were steadily eliminated over the last quarter of the 18th century. A tacksman (a member of the daoine uaisle, sometimes described as 'gentry' in English) was the holder of a lease or tack from the landowner. Where a lease was for a baile, the tacksman usually sublet to the farming tenants and may have provided some management oversight. Tacksmen were integral to the trade in black cattle out of the Highlands, providing an important role in the overall Highland economy. By preventing this section of society from sub-letting, the landlords obtained all of the rent paid by those who worked the land. Secondly, landowners replaced the older farming methods with pastoral systems, with leases being auctioned off to the highest bidder. In early cases, these new farms raised cattle. Much more common was the introduction of extensive sheep farms. Both required the eviction of the tenants of each baile. In many clearances, the tenants of inland farms were moved to crofting communities in coastal areas, often on poorer quality land. This type of clearance was carried out mostly until the 1820s.[5][6]

Croft work was hard, back-breaking work which yielded a subsistence living.[7] Aside from hay and oats, usually root vegetables, potatoes or cabbages were grown and peat would be cut by hand and left outside in various characteristic patterns of stacks to dry so as to serve later for fuel or sometimes for bedding for animals. Most crofters had sheep to shear and lamb. Some crofters had the care of small numbers of cattle.[8]^[better source needed]

The crofts created by clearance were not intended to support all the needs of those who lived there and consequently were restricted in size to a few acres of arable land with surrounding shared grazing. Landlords intended their crofting tenants to work in various industries, such as fishing or kelp. A contemporary estimate was that a crofter needed to carry out 200 days of work away from his croft in order to avoid destitution. In the second half of the 19th century, many crofters provided a substantial migrant workforce, especially for lowland farms.

Modern stack of drying pattern-laid machine-cut peat turfs in Ness, the Outer Hebrides (2007). Traditional crofting involved heavy labour to make hand-cut turfs using wood-handled metal peat-cutters with a blade set at 90 degrees (a tushkar).

Crofting communities in the period 1846–56 were badly hit by the Highland Potato Famine. The small arable plots had meant that the potato was an essential crop, due to its high productivity. The arrival of potato blight (and the collapse of the kelp industry a few years before) made some crofting communities inviable. This gave rise to the second phase of the Highland Clearances, when many tenants left the Highlands, often emigrating.[5]: 45–49  In 1852, in response to the poverty in the Highlands, Sir Charles Trevelyan founded the Highland and Island Emigration Society, designed to save poor families from starvation by emigration to Australia.

In 1883, the Napier Commission was established. Though its recommendations were not accepted, the problem of poverty and insecurity of tenure in the Highlands was investigated. Consequent on this, the first Scottish crofting legislation of 1886 was enacted.

History 1886 onwards

The Crofters' Holdings (Scotland) Act 1886 (49 & 50 Vict. c. 29) provided for security of tenure, a key issue as most crofters remain tenants.[9] The Act encouraged tenants to improve the land under their control, as it ensured that the control could be transferred within families and passed to future generations.[10]

Crofters were given the right to purchase their individual crofts in 1976. In 2003, as part of the Land Reform Act, crofting community bodies were provided with the right to purchase eligible croft land associated with the local crofting community.

In 1974 the Laidhay Croft Museum near Dunbeath in Caithness was opened to preserve and enhance a two hundred year old thatched crofting longhouse with its agricultural buildings (barn and stables). The home is fully furnished and there are displayed farm and stable equipment.[11]

In 2018 a section of the Sutherland Estate was bought out by a crofting community initiative,  Garbh Allt Community Initiative Estate. The area amounted to 1,214 hectares (3,000 acres) of land and included the crofting townships of Gartymore, Portgower, Marrel and West Helmsdale.[12] The £250,000 purchase money was made available in the form of two major contributions. These were: £273,000 from the Scottish government funded Scottish Land Fund; and £29,918 Beatrice Partnership Fund (a body connected to Beatrice windfarm in the Outer Moray Firth).[13] The transfer of ownership was in favour of crofters, some of whom were descendants of people removed from the Sutherland Estate two centuries previously.[14]

Statutory codes

Statutes

A key feature of crofting tenure is the highly developed network of legislation that has evolved since 1886. Crofting has been established and regulated in accordance with a series of statutes that have varied over time.[15] The following six statutes have been repealed: the Crofters Holdings (Scotland) Act 1886;[16] the Small Landholders (Scotland) Act 1911;[17] the Small Landholders and Agricultural Holdings (Scotland) Act 1931;[18] the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1955;[19] the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1961;[20] and the Crofting Reform (Scotland) Act 1976.[21] In 1993 there was a consolidation of the legislation into the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993.[22]

