Catch-22 (logic)

A flowchart showing Joseph Heller's original Catch-22

A catch-22 is a paradoxical situation from which an individual cannot escape because of contradictory rules or limitations.[1] The term was coined by Joseph Heller, who used it in his 1961 novel Catch-22.

Catch-22s often result from rules, regulations, or procedures that an individual is subject to, but has no control over, because to fight the rule is to accept it. Another example is a situation in which someone is in need of something that can only be had by not being in need of it (e.g. the only way to qualify for a loan is to prove to the bank that you do not need a loan). One connotation of the term is that the creators of the "catch-22" situation have created arbitrary rules in order to justify and conceal their own abuse of power.

Origin and meaning

Joseph Heller coined the term in his 1961 novel Catch-22, which describes absurd bureaucratic constraints on soldiers in World War II. The term is introduced by the character Doc Daneeka, an army psychiatrist who invokes "Catch-22" to explain why any pilot requesting mental evaluation for insanity—hoping to be found not sane enough to fly and thereby escape dangerous missions—demonstrates his own sanity in creating the request and thus cannot be declared insane. This phrase also means a dilemma or difficult circumstance from which there is no escape because of mutually conflicting or dependent conditions.[2]

"You mean there's a catch?"

"Sure there's a catch," Doc Daneeka replied. "Catch-22. Anyone who wants to get out of combat duty isn't really crazy."

There was only one catch and that was Catch-22, which specified that a concern for one's own safety in the face of dangers that were real and immediate was the process of a rational mind. Orr was crazy and could be grounded. All he had to do was ask; and as soon as he did, he would no longer be crazy and would have to fly more missions. Orr would be crazy to fly more missions and sane if he didn't, but if he was sane, he had to fly them. If he flew them, he was crazy and didn't have to; but if he didn't want to, he was sane and had to. Yossarian was moved very deeply by the absolute simplicity of this clause of Catch-22 and let out a respectful whistle.

Different formulations of "Catch-22" appear throughout the novel. The term is applied to various loopholes and quirks of the military system, always with the implication that rules are inaccessible to and slanted against those lower in the hierarchy. In chapter 6, Yossarian (the protagonist) is told that Catch-22 requires him to do anything his commanding officer tells him to do, regardless of whether these orders contradict orders from the officer's superiors.[3]

In a final episode, Catch-22 is described to Yossarian by an old woman recounting an act of violence by soldiers:[4][5]

"Catch-22 says they have a right to do anything we can't stop them from doing."

"What the hell are you talking about?" Yossarian shouted at her in bewildered, furious protest. "How did you know it was Catch-22? Who the hell told you it was Catch-22?"

"The soldiers with the hard white hats and clubs. The girls were crying. 'Did we do anything wrong?' they said. The men said no and pushed them away out the door with the ends of their clubs. 'Then why are you chasing us out?' the girls said. 'Catch-22,' the men said. All they kept saying was 'Catch-22, Catch-22.' What does it mean, Catch-22? What is Catch-22?"

"Didn't they show it to you?" Yossarian demanded, stamping about in anger and distress. "Didn't you even make them read it?"

"They don't have to show us Catch-22," the old woman answered. "The law says they don't have to."

"What law says they don't have to?"

"Catch-22."

According to literature professor Ian Gregson, the old woman's narrative defines "Catch-22" more directly as the "brutal operation of power", stripping away the "bogus sophistication" of the earlier scenarios.[6]

Other appearances in the novel

Besides referring to an unsolvable logical dilemma, Catch-22 is invoked to explain or justify the military bureaucracy. For example, in the first chapter, it requires Yossarian to sign his name to letters he censors while he is confined to a hospital bed. One clause mentioned in chapter 10 closes a loophole in promotions, which one private had been exploiting to reattain the attractive rank of private first class after any promotion. Through courts-martial for going AWOL, he would be busted in rank back to private, but Catch-22 limited the number of times he could do this before being sent to the stockade.

At another point in the book, a prostitute explains to Yossarian that she cannot marry him because he is crazy, and she will never marry a crazy man. She considers any man crazy who would marry a woman who is not a virgin. This closed logic loop clearly illustrated Catch-22 because by her logic, all men who refuse to marry her are sane and thus she would consider marriage; but as soon as a man agrees to marry her, he becomes crazy for wanting to marry a non-virgin, and is instantly rejected.

