In late July 1992, Hardee Memorial Hospital filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection with the United States Bankruptcy Court in Tampa.[6][7] The Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection had nothing to do with the baby-swap incident.[8]
Also in July 1992, the only physician who worked at Hardee Memorial Hospital quit their job and the hospital closed later that month.[9]
On June 27, 2016, the hospital had a groundbreaking ceremony for a new 50,000-square-foot, 25 bed hospital for $32 million. It would have a 15 bed emergency department and extensive therapy rooms. It opened 2017, on U.S. Route 17 about 0.75 miles (1.21 km) to the northeast.[10][11]
On January 1, 2021, the United States government passed a law requiring all hospitals to have their chargemaster on its website.[17] In a 2022, survey most hospitals in Florida, including AdventHealth Wauchula, were found to have failed to comply with the new law;[17][18] the hospital came into full compliance with the law in February 2023.[19]
Baby-swap incident and aftermath
In December 1978, babies Arlena Twigg and Kimberly Michelle May, born at Hardee Memorial Hospital, were inadvertently switched, unknown to their parents at the time.[20]
In 1989, the Twiggs filed a lawsuit against Robert Mays of Sarasota, Florida to seek custody of Kimberly Mays; after almost a year they agreed to drop their custody lawsuit if a genetic test was done on Kimberly. Originally Robert Mays had refused to submit Kimberly to a genetic test.[24][25] When the genetic test was carried out on Robert and Kimberly by Johns Hopkins University, it found that Kimberly was, to 99.9 percent probability, the daughter of the Twiggs.[23][24][25]
In 1991, Hardee Memorial Hospital agreed to settle the lawsuit for $3.5 million to $7 million.[8][26][27]
Also in late August 1992, the hospital agreed to settle a lawsuit by Robert Mays and daughter Kimberly Mays for $6.6 million.[8][28]
The money would be paid out from the Florida Patient's Compensation Fund, which was created by Florida hospitals to pay for lawsuits by patients.[8]
In late August 1993, Kimberly Mays successfully divorced the Twiggs, when Circuit Judge Stephen Dakan refused to order her to see them.[29][30]
In late November 1993, the Twiggs asked for a criminal probe into the baby-swap.[31][32] They did this after Patsy Webb, a former nurses' aid from Hardee Memorial Hospital, had said that a physician told her to switch Arlena and Kimberly. And that she had refused the request of the physician and that the following day they had been switched.[33] Later Robert May had been investigated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, and took a polygraph test, which he passed.[31]
No criminal probe was planned, since the claim by Patsy Webb was considered a tall tale.[34] During the custody hearing for Kimberly, Webb said in court that she knew nothing of the switch.[33]
In March 1994, Kimberly Mays ran away from home and was found later by Sarasota police at the YMCA, she later moved in with the Twiggs.[35][36][37] In early May 1994, the Twiggs, Robert Mays and Kimberly were back in the courtroom of Circuit Judge Stephen Dakan. He overturned his August 1993 decision, granting both the Twiggs and Robert Mays guardianship of Kimberly.[38][39]