As of 2023,^[update] the following four statutes together comprise the code of legislation applicable to crofting: the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993; the Crofting Reform etc. Act 2007;[23] the Crofting Reform (Scotland) Act 2010;[24] the Crofting (Amendment) (Scotland) Act 2013.[25]

Proposals for law reform

The Scottish government, due to the acknowledged complexity of the statutory codes, has a public consultation open until 2 September 2024 as to possible ways of simplifying the law.[26]

The Crofting Register

The Crofting Register is a public record available for consultation for free. It is kept by the Keeper of the Registers of Scotland. As at 12 September 2023 there were 9288 registered crofts and 335 registered common grazings.[27] Registration can be voluntary but is compulsory in some circumstances. The Keeper offers online guidance in the form of a list as to events that trigger a mandatory registration.[28] Registered boundaries of crofts are shown on a map and they are definitive.[29] First registration may give rise to boundary disputes. The Scottish Land Court will determine the boundary and in the case of insufficient evidence has the power to fix the boundary where it thinks is appropriate.[30]

Crofting terms and management

A crofting tenancy is one from year to year but it carries security of tenure under the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993 and in practice may therefore continue indefinitely whilst the tenant fulfils the terms of the tenancy. This reflects the basic protection granted in 1886. Other retained key features are now also contained in the consolidation of the 1993 Act. These are a right to compensation for improvements to the land, the right to pay a fair rent, and the right of bequest of the tenancy to a spouse or his family's next generation.[31][15]

A valid crofting agreement can only be made with the prior consent of the Crofting Commission.[32] Croft tenants are subject to the statutory conditions of tenure contained in section 5 and Schedule 2 of the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993. Additionally, since 2010 they are subject to the statutory duties.[33] These apply to all tenancies whether held under a written agreement or an oral agreement. The written terms are invalid in so far as they are inconsistent with the statutory provisions.[34] Grazings regulations prevail over the terms of a tenancy agreement.[35] These are regulations created by the crofters to manage their common grazings. The Scottish Government offers Guidance and a Regulations template to assist in the creation of rules. The template draft has been approved by the Crofting Commission.[36] As of 12 June 2023 applications can be made online to the Crofting Commission in respect of assignations, decroftings, divisions and sublets.[37]

A person taking an interest from the landlord takes subject to the rights of the crofter. In a case where almost a century had elapsed since the creation of an interest by the landlord but where there had been no formal resumption by permission obtained from the commission or the Scottish Land Court, the tenant was able to reclaim as part of the croft land that had been fenced off and supposedly taken away by such a transaction.[38]

Requirements

Tenants and owner-occupier crofters are required to comply with a range of duties specified in sections 5AA to 5C and 19C of the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993 as amended. There is a duty to be ordinarily resident within 32 km of the croft. If the croft is the sole dwelling and the crofter's family are residents while the croft is away this would probably be accepted as ordinarily resident. Other circumstances involving other places of residence would require to be assessed individually. In addition to the duty of residential tenants and owner-occupiers crofters are required to ensure the croft is cultivated, maintained and not neglected or misused.[39]

Practice

Characteristics of crofting

Crofting is a traditional social system in Scotland defined by small-scale food production. Crofting is characterised by its common working communities, or "townships". Individual crofts are typically established on 2–5 hectares (5–12+1⁄2 acres) of in-bye[40] for better quality forage, arable and vegetable production. Each township manages poorer-quality hill ground as common grazing for cattle and sheep.[41]

From the early days, certain improvements were done to render land more amenable to cultivation. In particular, where the ground was heavy peat, the creation of ditches (and their regular maintenance) was essential. A feature probably special to crofting practice was the establishing of Lazy Beds (Gaelic: fiannegan). These were areas where turfs had been cut so two layers of turf lay on top of one another. Seaweed or kelp could be spread in between these layers to fertilise the soil. This left lower areas around the beds that could then act as drainage conduits.[8]

Land use in the crofting counties is constrained by climate, soils, and topography. Since the late 20th century, the government has classified virtually all of the agricultural land in the Highlands and Islands as Severely Disadvantaged, under the terms of the Less Favoured Area (LFA) Directive, yet these areas reported in 2008-9 receiving the lowest LFA payments.[42] Most crofters cannot survive economically by crofting agriculture alone, and they pursue a number of other activities to earn their livelihood.[43]

The underlying potential of the crofting areas to produce a diverse local landscape and a more satisfactory diet for local people can be explored by analysis taking the agricultural values and practices of the pre-capitalist clan system in order to critique the view that the current Less Favoured Areas are intrinsically poorer.[44] On that basis, "traditional" landscape and livestock-dominated practices are no more than the outcome of market dependency and should not be regarded as the inevitable measure of the potential of the land.