At one point, Captain Black attempts to press Milo into depriving Major Major of food as a consequence of not signing a loyalty oath that Major Major was never given an opportunity to sign in the first place. Captain Black asks Milo, "You're not against Catch-22, are you?"

In chapter 40, Catch-22 forces Colonels Korn and Cathcart to promote Yossarian to Major and ground him rather than simply sending him home. They fear that if they do not, others will refuse to fly, just as Yossarian did.

Significance of the number 22

Heller originally wanted to call the phrase (and hence, the book) by other numbers, but he and his publishers eventually settled on 22. The number has no particular significance; it was chosen more or less for euphony. The title was originally Catch-18, but Heller changed it after the popular Mila 18 was published a short time beforehand.[7][8]

Usage

The term "catch-22" has filtered into common usage in the English language. In a 1975 interview, Heller said the term would not translate well into other languages.[8]

James E. Combs and Dan D. Nimmo suggest that the idea of a "catch-22" has gained popular currency because so many people in modern society are exposed to frustrating bureaucratic logic. They write of the rules of high school and colleges that:

This bogus democracy that can be overruled by arbitrary fiat is perhaps a citizen's first encounter with organizations that may profess 'open' and libertarian values, but in fact are closed and hierarchical systems. Catch-22 is an organizational assumption, an unwritten law of informal power that exempts the organization from responsibility and accountability, and puts the individual in the absurd position of being excepted for the convenience or unknown purposes of the organization.[5]

Along with George Orwell's "doublethink", "catch-22" has become one of the best-recognized ways to describe the predicament of being trapped by contradictory rules.[9]

A significant type of definition of alternative medicine has been termed a catch-22. In a 1998 editorial co-authored by Marcia Angell, a former editor of the New England Journal of Medicine, argued that:

It is time for the scientific community to stop giving alternative medicine a free ride. There cannot be two kinds of medicine—conventional and alternative. There is only medicine that has been adequately tested and medicine that has not, medicine that works and medicine that may or may not work. Once a treatment has been tested rigorously, it no longer matters whether it was considered alternative at the outset. If it is found to be reasonably safe and effective, it will be accepted. But assertions, speculation, and testimonials do not substitute for evidence. Alternative treatments should be subjected to scientific testing no less rigorous than that required for conventional treatments.[10]

This definition has been described by Robert L. Park as a logical catch-22 which ensures that any complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) method which is proven to work "would no longer be CAM, it would simply be medicine."[11]

U.S. Circuit Judge Don Willett referred to qualified immunity, which requires a violation of constitutional rights to have been previously established in order for a victim to claim damages, as a catch-22: "Section 1983 meets Catch-22. Important constitutional questions go unanswered precisely because those questions are yet unanswered. Courts then rely on that judicial silence to conclude there's no equivalent case on the books. No precedent = no clearly established law = no liability. An Escherian Stairwell. Heads government wins, tails plaintiff loses."[12][13]

Logic

The archetypal catch-22, as formulated by Joseph Heller, involves the case of John Yossarian, a U.S. Army Air Forces bombardier, who wishes to be grounded from combat flight. This will only happen if he is evaluated by the squadron's flight surgeon and found "unfit to fly". "Unfit" would be any pilot who is willing to fly such dangerous missions, as one would have to be mad to volunteer for possible death. However, to be evaluated, he must request the evaluation, an act that is considered sufficient proof for being declared sane. These conditions make it impossible to be declared "unfit".

The "Catch-22" is that "anyone who wants to get out of combat duty isn't really crazy".[14] Hence, pilots who request a mental fitness evaluation are sane, and therefore must fly in combat. At the same time, if an evaluation is not requested by the pilot, he will never receive one and thus can never be found insane, meaning he must also fly in combat.

Therefore, Catch-22 ensures that no pilot can ever be grounded for being insane even if he is.

