Following his junior year at Wheaton College in 2006, Studebaker was named a First-team All-American[4] and North Region Defensive Player of the year by D3Football.com.[5] He was also named College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin Defensive Player of the Year.[6] He led the conference with 17½ sacks (the most in the NCAA in 2006)[7] and 25½ tackles for loss.[8] Studebaker graduated from Wheaton College in May 2008 with a degree in Applied Health Sciences.[9]
Studebaker was a sixth round selection with the 203rd overall pick by the Philadelphia Eagles in the 2008 NFL draft.[10] He was waived by the Eagles on the last day of roster cuts on August 30, 2008[11] and subsequently re-signed on the team's practice squad.[12]
Kansas City Chiefs
Studebaker was signed off the Eagles' practice squad by the Kansas City Chiefs on November 19, 2008,[13] and played in his first career game against the Buffalo Bills on November 23, 2008. His first start was in Week 11 on November 22, 2009 against the Pittsburgh Steelers, in place of injured Mike Vrabel. In his first start, he intercepted Ben Roethlisberger twice, as the Chiefs won the game. On October 31, 2011 against the San Diego Chargers, Studebaker recovered an unlikely fumbled snap by quarterbackPhilip Rivers from amongst the scrum, likely aiding the Kansas City Chiefs in their improbable win that day by preventing the Chargers from scoring with just over a minute left in regulation.[14] Studebaker had 16 tackles, one fumble recovery, and one forced fumble at the end of the season.[15] While with the Chiefs, he was popularly known among fans as "The Student Baker."[16]
On April 1, 2013, the Chiefs released Studebaker.[17]
Jacksonville Jaguars
Studebaker was signed by the Jacksonville Jaguars on August 13, 2013.[18] He was released by the team on September 1, 2013.[19]
Indianapolis Colts (first stint)
On October 9, 2013, Studebaker signed with the Indianapolis Colts.[20] He played in 11 games in 2013.[15] In 2014, Studebaker played in 13 games, making one start.[15] He became a free agent at the end of the season.[21]
Tennessee Titans
On August 17, 2015, Studebaker signed with the Tennessee Titans.[22] He was released by the team on September 4.[23]
Indianapolis Colts (second stint)
On December 15, 2015, Studebaker was signed with the Colts.[24] He was released by the team on February 22, 2016.[25]