Economic significance

Despite its challenges, crofting is important to the Highlands and Islands. In 2014–2015 there were 19,422 crofts, with 15,388 crofters.[45] Some crofters have the tenancy of more than one croft, and in-croft absenteeism means that tenancies are held but crofts are not farmed. About 33,000 family members lived in crofting households,[45] or around 10% of the population of the Highlands and Islands. Crofting households represented around 30% of those in the rural areas of the Highlands, and up to 65% of households in Shetland, the Western Isles, and Skye. There were 770,000 hectares under crofting tenure, roughly 25% of the agricultural land area in the Crofting Counties. Crofters held around 20% of all beef cattle (120,000 head) and 45% of breeding ewes (1.5 million sheep).[46]

Regulatory supervision

Crofting generally is regulated by the Crofting Commission, a public body of the Scottish Government. The activities of the Crofting Commission are regularly publicly reported. Section 51 of the Crofting Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 requires the Scottish Ministers to report to the Scottish Parliament on the economic condition of crofting and on steps taken by the Government and by the Crofting Commission to support crofting. The 2019-2022 Report is the most recent.[47] The Crofting Commission in the Scottish Government Audit Scotland Crofting Commission Report 2020/2021 were considered as “falling below the standards expected of a public body in Scotland.”[48] Remedial steps were consequently taken. The commission is bound by the Crofting Commission Model Code of Conduct.[49] There is a scheme of delegation governing the handling of crofting matters.[50]

There are as at 2024 nine Commissioners. Six are elected by crofters, and the remaining three are appointed by the Scottish Government. The names of the Commissioners, alongside detailed statements by way of declarations of interests are available online.[51] The commission has its own support staff, and its main office is at Great Glen House, Leachkin Road, Inverness IV3 8NW. The staff is of approximately 70 civil servants with their Chief Executive appointed by the Scottish Ministers after discussion with the Commission Convenor.[52]

Subsidies

Crofters may claim Basic Payment Scheme subsidy, which is administered by the Scottish Government, Rural Payments and Services.[53]

Organisations of crofters

All crofters may join the Scottish Crofting Federation. In 2024 a support network for young crofters, the Western Isles Young Crofters, was founded to develop contacts and skills.[54]

Gaelic Language

Historically, crofting has been linked to the Scottish Gaelic language.[55] The Scottish Government supports the Gaelic language in the Gaelic Language Plan. The plan for 2022-2027 derives from the Gaelic Language (Scotland) Act 2005.[56] In relation to crofting, the Scottish Land Court must accommodate the Scottish Gaelic language including by having a Gaelic-speaking member of the Court.[57] Lord Minginish (Chairman of the Scottish Land Court 2014–2022) continues to hold office as a Gaelic-speaking member of the Court.[58] There are provisions to ensure that at all times at least one member of the Crofting Commission (whether elected or appointed) is a Gaelic language speaker.[59]

Case Reports

Reports of crofting litigation are a resource designed for lawyers that gives detailed information as to the families and the farms featured in the narrative. Since 1912 crofting cases in the Scottish Land Court have been reported, and are available. They are scattered in several series and locations.[60] Where such cases are dealt with on appeal to the Court of Session, they can be traced online.[61]

Gallery

Crofting landscapes show great beauty but also the remote, harsh and unyielding nature of the terrain. Often historically combined with fishing or the exploitation of peat, potash, or seaweed, agriculture operates on an uneconomic scale. Consequently, other industries connected to wool such as weaving or knitting, or to distillery products such as whisky and gin have developed. In more recent times, wind-farming has created some additional financial support. Features of crofting townships include shared grazing areas.

• 
  Port Duntulm (2015) on the Island of Skye in the Inner Hebrides. Duntulm is a crofting township. Sheep can be seen in the distance, held in stone-walled enclosures.
• 
  The coast south of Duntulm (1986) where barren high land is broken at lower level by farmable areas. The beach is bouldered. Housing is limited.
• 
  Croft in Upper Ardelve, a Highland settlement on Loch Alsh (2007). Image shows farmhouse behind a modest livestock shed. Cows graze the rear fields.
• 
  Crofting land of Fair Isle (1974). Image taken in August shows hay stacked in traditional stooks ready to be gathered and kept to feed livestock in the winter months.
• 
  Boreraig Burn by Boreraig, a crofting town NW of Dunvegan on Skye (2008). Image shows the rough quality of land used for cattle grazing.
• 
  Crofting community in Ormiscaig by Loch Ewe, Wester Ross in the NW Highlands (1972). The layout and whitewash appearance of houses is characteristic of these settlements.
• 
  Garrabost on the north coast of the Eye Peninsula, Isle of Lewis, Outer Hebrides (2007). Image shows complicated fencing patterns necessary on crofting land; modern or modernised buildings in traditional design.
• 
  Taobh Tuath on the Island of Harris in the Outer Hebrides (2001). Image shows crofting settlement in relatively protected lower areas. Harris is famous for its tweed weaving industry.
• 
  Ruined buildings (stone walls or foundations) are commonly seen in crofting areas. These are in the settlement of Boreraig, Skye which was cleared in 1853 and are probably remains of one of the houses that was abandoned at that time.[62]
• 
  Laidhay Croft Museum (2011) displays a thatched longhouse with its contents and nineteenth century farm equipment.