A logical formulation of this situation is:

1. For a person to be excused from flying on the grounds of insanity (E), he must both be insane (I) and have requested an evaluation (R). (premise)
2. An insane person (I) does not request an evaluation (¬R) because he does not realize he is insane. (premise)
3. Either a person is not insane (¬I) or does not request an evaluation (¬R). (2. and material implication)
4. No person can be both insane (I) and request an evaluation (R). (3. and De Morgan's laws)
5. Therefore, no person can be excused from flying on the grounds of insanity (¬E) because no person can be both insane and have requested an evaluation. (4., 1. and modus tollens)

The philosopher Laurence Goldstein argues that the "airman's dilemma" is logically not even a condition that is true under no circumstances; it is a "vacuous biconditional" that is ultimately meaningless. Goldstein writes:[15]

The catch is this: what looks like a statement of the conditions under which an airman can be excused flying dangerous missions reduces not to the statement

(i) 'An airman can be excused flying dangerous missions if and only if Cont' (where 'Cont' is a contradiction)

(which could be a mean way of disguising an unpleasant truth), but to the worthlessly empty announcement

(ii) 'An airman can be excused flying dangerous missions if and only if it is not the case that an airman can be excused flying dangerous missions'

If the catch were (i), that would not be so bad—an airman would at least be able to discover that under no circumstances could he avoid combat duty. But Catch-22 is worse—a welter of words that amounts to nothing; it is without content, it conveys no information at all.

See also

References

  1. ^ Largest Idioms Dictionary, The Idioms. "Catch 22 meaning". Theidioms.com. Retrieved 12 May 2020.
  2. ^ Beidler, Philip D. (1995). Scriptures for a Generation: What We Were Reading in the '60s. University of Georgia Press. p. 162. ISBN 978-0820317878. It is Catch-22: Dr. Daneeka explains how anybody who is crazy has a right to ask to be removed from combat status but how anybody who asks is revealing a rational concern for his own safety that makes him not crazy;
  3. ^ Margot A. Henriksen, Dr. Strangelove's America: Society and Culture in the Atomic Age; University of California Press, 1997; ISBN 0-520-08310-5; p. 250.
  4. ^ "Joseph Heller", Gale Encyclopedia of Biography, accessed via Answers.com, 16 August 2013.
  5. ^ a b James E. Combs & Dan D. Nimmo, The Comedy of Democracy; Westport, CT: Praeger (Greenwood Publishing Group), 1996; ISBN 0-275-94979-6; p. 152.
  6. ^ Ian Gregson, Character and Satire in Post War Fiction; London: Continuum, 2006; ISBN 978-1441130006; p. 38.
  7. ^ Aldridge, John W. (1986-10-26). "The Loony Horror of it All – 'Catch-22' Turns 25". The New York Times. p. Section 7, Page 3, Column 1. Retrieved 2011-01-09.
  8. ^ a b "A classic by any other name", The Telegraph, 18 November 2007.
  9. ^ Richard King, "22 Going on 50: Half a century later, the world is full of Catch-22s"; The Smart Set, 20 July 2011.
  10. ^ Angell, M.; et al. (1998). "Alternative medicine – The risks of untested and unregulated remedies". New England Journal of Medicine. 339 (12): 839–841. CiteSeerX 10.1.1.694.9581. doi:10.1056/NEJM199809173391210. PMID 9738094.
  11. ^ Park, Robert L., Alternative Medicine: The Clinton Commission's Catch-22. Archived 2016-03-04 at the Wayback Machine
  12. ^ Ford, Matt (September 12, 2018). "Should Cops Be Immune From Lawsuits?". The New Republic. Archived from the original on November 26, 2019. Retrieved November 25, 2019.
  13. ^ Zadeh v. Robinson, 902 F.3d 483 (5th Cir. 2018).
  14. ^ Heller, Joseph (1999). Catch-22: A Novel. Simon and Schuster. p. 52. ISBN 978-0-684-86513-3. Retrieved 2011-01-09.
  15. ^ Goldstein, Laurence (2004). "The Barber, Russell's paradox, catch-22, God, contradiction and more: A defence of a Wittgensteinian conception of contradiction". In Priest, Graham; Beall, J. C.; Armour-Garb, Bradley (eds.). The law of non-contradiction: new philosophical essays. Oxford University Press. Retrieved June 25, 2023.

