Cabinet noir

1815 caricature of the cabinet noir, Bodleian Libraries

In France, the cabinet noir (French pronunciation: [kabinɛ nwaʁ]; French for "black room", also known as the "dark chamber" or "black chamber") was a government intelligence-gathering office, usually within a postal service, where correspondence between persons or entities was opened and read by government officials before being forwarded to its destination.[1] However, this had to be done with some sophistication, as it was considered undesirable if the subjects of the practice knew about it, and important "that the black chamber not interrupt the smooth running of the postal service."[2]

This practice had been in vogue since the establishment of postal and telegraphy services, and was frequently used by the ministers of Louis XIII and Louis XIV; but it was not until the reign of Louis XV that a separate office for this purpose was created. This was called the cabinet du secret des postes, or more popularly the cabinet noir. Although declaimed against at the time of the French Revolution, it was used both by the revolutionary leaders and by Napoleon.[3][4]

Nowadays, the term cabinet noir in the press regards aides to elected officials, especially around the President of France, or to candidates for elected office, who are tasked with finding sensitive information on political opponents and using that information for political purposes.[5]

Outside France

By the 1700s, cryptanalysis was becoming industrialized, with teams of government cryptanalysts working together to crack the most complex monoalphabetic ciphers. Each European power had its own so called black chamber, a nerve centre for deciphering messages and gathering intelligence. The most celebrated, disciplined and efficient was the Geheime Kabinettskanzlei in Vienna. It operated according to a strict timetable, because it was vital that its activities should not interrupt the smooth running of the postal service. Letters which were supposed to be delivered to embassies in Vienna were first routed via the black chamber, arriving at 7 am. Secretaries melted seals, and a team of stenographers worked in parallel to make copies of the letters. Within three hours the letters had been resealed and returned to the central post office to be delivered to their intended destination. As well as supplying the emperors of Austria with vital intelligence, the Viennese black chamber sold the information it harvested to other European powers. In 1774, for example, an arrangement was made with Abbot Georgel, the secretary in the French embassy, who had access to a biweekly package on information for 1,000 ducats.

A black chamber was also employed by Anthonie Heinsius, Grand pensionary of the Dutch Republic, during the War of the Spanish Succession under the direction of his private secretary Abel Tassin d'Alonne. They used the services of François Jaupain, the director-general of the postal system in the Southern Netherlands to intercept the diplomatic mail of France and its allies.[6]

In 1911, the Encyclopædia Britannica Eleventh Edition took the view that the cabinet noir had disappeared, but that the right to open letters in cases of emergency still appeared to be retained by the French government; and a similar right was occasionally exercised in England under the direction of a Secretary of State. In England, this power was frequently employed during the eighteenth century and was confirmed by the Post Office Act 1837; its most notorious use was, perhaps, the opening of Mazzini's letters in 1844.[3]

Such postal censorship became common during World War I. Governments claimed that the total war which was waged required such censorship to preserve the civilian population's morale from heart-breaking news up from the front. Whatever the justification, this meant that not a single letter sent from a soldier to his family escaped previous reading by a government official, destroying any notion of privacy or secrecy of correspondence. Post censorship was retained during the interwar period and afterwards, but without being done on such a massive scale.[7]

The US Trade Act of 2002 permits the opening of international mail to and from the United States by Customs[8] under the border search exception to the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution.[9] This practice has been criticised, including suggestions that it adds to the cost of conducting the Postal Service and can affect postage rates.[10] The USPS apparently informed Congress of criticism before it passed the legislation.[11] The Act does prohibit reading mail incidentally included in the package or its envelope when searching for contraband.[8] The Intelligence Authorization Act of 2004 has also been said to unconstitutionally permit the opening of domestic mail.[8]

See also

References

  1. ^ Dwyer, Philip (2014). Napoleon and Europe. Abingdon, UK: Routladge. p. 84. ISBN 978-0-5823-1837-3.
  2. ^ "Black Chamber". Everything2. 2001-01-14. Retrieved 2012-12-24.
  3. ^ a b Chisholm 1911.
  4. ^ Kent, Neil (2019-01-02). "The Secret World: A History of Intelligence". The RUSI Journal. 164 (1): 86–93. doi:10.1080/03071847.2019.1605039. ISSN 0307-1847. S2CID 151126570.
  5. ^ Hélène Combis; Abdelhak El Idrissi (2017-03-24). "De la gauche à la droite, les "cabinets noirs" de la Ve République" (in French). Radio France.
  6. ^ de Leeuw, Karl (1999). "The Black Chamber in the Dutch Republic during the War of the Spanish Succession and Its Aftermath, 1707-1715". The Historical Journal. 42 (1): 133–156. doi:10.1017/S0018246X98008292. JSTOR 3020898. S2CID 162387765.
  7. ^ Demm, Eberhard (29 March 2017). "Censorship". International Encyclopedia of the First World War (WW1). Archived from the original on 2014-10-14.
  8. ^ a b c "U.S. Customs Opening International Mail". Schneier.com. 16 January 2006.
  9. ^ "Feds Use Border Search Exception to Nab Pedophile". Volokh.com. 2006-08-29. Retrieved 2012-12-24.
  10. ^ mininggazette.com [permanent dead link‍]
  11. ^ "Minutes of the Mailers' Technical Advisory Committee". United States Postal Service. 2002-05-02. Archived from the original (Word document) on 2009-01-15. Retrieved 2012-12-24.

Sources