See also

• Agriculture and agronomy portal
• Agriculture in Scotland
• Croft
• Crofters Holdings (Scotland) Act 1886
• Highland Clearances
• Highland and Island Emigration Society
• Highland Potato Famine

References

1. Chambers's encyclopaedia: a dictionary of universal knowledge for the people. Vol. 3 (revised ed.). W. and R. Chambers. 1901. p. 575. Retrieved 1 August 2009.
2. "Farmers & Crofting". Manx National Heritage. Retrieved 4 August 2011.
3. "crofting scotland sheep - Google Search". www.google.ca. Retrieved 20 March 2016.
4. Collins Encyclopedia of Scotland (revised ed.). edited by John Keay and Julia Keay. 2000. pp. 205–206. ISBN 9780007103539. Retrieved 1 March 2013.
5. Devine, T M (1994). Clanship to Crofters' War: The social transformation of the Scottish Highlands (2013 ed.). Manchester University Press. ISBN 978-0-7190-9076-9.
6. Dodgshon, Robert A. (1998). From Chiefs to Landlords: Social and Economic Change in the Western Highlands and Islands, c.1493–1820. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. ISBN 0-7486-1034-0.
7. Lynn Abrams (2005). Myth and Materiality in a Woman's World: Shetland 1800–2000. Manchester University Press. ISBN 0719065925. As the nineteenth-century visitors correctly observed, croft work was hard, back-breaking work which yielded a subsistence living at best. The small agricultural holdings tenanted by most rural Shetlanders in the nineteenth century consisted of a dwelling, a small area of arable or cultivable ground which, while runrig was still practised, could be scattered and fragmented around
8. "The Crofting Calendar". Darach Social Croft. 26 April 2020. Retrieved 14 September 2023.
9. "Crofters Holdings (Scotland) Act 1886". Legislation.gov.uk.
10. McAllister, Angus (26 February 2013). Scottish Law of Leases. A&C Black. ISBN 9781847665669.
11. "Laidhay Croft Museum, 200 Year Old Farm Croft | Caithness, Scotland". www.caithnessandsutherland.com. Retrieved 5 September 2023.
12. "Crofting townships near Helmsdale in community ownership". BBC News. 14 June 2018. Retrieved 3 September 2023.
13. "Community to buy out 3,000 acres in Sutherland". BBC News. 19 June 2017. Retrieved 3 September 2023.
14. "Reversing the Clearances bit by bit". BBC News. 13 August 2017. Retrieved 3 September 2023.
15. Derek Flyn; Keith Graham Crofting Law (First Edition) Edinburgh University Press (2017) ISBN 978-1904968313
16. Contents legislation.gov.uk Retrieved 3 September 2023
17. Contents legislation.gov.uk Retrieved 3 September 2023
18. Contents legislation.gov.uk Retrieved 3 September 2023
19. Contents legislation.gov.uk Retrieved 3 September 2023
20. Contents legislation.gov.uk Retrieved 3 September 2023
21. Contents legislation.gov.uk Retrieved 3 September 2023
22. Contents legislation.gov.uk Retrieved 3 September 2023
23. Contents legislation.gov.uk Retrieved 3 September 2023
24. Contents legislation.gov.uk Retrieved 3 September 2023
25. Contents legislation.gov.uk Retrieved 3 September 2023
26. "Crofting law reform proposals 2024: consultation". www.gov.scot. Retrieved 19 August 2024.
27. "Crofting Register". www.crofts.ros.gov.uk. Retrieved 12 September 2023.
28. "Who should register, and when". RoS Knowledge Base. Retrieved 12 September 2023.
29. Section 3ZA(2)(b) of the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993, added by the Crofting Reform (Scotland) Act 2010
30. Section 53A of the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993, added by section 18 of the Crofting Reform etc Act 2007
31. See under "the Act" in article Crofters Holdings (Scotland) Act 1886
32. Section 23(3) of the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993
33. Contained in sections 5AA, 5B and 5C of the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993
34. Section 5 of the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993
35. Section 49(8) of the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993