Read other articles:

Pour les articles homonymes, voir Müller. Herta Müller Herta Müller en 2012. Données clés Naissance 17 août 1953 (70 ans) Nițchidorf (Roumanie) Activité principale Romancière, essayiste, poète Distinctions Prix Nobel de littérature (2009) Auteur Langue d’écriture allemand, roumain Mouvement Weltliteratur Genres Roman, essai, poésie modifier Herta Müller (née le 17 août 1953 à Nițchidorf) est une romancière gérmano-roumaine, douzième femme lauréate du prix Nobel de li…

American football player (born 1986) American football player Dominique Rodgers-CromartieRodgers-Cromartie with the Washington Redskins in 2019No. 29, 23, 45, 21, 41Position:CornerbackPersonal informationBorn: (1986-04-07) April 7, 1986 (age 38)Bradenton, Florida, U.S.Height:6 ft 2 in (1.88 m)Weight:205 lb (93 kg)Career informationHigh school:Lakewood Ranch (Bradenton, Florida)College:Tennessee State (2004–2007)NFL draft:2008 / Round: 1 / Pick: …

Министерство природных ресурсов и экологии Российской Федерациисокращённо: Минприроды России Общая информация Страна  Россия Юрисдикция Россия Дата создания 12 мая 2008 Предшественники Министерство природных ресурсов Российской Федерации (1996—1998)Министерство охраны о…

Bilateral relationsMauritania – United States relations Mauritania United States Mauritania – United States relations are bilateral relations between Mauritania and the United States. Overview This section does not cite any sources. Please help improve this section by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. (December 2023) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Embassy of Mauritania in Washington, D.C. After Mauritania gained independence …

Державний комітет телебачення і радіомовлення України (Держкомтелерадіо) Приміщення комітетуЗагальна інформаціяКраїна  УкраїнаДата створення 2003Керівне відомство Кабінет Міністрів УкраїниРічний бюджет 1 964 898 500 ₴[1]Голова Олег НаливайкоПідвідомчі орг…

2016年美國總統選舉 ← 2012 2016年11月8日 2020 → 538個選舉人團席位獲勝需270票民意調查投票率55.7%[1][2] ▲ 0.8 %   获提名人 唐納·川普 希拉莉·克林頓 政党 共和黨 民主党 家鄉州 紐約州 紐約州 竞选搭档 迈克·彭斯 蒂姆·凱恩 选举人票 304[3][4][註 1] 227[5] 胜出州/省 30 + 緬-2 20 + DC 民選得票 62,984,828[6] 65,853,514[6] 得…

This is a list of airlines operating in Luxembourg as of 10 August 2005.[1] Scheduled airlines Airline Image IATA ICAO Callsign Commencedoperations Notes Luxair LG[2] LGL LUXAIR 1961 Charter airlines Airline Image IATA ICAO Callsign Commencedoperations Notes Global Jet Luxembourg SVW 2004 Luxaviation - LXA RED LION 2009[3] JetFly Aviation - JFA MOSQUITO 1999 Cargo airlines Airline Image IATA ICAO Callsign Commencedoperations Notes Cargolux CV[2] CLX CARGOLUX 1970 …

Nama ini merupakan sebuah nama Belanda; nama keluarganya adalah Van Raak, bukan Raak. Ronald van Raak Anggota Dewan PerwakilanMasa jabatan30 November 2006 – 31 Maret 2021Anggota SenatMasa jabatan10 Juni 2003 – 29 November 2006 Informasi pribadiLahirAntonius Adrianus Gerardus Maria van Raak30 Oktober 1969 (umur 54)Hilvarenbeek, BelandaKebangsaanBelandaPartai politikPartai SosialisHubunganMenikahTempat tinggalAmsterdamAlma materUniversitas Erasmus Rotterdam (Magistrat da…

本條目存在以下問題,請協助改善本條目或在討論頁針對議題發表看法。 此條目需要編修,以確保文法、用詞、语气、格式、標點等使用恰当。 (2013年8月6日)請按照校對指引,幫助编辑這個條目。(幫助、討論) 此條目剧情、虛構用語或人物介紹过长过细,需清理无关故事主轴的细节、用語和角色介紹。 (2020年10月6日)劇情、用語和人物介紹都只是用於了解故事主軸,輔助讀…

Artikel ini memiliki beberapa masalah. Tolong bantu memperbaikinya atau diskusikan masalah-masalah ini di halaman pembicaraannya. (Pelajari bagaimana dan kapan saat yang tepat untuk menghapus templat pesan ini) Kontributor utama artikel ini tampaknya memiliki hubungan dekat dengan subjek. Artikel ini mungkin perlu dirapikan agar mematuhi kebijakan konten Wikipedia, terutama dalam hal sudut pandang netral. Silakan dibahas lebih lanjut di halaman pembicaraan artikel ini. (Pelajari cara dan kapan s…

Jannatul Baqi graveyard in Medina, Saudi Arabia The destruction of heritage sites associated with early Islam is an ongoing phenomenon that has occurred mainly in the Hejaz region of western Saudi Arabia, particularly around the two holiest cities of Islam, Mecca and Medina.[1] The demolition has focused on mosques, burial sites, homes and historical locations associated with the Islamic prophet Muhammad, his companions, and many of the founding personalities of early Islamic history by …

Belforte Monferrato komune di Italia Tempat Negara berdaulatItaliaDaerah di ItaliaPiemonteProvinsi di ItaliaProvinsi Alessandria NegaraItalia Ibu kotaBelforte Monferrato PendudukTotal498  (2023 )GeografiLuas wilayah8,33 km² [convert: unit tak dikenal]Ketinggian233 m Berbatasan denganOvada Rossiglione Tagliolo Monferrato SejarahHari liburpatronal festival Santo pelindungKelahiran Maria Informasi tambahanKode pos15070 Zona waktuUTC+1 UTC+2 Kode telepon0143 ID ISTAT006014 Kode kadaster I…

  لمعانٍ أخرى، طالع صحن (توضيح). صحن مسجد بطهران الصحن أو الحوش هو ساحة مفتوحة في وسط المبنى.[1] ويكثر استخدام الصحن في الدول العربية ويعتبر من الخصائص المعمارية المميزة لها، ومنها انتشر إلى مناطق أخرى مثل إسبانيا. يعود استخدام الصحن إلى عصور كثيرة قبل الإسلام فقد وجد…

Professional practitioner of engineering and its subclasses For other uses, see Engineer (disambiguation). EngineerMechanical engineer Joel Steinkraus and systems engineer Farah Alibay (right) from NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory hold a full-scale mockup of Mars Cube OneOccupationNamesEngineerOccupation typeProfessionActivity sectorsApplied scienceDescriptionCompetenciesMathematics, science, design, analysis, critical thinking, engineering ethics, project management, engineering economics, creati…

Subspecies of mammals Arabian leopard Leopard at Ein Gedi, Israel Conservation status Critically Endangered  (IUCN 3.1)[1] Scientific classification Domain: Eukaryota Kingdom: Animalia Phylum: Chordata Class: Mammalia Order: Carnivora Suborder: Feliformia Family: Felidae Subfamily: Pantherinae Genus: Panthera Species: P. pardus Subspecies: P. p. nimr Trinomial name Panthera pardus nimr(Hemprich and Ehrenberg), 1833 Distribution of the Arabian leopard Synonyms P. p. jarvisl…

US railroad with cross harbor car float New York New Jersey Rail, LLCOverviewHeadquartersGreenville, Jersey City, New JerseyReporting markNYNJLocaleUpper New York BayDates of operation2006–PredecessorNew York Cross Harbor RailroadTechnicalTrack gauge4 ft 8+1⁄2 in (1,435 mm) standard gaugeLength4 miles (6 kilometers) (car float) 4.5 miles (7 kilometers) (trackage)OtherWebsitenynjr.com The 65th Street Yard in Brooklyn, refurbished in 1999 by the city of New York. Th…

Medical institutions in and around Vellore, Tamil Nadu Christian Medical College redirects here. For the college of same name in Ludhiana, India, see Christian Medical College, Ludhiana. Christian Medical CollegeMottoNot To Be Ministered Unto, But To MinisterTypePrivateEstablished1900; 124 years ago (1900)[1][2]Budget₹1,738 crore (US$210 million)[3]PrincipalSolomon Sathishkumar[4]DirectorVikram Mathews [4]Undergraduates401[3 …

This article relies largely or entirely on a single source. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please help improve this article by introducing citations to additional sources.Find sources: Serenade Bruch – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (May 2016) Max Bruch's Serenade in A minor, Op. 75 is a composition for violin and orchestra that was composed in Cologne in 1899.[1] Structure The work has four movements and take…

Questa voce sull'argomento centri abitati dell'Indonesia è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. MalangkotaKota Malang Malang – Veduta LocalizzazioneStato Indonesia Provincia Giava Orientale TerritorioCoordinate7°58′48″S 112°37′12″E7°58′48″S, 112°37′12″E (Malang) Altitudine476 m s.l.m. Superficie252,13 km² Abitanti820 243 (2010) Densità3 2…

Writer who analyzes food or restaurants This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Food critic – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (January 202…