36. "Regulated Commons Grazings | Crofting Commission". www.crofting.scotland.gov.uk. Retrieved 12 September 2023.
37. "News | Crofting Commission". www.crofting.scotland.gov.uk. Retrieved 12 September 2023.
38. Smith v Murray 1990 SLCR 90; [1990] 4 WLUK 205; [1991] C.L.Y. 5707
39. "FAQ | Crofting Commission". www.crofting.scotland.gov.uk.
40. Pertaining to the direction towards the house.
41. MacColl, Allan W. (1 January 2006). Land, Faith and the Crofting Community: Christianity and Social Criticism in the Highlands of Scotland, 1843-1893. Edinburgh University Press. ISBN 9780748623822.
42. The review of the less favoured areas scheme: 13th report of session 2008-09, report with evidence. The Stationery Office. 4 June 2009. ISBN 9780108444357.
43. Byron, Reginald; Hutson, John (1 August 1999). Local enterprises on the North Atlantic margin: selected contributions to the Fourteenth International Seminar on Marginal Regions. Ashgate. ISBN 9781840149326.
44. Elise Wach (2021) Market Dependency as Prohibitive of Agroecology and Food Sovereignty—A Case Study of the Agrarian Transition in the Scottish Highlands Sustainability 2021, 13(4), 1927 Retrieved 15 September 2023
45. "Crofting facts and figures". Crofting Commission. Retrieved 29 April 2016.
46. Doogan, John; Girvan, Edith (1 January 2004). Changing life in Scotland and Britain: 1830s-1930s. Heinemann. ISBN 9780435326920.
47. Scottish Government Report to Parliament: Economic Condition of Crofting 2019 - 2022 (16 December 2022) ISBN 9781805253860 Retrieved 2 September 2023
48. Paragraph 5, page 3, Scottish Government Audit Scotland Crofting Commission Report 2020/2021 https://audit.scot/uploads/docs/report/2021/aar_2021_crofting_commission_0.pdf Retrieved 1 October 2024
49. Crofting Commission Model Code of Conduct, Version 2 dated 2023 https://crofting.scotland.gov.uk/userfiles/file/board_meetings/code-of-conduct-for-board-members-2023.pdf Retrieved 1 October 2024
50. CROFTING COMMISSION’S FUNCTIONS AND DECISIONS: SCHEME OF DELEGATION (Updated January 2024) https://www.crofting.scotland.gov.uk/userfiles/file/act_and_policy/scheme-of-delegation-240111.pdf?d=15/01/2024%2017:24:26 Retrieved 1 October 2024
51. Commission, Crofting. "Meet the Commissioners | Crofting Commission". www.crofting.scotland.gov.uk. Retrieved 1 October 2024.
52. Page 20 para 26.1.3 of the 2019-2022 Report of the Scottish Ministers https://www.gov.scot/publications/economic-condition-crofting-2019-2022/pages/20/ Retrieved 1 October 2024
53. "Support for farmers and crofters". www.ruralpayments.org. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
54. "New Western Isles group to support young crofters". www.bbc.com. Retrieved 27 July 2024.
55. MacKinnon, Iain. (2008). Crofters: indigenous people of the Highlands and Islands Scottish Crofting Foundation Retrieved 2 September 2023
56. Gaelic language plan 2022 to 2027 The Scottish Government (10 October 2022) Retrieved 2 September 2023
57. Section 1(5) of the Scottish Land Court Act 1993
58. "The Scottish Land Court". www.scottish-land-court.org.uk. Retrieved 2 September 2023.
59. Crofting Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 Schedule 1, para 4. Explained at Explanatory Notes Retrieved 2 September 2023
60. "Reported decisions [Decisions: The Scottish Land Court]". www.scottish-land-court.org.uk. Retrieved 3 September 2023.
61. "About Judgments". www.scotcourts.gov.uk. Retrieved 3 September 2023.
62. Archibald Geikie Scottish Reminiscences James Maclehose and Sons, Glasgow (1908) at Chapter VIII page 226 Project Gutenberg https://www.gutenberg.org/files/63074/63074-h/63074-h.htm#CHAPTER_VIII Retrieved 6 September 2023 Boreraig was cleared at the same time as Suishnish (3 km/ under 2 miles away) at the behest of Lord Macdonald's trustees in 1853

External links

• The Crofting Commission
• The Crofting Register
• The Scottish Crofting Federation
• The Scottish Land Court